4 ms·
If you object to standardized tests, what do you propose we use? Non-standard tests? The opinions of assorted cronies?
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
If you object to standardized tests, what do you propose we use? Non-standard tests? The opinions of assorted cronies?
- ewanmcteagle 16y agoIf students weren't locked into schools enrollment levels and parent feedback would provide a lot of information.
- ktsmith 16y agoParent feedback isn't worth nearly as much as you might think. Parents aren't in the classroom, they tend to get one side of things (their child's). Some parent's are objective and some aren't. This leads to plenty of horror stories about parents that assume all teachers are morons and their children are infallible, I've seen it first hand and it's really pathetic. The flip side of that would be the parents of my wife's former students. She has been teaching in poor neighborhoods and a significant percentage of the parents are illiterate. While these parent's are very happy with my wife and they request all their children (and cousins etc) have her, using their feedback to rate my wife as a teacher would be seriously flawed as they really don't have the ability to judge if the teaching is effective at all.
- jbooth 16y agoWell, that's sort of like saying we should use lines of code as a metric, because what else to we have to go on. The opinions of assorted developers? There needs to be some attempt at normalization between teachers and school districts, of course. But there's room for qualitative measures instead of quantitative ones. Especially when the tests seem (unintentionally) designed to punish teachers for teaching poor/minority/ESL students.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoWe have much better metrics for developers than lines of code - bug fixes/feature requests weighted by importance, P&L, etc. Do you have a better metric for teachers than standardized tests? Especially when the tests seem (unintentionally) designed to punish teachers for teaching poor/minority/ESL students. This is utterly false if we reward teachers based on deltas rather than absolute values, that is we compare actual performance to statistically predicted performance and reward/penalize teachers when actual performance exceeds predicted performance.
- abstractbill 16y agoThis is utterly false if we reward teachers based on deltas rather than absolute values... That's a big if. From what I've seen, this is practically never done - absolute values are the norm.
- kingkilr 16y ago> bug fixes/feature requests weighted by importance Isn't there a DailyWTF about a company that did just that and found that the testing people conspired with the developers to invent bugs, locate them, and then collect bonuses for fixing them.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoPreventing conspiracies like this is exactly why teachers should be evaluated by standardized tests designed by an independent agency.
- jbooth 16y agoYou already said you think teachers are overpaid and underworked and your goal is to make things harder for them. Why should they want to work under a system like that? What independent agency would you want devising metrics to figure out how good you are at your job while knowing nothing about the specific challenges you deal with?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI believe teachers currently are comped at above-market rates. I would bring them down to market rates. They would work under that system for the same reason most other professionals work at market rates - it's the best they can get. The independent agency which currently devises metrics to figure out how good I do my job is the stock market. My bonus = % of profits. When I was a professor, I favored (and suggested to the department) that some higher authority should devise midterm and final exams. It would a) allow us to measure teacher performance, as opposed to student opinion [1] and b) allow comparison of student performance across classes. [1] To get good student evaluations, all you need is easy tests + jokes + good looks.
- lutorm 16y agoI don't have an alternative that I think is workable. And that's why I'm far from convinced that teacher salaries should be tied to performance; I think the side effects of "optimization by proxy" will be severe. As an aside, pointing out that something is bad does not put the onus on me to invent something better. The sensible conclusion is to not do anything until something good has been worked out. The alternative is to do something just for the sake of appearing to do something.