9 ms·
Colliding neutron stars falsify some theories of gravity
- ianai 9y agoIt sounds more like a confirmation of GR. Mass-energy tells spacetime how to curve through gravity, and spacetime tells light where to travel.
- ffn 9y agoYes, the article even has a section where they straight up say "Einstein was right". The title of the article "Colliding neutron stars falsify some theories of gravity" is accurate, but the theories of gravity that it falsifies isn't the popular mainstream one (Einstein's) that, let's face it, we've all been secretly hoping to take down. Instead, it falsifies some of the new challenger (MOND) theories. I, for one, welcome our continuing Einsteinian Relativistic overlord theories of gravity (at least when it comes to dark matter)
- yourapostasy 9y ago> ...the popular mainstream one (Einstein's) that, let's face it, we've all been secretly hoping to take down. Please ELI5 what benefits follow from taking down the GR-based gravity theory?
- semi-extrinsic 9y agoFame, money, Nobel prize, etc...
- ianai 9y agoWell I for one hope there’s a loop hole for FTL. Absolutely all evidence currently points to c as a hard limit.
- snarfy 9y agoNot a loop hole, but possibly a worm hole.
- xelxebar 9y agoWell, in practice we can't really confirm a theory so much as "fail to reject" it. There's a zoo of gravitation theories out there and this new data weeds out some of them. The problem I see with the "confirms GR" language is that the new data also fails to reflect some of the MOND models, but are we going up say that it "confirms MOND" as well? That sounds really misleading to me.
- ianai 9y agoYou’re absolutely correct. I’m still really skeptical of dark matter. It just feels more like a massive black box of not understanding what’s going on than non-visible matter.
- SAI_Peregrinus 9y agoI'm not sure how most of the alternatives are any better. MOND is a massive black box of not understanding what's going on with gravity. Dark matter: Some sort (or sorts) of particle that interacts gravitationally. It can't interact via the strong or electromagnetic forces. If we're very lucky it interacts via the weak force as well and we'll be able to directly detect some, but there's a good chance that it doesn't and we'll only ever have the indirect detections. And there are a lot of indirect detections that the current theory (Lambda-CDM, henceforth ΛCDM) predicts: the anisotropies in the cosmic microwave background, the large scale structure of the universe, galaxy rotation curves, gravitational lensing where no visible matter exists to create the lens, velocity dispersions of elliptical galaxies, galaxy cluster radial velocity distributions, galaxy cluster x-ray spectra, baryon acoustic oscillations, redshift survey distortions, Type Ia supernova distance measurements, Lyman-alpha forest measurements, and now the measured speed of gravitatonal waves. Any alternative to cold dark matter + dark energy needs to agree with all the observations. Not just some, ALL. ΛCDM does. Some alternatives agree with parts and make no predictions about the rest, so they can't be eliminated (eg entropic gravity). But ΛCDM is currently the best fit for the observations. I am not a physicist. I acknowledge that we need a way to unify QM and General Relativity, so one or both of those two must be incorrect. I just don't think that Dark Matter is an hypothesis thing to discard, given the evidence.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- smitherfield 9y agoClickbait title, but interesting article. I Am Not a Physicist, so I need a real one to explain why I'm wrong, but I've thought for a while the cleanest explanation for dark matter is 1. The universe is inside a black hole. 2. Dark matter is matter which is outside the black hole, which explains why it has mass but no other observable properties.
- contravariant 9y agoWhy would we then detect dark matter inside our universe?
- smitherfield 9y agoWe're at the very edge of the event horizon and so is dark matter, just on the other side.
- gnaritas 9y agoNo, we see evidence of dark matter everywhere inside the universe, around galaxies; you may be confusing dark matter with dark energy.
- smitherfield 9y agoI am almost certainly just talking nonsense, but it seems to me if the light-emitting universe is on one side of a flat plane and dark matter is on the other, the physical distance between the light-emitting universe and dark matter could be 0.
- tynpeddler 9y ago>The light and the gravitational waves travel along the direct line of sight to us, curling around the gravity wells of intervening galaxies along the way. As a result, the initial burst of light and gravitational waves hid a little gem: the time difference between the arrival of the gravitational waves and the light. All 1.7 seconds of it. I'm not clear on this part. Was the light slower by 1.7 seconds because it interacted with intervening matter?
