7 ms·
The involvement of Western powers in the Russian Civil war (Temporary occupation of the Far East, aid to the Whites in the West) was a large contributing factor
by vkou 9y ago
The involvement of Western powers in the Russian Civil war (Temporary occupation of the Far East, aid to the Whites in the West) was a large contributing factor to the USSR's wretched relationship with the West - long after 'Communism in all countries' was forgotten.
As it turns out, backing the losing side in a civil war does not ingratiate you with the winner.
- danharaj 9y agoIt also was a powerful factor in forcing the early revolutionaries to adopt a militarized war-footing whose impetus never quite subsided. Turns out when you build a society from scratch and have to spend most of your time solving military problems, you eventually run your entire society like a military.
- arethuza 9y agoThe failure to appreciate how paranoid and scared the Soviets were almost started a nuclear war in 1983 with the Able Archer debacle - at least Reagan realised that the "Evil Empire" rhetoric was a mistake and calmed things down. [NB I'm not trying to defend the Soviets, who were a thoroughly unpleasant bunch, but the colossal failure to understand their motivations and just how one side the Cold War was for most of the time almost ended things.]
- cmdkeen 9y agoWhile we may like to think of the Western intelligence agencies as all knowing for large periods throughout the Cold War they were essentially blind as to the inner working / thinking of the USSR. The occasional defectors or agents who could bring understanding are significant because of their scarcity. The West had many reasons to believe the USSR was stronger than it was, hawks on the right wanted to believe it, fellow travellers on the left wanted to believe it, the Russian political system wanted to believe it (and lied to itself repeatedly).
- arethuza 9y agoThe "Bomber Gap" and "Missile Gap" were known to be fiction pretty much at the time but for partisan political purposes nobody could actually be seen to publicly acknowledge how small the threat was. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bomber_gap https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bomber_gap https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missile_gap https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missile_gap
- vkou 9y ago> It also was a powerful factor in forcing the early revolutionaries to adopt a militarized war-footing whose impetus never quite subsided. I wouldn't agree with that - I think the Civil war, and the subsequent domestic uprisings were that impetus. Outside of the Second World War, most of the fighting the Red Army did was against its own people.
- danharaj 9y ago> Outside of the Second World War That is a whole lot of fighting to leave out. In any case, these things compound. Immediately after WW2, the USSR still felt threatened by the West, which was not an unfounded fear. Multigenerational paranoia about being invaded by more powerful nations is precisely the kind of thing that damages institutions to the point where they no longer serve any purpose but preserving themselves.
- tomohawk 9y agoIt was always the plan of the Marxists to grab all the power and run a dictatorship. They supposed they needed that to reeducate the masses and change society. Then, they ended up doing what every dictatorship ends up doing. In the end, 100 million people died. If your ideas require you to impose a dictatorship to implement them, then maybe they're not such good ideas.
- danharaj 9y agoI suggest you actually diligently check the sources for the suspect claims that 100 million people died under Communism. Under the accounting methods used, capitalist systems of government would dwarf that number. Of course, uneven standards are par for the course. > It was always the plan of the Marxists to grab all the power and run a dictatorship. "The Marxists". Do you know how many groups participated in the Russian civil war, how many of them considered themselves Marxists, and how many of them were purged by the sole political entity that seized power? Since you uncritically cited that 100 million figure, I'm going to guess no.
- logicchains 9y agoAs an example just in China: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Leap_Forward#Famine_deaths https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Leap_Forward#Famine_deat..., due to economic mismanagement. I'd be interested to see any sources showing a similar number of deaths under a capitalist government, which I suspect would be hard as capitalist governments by definition don't exercise complete centralised control over the country's economic production.
- jahaja 9y ago> I'd be interested to see any sources showing a similar number of deaths under a capitalist government Have you ever tried yourself? It's not a very hard thing to start to compile. The problem here is ideological though. Everything that would be added to the capitalism list would be rationalized away even if it uses the same measurement stick.
- opo 9y agoRelations between the west and the Soviet Union were more complex than that: >...The United States government was initially hostile to the Soviet leaders for taking Russia out of World War I and was opposed to a state ideologically based on communism. Although the United States embarked on a famine relief program in the Soviet Union in the early 1920s and American businessmen established commercial ties there during the period of the New Economic Policy (1921–29), the two countries did not establish diplomatic relations until 1933. By that time, the totalitarian nature of Joseph Stalin's regime presented an insurmountable obstacle to friendly relations with the West. https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/archives/sovi.html https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/archives/sovi.html
- vkou 9y ago> By that time, the totalitarian nature of Joseph Stalin's regime presented an insurmountable obstacle to friendly relations with the West. That is complete nonesense. The West has had, currently has, and will always have friendly relations with dictators and killers of all shades and stripes, as long as they are useful to us. There is nothing about their domestic policies that we consider insurmountable.
