5 ms·
Have Marijuana Tests Resulted in Tens of Thousands of False Convictions?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Alex3917 16y agoI'm not pro drugs per se, I just think that a lot of the research and theory is fascinating. For example, check out these two videos from last year's Horizons conference. http://vimeo.com/10931182 http://vimeo.com/10931182 (Alicia Danforth - Little Pieces of a Big Dream: Participants’ Stories from a Cancer Anxiety Study with Psilocybin) http://vimeo.com/10918637 http://vimeo.com/10918637 (Bob Wold - Suicide or Psychedelics) Both videos are a lot more intellectually interesting than 99% of the stuff that gets posted on HN. In fact they're both a lot more compelling than the average TED talk. Or check out this podcast by the founders of Erowid, The Role of Drug Geeks in Society: http://www.matrixmasters.net/archive/Erowid/026-ErowidDrugGeeks.mp3 http://www.matrixmasters.net/archive/Erowid/026-ErowidDrugGe... I realize this stuff will never be popular on HN because it's just too long and it's somewhat difficult to fully grok, but nevertheless I think there is a lot of really cool stuff out there.
- bugsy 16y agoI don't use drugs myself, but this article is very interesting because it contains science and statistics and talks about a specific chemical test, its history, its serious flaws, its misuse, and how its misuse has become a tool to imprison obviously innocent people. There's enough science geek content in the article that I think it makes sense to be on HN.
- jbooth 16y agoHey, you can't imprison 1% of your population without cutting a few corners.
- coryl 16y agoThe fail here is your request; you can't "turn" the userbase into anything. The userbase is what is is. That's why we have the upvote/downvote system. Downvote the articles you don't find relevant. Or ever easier, don't read them/comment on them.
- mcknz 16y agoYou care when a bogus test or false accusation gets you in trouble even though you have not used drugs. Like that article on DFS previously -- it's good to know about abuses in the system so you can be ready if/when it happens to you. I imagine any articles about writing the Declaration of Independence on hemp paper would be dead pretty quickly.
- ericingram 16y agoYou are free to form your own opinion about "illegal" substances, but no one should be penalized for behavior that does not infringe on the rights of another individual. In short, Marijuana and all other drugs should be legal. Acts which violate the rights of others, committed under the influence of substances (or any condition really) is no different than an act committed with a clear mind/body. Trying to prevent crime by criminalizing victimless actions only creates more crime.
- runT1ME 16y agoI agree with you, but to play devil's advocate, how would you feel about me constructing a nuclear reactor in my backyard for fun? Or manufacturing a bomb or rocket?
- shod 16y agoYou mean like Mark Suppes does? http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/10385853 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/10385853
- king_jester 16y agoSmoking marijuana isn't the same as building a bomb. If I accidentally light a joint, the people in my immediate radius aren't blown to pieces (although they might choose to get blown).
- Alex3917 16y ago"Smoking even one marijuana cigarette is equal in brain damage to being on Bikini Island during a hydrogen bomb blast." --Ronald Reagan
- InclinedPlane 16y agoI think runTIME may be making a subtly different argument. Let's say I have a 1,000 acre ranch and I build a nuclear reactor on it. I go to extreme lengths to make sure it's safe and secure. As far as my neighbors are concerned my operating a nuclear reactor has no impact on them. However, now I have the potential, should I choose, to make nuclear weapons, radiological "dirty" bombs, or otherwise contaminate the general vicinity (for potentially very large values of vicinity) with radioactive byproducts. It is for this reason that the operation of nuclear reactors is highly regulated. One could imagine how this argument might apply to personal drug use. Drug use itself may not instantly impact anyone else but suppose that, as in personally operating a nuclear reactor, it enabled individuals to have a far greater negative impact on society than other normal human behaviors might. I don't buy it and I'm not sure if that's the argument that runTIME was making, but it's an interesting argument I think.
- yanowitz 16y agoInteresting article, horrific story, but one oddity stuck out: "The Duquenois test was developed in the late 1930s by a French pharmacist, Pierre Duquénois, while he was working for the United Nations division of narcotics." The UN wasn't founded until 1945. How did he do this work for the UN in the late 30s? Should that be late 40s?
- anigbrowl 16y agoThe most egregious example occurred in 2006. U.S. District Judge William Alsup found the D-L test to be a specific identification test and declared, grandiosely: “Despite the many hundreds of thousands of drug convictions in the criminal justice system in America, there has not been a single documented false-positive identification of marijuana or cocaine when the methods used by the SFPD [San Francisco Police Department] Crime Lab are applied by trained, competent analysts.” I am surprised, as Judge Alsup has a good reputation in general...but an opinion is only as good as the quality of the data it's based on. The SFPD Drug Lab has turned out to be disastrously unreliable, and was shut down a couple of months ago. http://pdfserver.amlaw.com/ca/massullo_order.pdf http://pdfserver.amlaw.com/ca/massullo_order.pdf If you are interested in reading about the conclusions of the judge who investigated the goings-on.
- lucisferre 16y agoOne could argue that Marijuana being illegal has resulted in hundreds of thousands of false convictions.