3 ms·
We must push for the right of comprehensible ownership, not the right to repair your electronics. We must stop the consumer trend of not really owning things, b
by threatofrain 9y ago
We must push for the right of comprehensible ownership, not the right to repair your electronics. We must stop the consumer trend of not really owning things, but instead buying a license to use something.
Consumers don't keep track of every little law or right, and must rely on intuition to guide their sense. Ignorance of the law is a most forgivable excuse to forgetting you have some right or protection in the first place, and a "license to use" breaks a lot of citizens understanding of their legal relationship to the goods they acquired from the market, and the kind of protections their society offers them.
Most citizens don't imagine that they cannot repair or break apart their Ikea furniture. Of course I'm not saying that ordinary people want to break open their phones or laptops, but they may want to take it to a repair shop.
- pimmen 9y agoThe big problem is that manufacturers want to eat their cake and have it too. Imagine if the CPSC would require that they pitch accurately: "And for just $699, you can sign up for an indefinite license to use this magnificent product, ladies and gentlemen! Yes, for that price, you'll be a lucky phone-renter!" If you want to tap into people's desire to own a phone you can't tell them you're filling that desire and then turn around and say "well, what is ownership anyway?".
- npsimons 9y ago> Consumers don't keep track of every little law or right This came up in a similar form in the discussion about IoT devices and privacy. We hold doctors and civil engineers to standards to protect the public, why shouldn't we do the same for software and hardware that could ruin your life? If you don't think this is a problem, or businesses have a "right" to pursue profits at all costs, you are a part of the problem and need to kindly find another industry to harm.
- threatofrain 9y ago> If you don't think this is a problem, or businesses have a "right" to pursue profits at all costs, you are a part of the problem and need to kindly find another industry to harm. You might have a romantic model of the medical system, but I certainly don't think that any business in any industry should be able to pursue profits without any moral restraint.