6 ms·
AMD is a clear winner now on Linux. Nvidia will become an underdog, if they won't open source and upstream their driver, which is very unlikely. Nvidia was and
by shmerl 9y ago
AMD is a clear winner now on Linux. Nvidia will become an underdog, if they won't open source and upstream their driver, which is very unlikely. Nvidia was and will be plagued by integration issues, while AMD already nearly caught up performance wise, and will overtake Nvidia soon enough.
- wyldfire 9y agoI've pinned my compute hopes on AMD for about a decade now. They've been able to hang in there performance-wise, but their solutions on linux just haven't been as stable as NVIDIA's. I hope that's changing, but I'm pretty reluctant to believe it.
- shmerl 9y agoWith OpenCL being replaced with Vulkan, things will get in shape.
- m-p-3 9y agoTheir new drivers (AMDGPU) are being slowly integrated in the Linux kernel, no closed-source binaries.
- nhaehnle 9y agoSmall correction: the amdgpu driver has been integrated and working in the upstream Linux kernel for many years now. The one chink recently was the new display code, which was a requirement for Vega (but not for earlier generations), and which was a genuine open sourcing of an existing, Windows-focused code base. That process took longer than one might hope for, but we're clearly over the hump now with it going upstream.
- danieldk 9y agoThe amdgpu driver really changes that. With NVIDIA you have to choose between an open source driver (nouveau) that has quite some problems or a proprietary driver that does not really integrate well with the rest of the platform. E.g. for a long time you could not use Wayland with the proprietary NVIDIA drivers because they had implemented a different API for device memory allocation (via EGLStreams) [1]. In contrast, AMD is actively contributing to the open source amdgpu driver and builds their proprietary AMDGPU-PRO driver on top of that. I have recently switched from an NVIDIA Quadro card to an AMD FirePro card. I use GNOME/Wayland and the difference is quite big, with NVIDIA on nouveau, there was regularly flickering (at random moments), artifacts and other problems. The FirePro with the amdgpu driver on the other hand works completely flawless on my machine. [1] https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=XDC2016-Device-Memory-API https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=XDC2016-...
- lmm 9y ago> I have recently switched from an NVIDIA Quadro card to an AMD FirePro card. I use GNOME/Wayland and the difference is quite big, with NVIDIA on nouveau, there was regularly flickering (at random moments), artifacts and other problems. nouveau was always pretty awful, but the nvidia binary drivers always Just Worked, across many models for many years, whereas with AMD it's always been a crapshoot whether a given card would work properly or not. The binary drivers always kept up with the important things (indeed they were well ahead of AMD in terms of doing accelerated video decoding on linux via Xvmc and later vaapi, their xinerama integration was always better...). Sure, they don't support Wayland, but that's a solution in search of a problem; if and when there's actual value to be had by using it I have confidence that nvidia will support it.
- Fnoord 9y agoJust worked? The amount of security advisories for Nvidia kernel module or Nvidia X module are staggering. X is also insecure from the ground up, that alone is enough incentive to move away from it.
- danieldk 9y agothey don't support Wayland, but that's a solution in search of a problem Not - if you don't want any GUI application to be able to read keystrokes/mouse events/screen grabs of any other GUI application, - if you want per-display scaling factors, - if you want a tear-free desktop experience.
- bryanlarsen 9y agoI'm currently building out a CUDA cluster and I can assure you that Nvidia drivers don't "Just Work" If AMD is worse, they're failing to clear a pretty low bar.
- guicho271828 9y agoI'm on 1070 for DL tasks with the proprietary driver and it segfaults cinnamon every hours, probably when the acceleration for its graphic effects kicks in. It can be restarted though. I know it is due to the driver because every time the kernel gets updated cinnamon keeps failing to restart itself until I restart the entire system. This never happened before switching from Radeon.
- fgonzag 9y agoAMDGPU beats Nvidia proprietary blobs on every measure. Stability, Performance (Vega 64s hanging with 1080Ti in some games), ease of installation. Especially now that both the kernel developers and AMD are making a concerted effort to integrate the driver into the kernel.
- shaklee3 9y agoYou should clarify you mean games. Nvidia has the gpgpu market to themselves on Linux, and nobody cares if the driver is open source in that area.
- shmerl 9y agoYes, I mean games. In GPGPU market AMD is popular as well though. Miners buy Vega GPUs like hot cakes, it even creates a shortage. Also, CUDA lock-in will be undermined by Vulkan becoming the new common basis for compute. And AMD hardware is better for it and has more raw power, there is no question about it.
- Nursie 9y agoI haven't noticed a Vega shortage, are you sure? Vega is loud and power-hungry, and expensive The last generation of AMD card was snapped up by miners, I've not heard of it happening with Vega.
- shmerl 9y agoThere was Vega shortage for some time, but now it looks better. Huge demand from miners clearly affects it.
- Nursie 9y agoAFAICT here in the UK there was a very limited first week release, followed by a restock and since then it's not been an issue. I am genuinely interested in whether miners are really buying these. Have you any reason to think they are? I couldn't find much when I looked, beyond speculation about how amazing they might be (but turned out not to be). AFAICT for ethereum you're better off with nVidia 1070s which can cost about 75% as much, have about 75% of the hash rate, and use under 50% of the power.
- shmerl 9y agoThat's what I've heard from others about the shortage reason. I didn't specifically research mining topic.
- aslkdjaslkdj 9y agoThe several dozen people playing AAA games on linux must be thrilled.
