4 ms·
> If there’s no 6, said Caroline Turnage-Butterbaugh, a math professor at Duke University, then there can’t be a 7, 8 or 9 — or, really, any number greater than
by OJFord 9y ago
> If there’s no 6, said Caroline Turnage-Butterbaugh, a math professor at Duke University, then there can’t be a 7, 8 or 9 — or, really, any number greater than 5. Say you have a pile of seven items. You could take one away, ending up with the-number-formerly-known-as-6.
This seems like a weak argument: say you have a pile of five items; you could add one, and then we have six after all.
I don't see why subtraction should be treated any differently?
I thought this was going to be more interesting than 'imagine the world in base 6' - what're the ramifications of a 'hole' in the middle? I recall enough to know that fields allow for it, but are the consequences at all interesting?
- dogecoinbase 9y agoThis seems like a weak argument: say you have a pile of five items; you could add one, and then we have six after all. You presume the existence of a sixth item, so of course you can construct it.
- pavement 9y agoThere are multiple interpretations to the question, clearly. Removing a tick mark from an infinite number line would just cause all the other tick marks to slide closer together like billiard balls, no? Or is the question really about what happens if we render six as a forbidden, unaddressable element? Maybe equations normally resulting in an integral six, or involving an integral six return an error stating: undefined? Not unlike a divide by zero error? Consider rationalizing division by zero. One could interpret the outcome of such an operation as always resulting in zero, instead of an error, but what would that mean when modeling real world events? If you have zero, and you want to divide it into N number of parts, well, you’d still have zero things, and so what? But what if you had somethings, and you wanted to divide them all into zero parts? Does that mean the operation represents the total annihilation of those things? We can imagine a situation where total annihiliation by division is possible, but is it worth building that interpretation into most models, when an operation like that isn’t often applied to circumstances, and such an outcome is rarely requested?
- derefr 9y agoMy understanding is that the math professor interpreted the question to mean "what if our universe, rather than acting in so-far-seeming correspondence with ZFC set theory, was one that was best explained by a different axiomatic set theory—one that didn't entail the existence of "6" as a mathematical object? What universe would we be in, and what would it be like?"
- opportune 9y agoIf there were no number 6, there could be no infinite countable sets, because all infinite countable sets have a bijection to Z, and 6 is in Z. Furthermore there could be no finite sets with cardinality greater than 6 because those have a bijection to Z_n for some n in Z. That would be true in both a mathematical sense and a physical sense, since you could still physically represent the quantity 6 with 6 particles. So any "world" with no 6 could have at most 3 bits of information in it. It's really a nonsensical question because 6 is both an abstract concept - hence the reasoning about infinite and finite sets - and a real quantity you can have of something. The normal arithmetic operators wouldn't even be well-defined. The only way to make this universe consistent is if you made an exception such as 5 + 1 = 7 and 7 - 1 = 5, but in that case you have simply replaced the symbol of the number k with the symbol of the number k-1 for all k > 6. It's just an absurdity, and in my opinion a poor question to write about for a non-mathematical audience, because it will make people confused. It's like asking the question what if there were no sets, or what if there weren't addition. Math is truth not limited by the constraints of our physical universe; it is an absolute. There has to be a concept of 6 for there to be mathematics - or anything - at all.
- westoncb 9y agoI think your proof using the bijection amounts to: it wouldn't work because 6 wouldn't be in Z—but that is the essence of the proposition here: "what if 6 weren't in Z?" So you end up just dismissing the question. Sure, it's a fairly arbitrary idea that isn't really going to go anywhere, but maybe it can at list be a bit more interesting. For example, what if we treated operations resulting in what would be the 7th member (counting from zero) of Z (i.e. '6') the same we treat division by zero? If we are constructing the system axiomatically, we can follow the the pattern with Fields, looking at their definition of multiplicative inverses (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Field_(mathematics)#Classic_definition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Field_(mathematics)#Classic_de...), which effectively excludes the possibility of division by zero. There's probably a similar way of patching axioms related to addition and multiplication so as to preclude the possibility of arriving at '6' through application of those operations.
- opportune 9y ago
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> I thought this was going to be more interesting than 'imagine the world in base 6' - what're the ramifications of a 'hole' in the middle? I recall enough to know that fields allow for it, but are the consequences at all interesting? Why? There's nothing interesting to say. If you have no 6, either you renamed it ( http://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?id=3913 http://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?id=3913 ) or you've stopped working in a useful structure. In particular, ℤ without 6 is not an algebraic field, because fields are closed under addition and multiplication.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoℤ mod 5 is a useful structure where 6 doesn't exist.
- thaumasiotes 9y ago6 is part of that structure, sharing space with 1 and 11.