4 ms·
I'm fond of this old RAND report from Dreyfus, which is worth skimming if you're mathematically inclined: Dynamic Programming and the Calculus of Variations, ht
by psykotic 9y ago
I'm fond of this old RAND report from Dreyfus, which is worth skimming if you're mathematically inclined: Dynamic Programming and the Calculus of Variations, https://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/reports/2006/R441.pdf https://www.rand.org/content/dam/rand/pubs/reports/2006/R441...
One important takeaway is that dynamic programming in the Bellman formulation is a discrete analogue of Hamilton-Jacobi theory in how it writes down an equation for the optimal value as a function of a given endpoint rather than writing down an equation for the path as with the Euler-Lagrange equations. (You can reconstruct the path from the value function after the fact by gradient descent.) The relationship between Hamilton-Jacobi and Euler-Lagrange is the classical version of wave-particle duality. A concrete example in geometrical optics is the eikonal equation, a Hamilton-Jacobi type PDE, versus the geodesic equation, an Euler-Lagrange type ODE. Not coincidentally, one common numerical method for the eikonal equation called the fast marching method is a dynamic programming algorithm, very similar to Dijkstra's algorithm for shortest paths.
It should be mentioned that any "local" equation like a PDE or ODE cannot describe a globally optimal solution without strong assumptions such as convexity. In fact, satisfying the Euler-Lagrange equation isn't even sufficient for local optimality without further qualifications (Weierstrass conditions). But the Bellman dynamic programming equation, being recursive, can describe globally optimal solutions.
- mlevental 9y agounderstand basically all of you've said here except this: >The relationship between Hamilton-Jacobi and Euler-Lagrange is the classical version of wave-particle duality. in what sense are two formalisms (hamiltonian and lagrange) related to the relationship between time and freq space for fourier solutions to pdes? also holy shit i would pay pretty good money for a service that typeset these old monographs using latex.
- kbenson 9y agoSeems like in a world where there's on-demand photoshop editing through a gig economy, something like this should be feasible, if not already exist. Maybe a separate cost per page for text, diagram or both, and a system to pay other people to review pages for correctness (mechanical turk style, or just actually use mechanical turk), and you have a nifty way to update old scanned documents while helping put food on some poor grad student's table.