3 ms·
Problem definition is not the issue. Contextual awareness is the issue. Humans use different sub-languages to speak to friends, bosses, dates, lovers, spouses,
by TheOtherHobbes 9y ago
Problem definition is not the issue. Contextual awareness is the issue.
Humans use different sub-languages to speak to friends, bosses, dates, lovers, spouses, teachers, students, and so on.
Each social context has its own vocabulary, its own set of expected conversation starter statements, its own set of likely responses, its own set of problems that may need to be solved - and so on.
A lot of what passes for intelligent interaction among humans is really just this social awareness.
Machines will fail the Turing Test without it. But you can't teach a machine to mimic social awareness by throwing 100,000 hours of speech samples at it.
Nor can you expect Echo/Siri/etc to know the context you're working in with no input from social cues - location, dress, time of day, social relationship, facial expression, etc.
So practical ASR turns into spoken-command-line-plus-guessing.
That turns out to be a pretty poor imitation of even the simplest social relationship.
It's not a useless imitation. Even today's limited voice assistants do a fair job at providing a useful service.
But the idea that you can drown neural networks in sample soup to train them, and build yourself a machine capable of intelligent-seeming conversation is just naive.
That's not how baby humans learn to hear and speak, and it's certainly not going to teach machines to converse at a human level.