- wiredfool 9y agoThere are two parts to this: * For the theories to be correct, the difference in arrival time between the gravity waves and the light waves would need to be more like 3 years. 1.7 seconds from 130 million LY is a very small difference. * The gravity waves peak as the stars are just approaching each other, the gamma pulse happens when they collide.
- mcguire 9y ago"These two seemingly independent metrics [for light and gravity] can explain the structures of galaxies and of collisions between galaxy clusters, but the idea has consequences. For instance, if a something should emit both gravitational waves and light, the two waves will travel by different paths depending on the masses they encounter. So, light and gravitational waves won't arrive at a distant observation point at the same time." However, "The measured delay was so much shorter than the difference predicted by double metric theories that the researchers didn't even bother performing more detailed calculations. There is, in their view, simply no way to include the intervening galaxies and exclude dark matter. This is a dead MOND theory."
- 0xfaded 9y agoDisclaimer: not an expert. Photons have an anomalous magnetic moment. Not going to pretend to be qualified to explain it, but if the photons and gravitons are originating from a region with electromagnetic fields, the photons will be slightly retarded compared to the gravitons which as far as we know do not interact. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anomalous_magnetic_dipole_moment https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anomalous_magnetic_dipole_mo...
- gregcoombe 9y ago"If the Universe were your local neighborhood, dark matter is the family that communicates with everyone, even other family members, only by changing the name of their WiFi network." Ha! There are a couple of other gems in the article. Entertaining and educational.
- mcguire 9y agoIt's a fun way to describe the difference, if possibly not entirely clear to someone who knew nothing. But the description of the actual result is very clear and very well done.
- nategri 9y agoTIL that SSIDs exhibit weak force coupling
- KGIII 9y agoThat's actually pretty horrible. Gotta be honest. HN has enough people who could design a protocol and hardware to do exactly that with wifi. HN can't adequately explain dark matter, except to say it is a placeholder and to define how we observe the effect. Anything more than that is conjecture and anyone who says otherwise is a dirty rotten liar. Really. I hate the name Dark Matter. It's a horrible name. But, someone here understands electromagnetism well enough, pulse signaling, electronics, binary, spectrums, radio, whatever. They could build some sort of mesh network to do exactly that. They could probably build it with COTS and do it for pretty cheap - and write you a damned good paper. Don't have a damned clue what Dark Matter really is. Nope. Edit: Hell, now that I think about it, someone here would probably set that up on like their ham radio stuff at 600 baud just for fun and make it all operate out of terminal. That's a compliment, really. There'd be a Show HN and someone would tell them it had an Emacs shortcut.
- canjobear 9y agoI found the writing in this article cutesy and incomprehensible, but the subject matter sounds very interesting. Are there any more lucidly written descriptions of this work? The actual paper is hard to understand.
- Santosh83 9y agoYup. http://backreaction.blogspot.in/2017/10/new-gravitational-wave-detection-with.html http://backreaction.blogspot.in/2017/10/new-gravitational-wa...
- importantbrian 9y agoThis is why I love HN.
- jerry40 9y agoBut how do we know that light and gravitational wave were emitted exactly at one moment? It is not obvious for me.
- jerf 9y agoWhat is your resolution on "one moment"? At the second-or-so level, we'd think that they weren't emitted at the same moment, as the gravity waves come from the orbiting stars before they collide with each other, i.e., mostly prior to the collision. However, relative to a prediction that they should be separated by over a year, they arrived simultaneously. You might wonder whether perhaps we correlated the gravity waves from one event with the light from another; this is counterindicated by the fact that the gravity waves match theoretical predictions about colliding neutron stars, and the resulting light data we gather matched theories about what colliding neutron stars might look like, an event never before witnessed. The coincidence of these two factors makes it rather likely these events are connected, in another spectacular triumph of theory predicting events that we've never seen before. I don't know that the popular press articles captured or explained this aspect very well, but I think it is part of why the astronomy community got so excited about this. Only part; there's plenty to be excited about in this event! It may well be the most exciting single astronomical event in my lifetime, because there were just so many bits that came together all at once for the first time.
- jerry40 9y agoYes, I know that coincidence of two such events is highly unlikely, but to "compare" paths of gravitons and photons we need to imagine how much time divides 2 emission events. Seconds? Minutes? Hours? Perhaps it isn't very important but it's still interesting.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoIt was one event, a neutron star merger. The gravitational waves were emitted during the inspiral, the light was emitted as the neutron stars smashed into one another and then blew apart in a "kilonova". The two weren't emitted simultaneously, there was a slight delay between the production of gravitational waves and the peak brightness. However, the important aspect is that MOND theories predict not just a slight difference in travel times but literally months or years worth of delay.
