3 ms·
By not allowing a housing collapse to occur when it should have.
by pixl97 9y ago
By not allowing a housing collapse to occur when it should have.
- freedomben 9y agoI agree. It's better to bring the pain now, than delay it later when it's much more intense. It would also be great if we would quit blowing huge bubbles in the market with poor monetary policy and attempted centralized control of something we don't understand.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoA housing collapse hurts and could have unintended consequences. There's no guarantee that allowing a collapse to happen would be better than what we have now. It's a very blunt instrument of economic management. There may be other ways to sort out the problem. I believe we should focus on those.
- opportune 9y agoWhat was done to prevent a housing collapse? I am under the impression the government focused on preventing a banking institution collapse, which is different. That money was given to offset the liabilities caused by the housing collapse. If Bob was foreclosed, he was foreclosed because he didn't make his payments, at which point his house was put on the market. The banks collapsing wouldn't put more houses on the market than before, it would just mean that a different financial holding company would be selling the houses. So to prevent a housing collapse the government would have to make it easier for Bob to make his payments, but as far as I know the government didn't do that. Or perhaps you are talking about something other than the bailout like interest rates, in which case I would still be curious what you think would have caused the collapse
- derefr 9y agoMy understanding: the government themselves bought a large portion of the housing CDOs (i.e. people's mortgages) from the banks during the credit freeze, to both give the banks money, and give the CDOs a value to get them trading again. If the government had not done that, and had instead just given the banks money, the banks would have had the breathing room to sell their CDOs off for pennies on the dollar, devaluing the mortgages and thus the properties themselves.
- opportune 9y agoI think I get it. For some reason I thought CDOs were kind of like bonds or annuities based on the mortgage payments, but I didn't realize that if you bought a CDO from someone you were also buying the underlying assets. So in the first scenario I thought banks were on the hook for reimbursing mortgage payments to the CDO holders, but in actuality whoever held the CDO was the one getting screwed. However, even if banks were forced to sell off their CDOs, I don't quite see how that devalues the properties. Selling a CDO for a lower rate than before might simply suggest a reduced rate of people making their mortgage payments. For example if I have given Bob a mortgage on a house worth $100, expect to make $10 from interest, and think Bob has a 10% chance of defaulting, wouldn't the value of the CDO be roughly $109 (ignoring that the amount of time into the mortgage at which he defaults affects the price), because even if Bob does default, I still own the $100 house? And then let's say I run into liquidity trouble and need to sell this CDO for $101 (over $100 because my own liquidity problems don't necessarily affect Bob's), that doesn't seem to affect the value of Bob's mortgage at all. Was the problem that the only institutions that could actually buy CDOs were banks themselves? So then if they were all illiquid, there was nobody who could even buy that many assets at once.
- sokoloff 9y agoIf trillions of CDOs were to hit the market all at once because of a concentration of defaults, Bob's house isn't likely to be worth $100 anymore. Depending on how much the CDO Jenga tower inflated the value, it might not even be readily sellable at $50. Why? Because it will be competing for buyers with Charlie's, Dave's, Eve's, Frank's, George's, Henrietta's, Irma's, Julie's, etc houses that are all also for sale after their defaults and those remaining standing with cash or liquid credit will be able to be choosy and drive a hard bargain especially if they're not going to personally occupy the property (as then they are largely indifferent among the competing housing stock).
- pjc50 9y agoI don't believe that the arrow of causation runs that way; how does selling the CDO at any price push the house price around?