- shmerl 9y agoYour sarcasm is misplaced because you didn't pay attention to the growth of the Linux gaming market. Check contributions to Mesa by Valve, Feral and others. But more to the point - sure, Linux gamers are quite excited about all the work that's going now into the open graphics stack.
- sliken 9y agoAmusing that you call it sarcasm. Linux gaming has flatlined at 1% or so for years without any noticeable changes. I just checked the last steam hardware survey, linux is at 0.60%. The linux steam hardware has pretty much been a flop. Ubuntu is ditching unity. I sit in front of linux desktops at home and work. I do occasionally game some under linux. I have a linux phone (which has a linux kernel). But I fully realize it's a niche and feel lucky when any game comes to linux. I don't really see any reason for any real optimism.
- shmerl 9y ago> Linux gaming has flatlined at 1% or so for years You didn't pay attention either. The growth was well described here: http://boilingsteam.com/linux-gaming-in-2016-the-good-the-bad-and-the-meh/ http://boilingsteam.com/linux-gaming-in-2016-the-good-the-ba... And that was last year, since then it only improved. And please, stop using Steam hardware survey for any Linux market estimation. It's useless.
- nl 9y ago> The growth was well described here: https://boilingsteam.com/linux-gaming-in-2016-the-good-the-bad-and-the-meh/ https://boilingsteam.com/linux-gaming-in-2016-the-good-the-b... That actually says (if you follow the links to try to find the actual claims): The Linux Market share on Steam is about 1%, Mac is about 4%. They are relatively stable around that. But obviously more people join Steam every day.[1] So... about 1%, using Steam to estimate (not steam hardware though). [1] https://boilingsteam.com/our-fifth-podcast-with-feral-interactive/ https://boilingsteam.com/our-fifth-podcast-with-feral-intera...
- sliken 9y agoI've heard this annually or so for 5 years or so. Yet whenever I look at a benchmark of linux games about half of them don't work on AMD GPUs. Similar for the steam statistics on linux, AMD just doesn't compete on anything that pushes the GPU on linux. Even things like vlc, mplayer, plex, and friends often get the AMD GPUs in a wonky mode. The problems I most often see is new windows fail to map, I just get a black window. Presumably something to do with memory allocations of the backing store. It's also frequently munges the console so I can't get to text mode to unwedge the AMD GPU. So generally if you what a stable linux box I'd recommend nvidia or intel GPUs. Things just work, you can easily have month long uptimes, and things don't freak just because you are playing 1080P video full screen. No pixel droppings, no failing to map, console always works, etc.
- shmerl 9y ago> Yet whenever I look at a benchmark of linux games about half of them don't work on AMD GPUs. Not sure what you looked at, but I see quite a rapid progress of bug fixes: https://www.gamingonlinux.com/wiki/Mesa_Broken https://www.gamingonlinux.com/wiki/Mesa_Broken Never had problems with vlc or mpv on AMD. It works just fine with vaapi. If anything munges the console, it's Nvidia blob which doesn't even support framebuffer. Also, it sounds like you aren't using Mesa, but use AMD closed stack instead. Don't do that. In short, if you want a stable experience - AMD is way ahead of Nvidia.
- MrRadar 9y ago> Also, it sounds like you aren't using Mesa, but use AMD closed stack instead. Don't do that. This is true, but needs a caveat: a lot of work has gone into improving Mesa and the rest of the Linux graphics stack recently and it's now pretty much caught up (performance-wise) to the proprietary AMD drivers. However, that's only happened in the past 6 months or so, so if you're not using a rolling-release distro like Arch or Gentoo you might still be better off with the proprietary drivers until your distro catches up.
- shmerl 9y ago
- unabridged 9y agoThe future of GPU is virtualization (ie where a single gpu can power multiple VMs at almost native performance). When the mining profits start to dwindle, AMD is going to need something to fall back on. They should start putting MxGPU on their consumer cards. Intel already sees the future and has enabled GVT-g on all their integrated GPUs. AMD had slideshows describing the feature on the new Vegas, but decided to disable it before release. This alone stopped me from building a threadripper + vega machine. Now instead I'm waiting for Intel to add more cores, then I will use their integrated graphics between multiple VMs.
- simik 9y agoWhat do you use integrated graphics for on VMs? Genuinely interested, I haven't used VMs beyond web dev and occasionally trying out some new distro of Linux.
- lgbr 9y agoFor those using IOMMU, integrated GPUs are a wonderful way to separate your host machine (which uses the integrated GPU exclusively) and your virtual machine (which uses the dedicated GPU exclusively) such that you can work on a Linux host and game on a Windows guest with (near?) native performance.
- shmerl 9y agoI wonder if AMD will enable SR-IOV for their desktop GPUs.
- snarfy 9y ago> AMD is a clear winner now on Linux. It depends what you value. I've consistently bought Nvidia hardware because of the proprietary drivers.
- dvtv75 9y agoI had an admittedly very old ATI card that I was using in my Linux box while saving my pennies for a newer Nvidia card. I had to give up on it and use an equally old iMac (2008-ish) because the ATI card was locking up my desktop with ring 0 errors nightly (if I ran something that required the 3D hardware, 2D was fine), and no amount of searching could find the solution. That put me off an AMD GPU. I would love to support something else in the ecosystem, but sadly I just don't have the dollars to waste on new hardware that may not work.
- shmerl 9y agoUntil recently, it was a sensible approach for Linux gamers. Today - not anymore. AMD is just better overall.