- lstodd 9y agoThere is also a recent hypothesis that doesn't require anything 'dark' > It is shown that reduction of the gravitational mass of the system due to emitting gravitational waves leads to a repulsive gravitational force that diminishes with time but never disappears. This repulsive force may be related to the observed expansion of the Universe. https://arxiv.org/abs/1608.01541 https://arxiv.org/abs/1608.01541 Published in MNRAS https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stw1517 https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stw1517 In their other work they try to explain the EM-drive as a crude detector of high-frequency (GHz range) gravitational wave background.
- eli_gottlieb 9y agoSounds kooky. But... the Royal Astronomical Society is publishing it?
- lstodd 9y agoThe math in the original article is more or less solid, no errors were found since publication in 2016. The EM-drive idea is an attempt at an experiment to prove/disprove that the math has any relation to the reality. edit: inventing undetectable dark this or dark that sounds way more kookier than this.
- acqq 9y agoFrom the 1608.01541 (2016) paper you linked: "We hope that our theoretical prediction about decreasing acceleration of the Universe can be verified by observations." But the observations actually see the opposite, the increasing acceleration, verified enough that five years before that paper, the 2011 Nobel Prize in Physics was for that discovery of the increasing acceleration, based on the measurements of Ia supernovae: https://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/physics/laureates/2011/press.html https://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/physics/laureates/20... "What will be the final destiny of the Universe? Probably it will end in ice, if we are to believe this year's Nobel Laureates in Physics. They have studied several dozen exploding stars, called supernovae, and discovered that the Universe is expanding at an ever-accelerating rate. The discovery came as a complete surprise even to the Laureates themselves."
- acqq 9y agoThere were indirect proofs that the speed of gravity is close to the speed of light since at least 1980-es, based on the 1974 discovery of a pulsar in the binary system (1993 Nobel Prize in Physics for Hulse and Taylor) and the measurements and analysis of that data: https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2016/04/28/why-does-gravity-move-at-the-speed-of-light https://www.forbes.com/sites/startswithabang/2016/04/28/why-... "we have constrained the speed of gravity to be equal to the speed of light with a measurement error of only 0.2%!" But this one now is the first direct and so precise measurement that there is no more wiggle room for those who needed it for their hypotheses. Written in 2016 in the article I've linked: "The best results, at the present time, tell us that the speed of gravity is between 2.993 × 10^8 and 3.003 × 10^8 meters per second, which is an amazing confirmation of General Relativity and a terrible difficulty for alternative theories of gravity that don’t reduce to General Relativity!" Now in 2017 also confirmed by the direct observation. The Einstein's General Relativity (1915) is more than 100 years old. Those who designed all the detectors for the gravitational waves were sure decades ago. There were already enough consensus even then that allowed that long work, after all, it's all based on the 1915 theory confirmed in many different ways since. But it's so nice that now we have the real direct measurements of the gravitational waves and the EM signals together. It's really something comparable to the first use of the telescope 400 years ago.
- nerfhammer 9y agoAs as result of the recent detection gravity is now known to update at the speed of light to within ~0.0000000000000001%, if I'm not mistaken.
- marktangotango 9y agoOdd that the title here has been edited to not match the source when usually titles are edited to match the source. If ars uses a click bait title why should HN fix it?
- jackconnor 9y agoDark matter disproven, wow this is amazing. This is literally one of the most important shake ups in modern astrophysics.
- Sniffnoy 9y agoYou seem to have read the article backwards. It's saying that it falsifies certain modified gravity theories (including TeVeS and STVG), not that it falsifies dark matter.
- chmike 9y agoGood. Space Time Quantification (STQ) theory predicts and justify the existence of dark matter particles. It can also predict and justify how all elementary particles react with each other. It provides the equivalent of a mendlejev table for elementary particles. These are conclusion based on the single premice that space measurement is quantified by a unit a. See http://www.scirp.org/journal/Articles.aspx?searchCode=Auguste++Meessen&searchField=authors_complete&page=1&SKID=0 http://www.scirp.org/journal/Articles.aspx?searchCode=August...