- gaius 9y agoParticularly if they have a veneer of leftist lip service. Plenty of Westerners were and still are supporters of brutal regimes, while hostile to regimes that just happen to be right wing. If the Apartheid regime of SA had called itself "socialist" there would have been no boycotts or concerts...
- dashundchen 9y agoI'm not sure where this bizarre revision of history comes from. The "West", dominated by the US for the past century, has installed plenty of brutal dictators and military regimes, mostly when countries ignored the US to go left, not right. See Iran, Syria, a good fraction of Latin America including Cuba, Chile, Venezuela, Nicaragua, Honduras, along with Korea and Vietnam. Western governments, including Reagan, Nixon, and Thatcher ignored and even actively supported SA's apartheid government for decades. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tar_Baby_Option https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tar_Baby_Option
- scarmig 9y agoIt's convenient for some people to say that it's inevitable that the USSR would be paranoid and anti-Western because of the West's ill-conceived intervention there. But the reality is that, once the situation was stable in the USSR, the West was plenty willing to play ball there. Even the Koch patriarch was more than willing to build refineries there. A combination of ingrained Russian xenophobia and ideological commitments drove the USSR to go haywire, not a small interventionary force a couple thousand strong.
- thriftwy 9y ago> ingrained Russian xenophobia Citation needed. (Unless you can't back it with statistics and then it becomes a slur)
- scarmig 9y agoXenophobia is present in all nations. I'm happy to go further and say that xenophobia plays a more central role in Russian identity than, say, English. Demanding "statistics" is a way of setting a bar that's more focused on dismissing historical and non-quantitative evidence than it is on clarifying anything. I could just as easily demand you prove the existence of Russia using statistics, and you'd fail. The Russian state has always had a fraught and conflicted relationship with the West. It had a fairly unique place in being geographically situated to avoid economic and political domination by the West, but being less developed and near enough that its interactions with the Western powers led to a persistent inferiority complex. The court ladies excitedly took up the latest fashions and fads from Paris, while the political leadership attempted difficult reforms, partially to ensure their continued ability to resist Western domination and partially because they wanted approval of the more cosmopolitan powers. (The quasi-apocryphal Potemkin villages were built in order to impress Catherine II and a group of Western ambassadors.) Pan-Slavism emerged in the 19th century. Instead of focusing myopically on aping Western powers, its intellectuals wanted to build a pan-Slavic identity and nationalism, centered around the Slavic folk, the Orthodox church, and the Tsar. This naturally led to conflicts with the more-Westernized countries that dominated Slavic peoples, as well as the Ottoman Empire. The people who questioned religion and the Tsar, for their part, were filthy liberals who were stooges of Western intellectuals (sound familiar?) And, for what its worth, most of the liberals were relatively privileged folk who looked down on the idiocy of the countryside, who made up the heartland of Russia (sound familiar?) It formed a useful dialectic for everyone involved. Revolution and war come. Through an unlikely series of (un)fortunate accidents, the Bolsheviks come into power. They were a very funny set of people to rule over Russia, but they ruled. Their opinions of the Western ranged from (at best) negative to incredibly bitter and angry. But some compromises were made, in the first decade of Soviet rule. Ultimately, though, Stalin came to power. Mostly because he was the most ruthless autocrat. But he was more than happy to deploy xenophobia and the trope of his enemies being stooges of foreign powers when it suited him, as it often did. The scars of WW2 made him and Russian society even more sclerotic, leading to the present day.
- pm90 9y agoThere is a reason why the Western powers (especially France) supported the White Russians. The Bolsheviks had indicated the possibility of not paying back foreign loans that were taken out by the Russian Empire (they followed through on that promise and defaulted on all foreign loans; USSR was basically cutoff from the Western Financial system until WW2). France had provided most of these, but the other powers were involved as well. This was probably the most important reason for their opposition: if they let the Bolsheviks get away with not paying loans, not only would their bankers lose a shit ton of money, but what was to stop other foreign powers (possibly communist ones) from doing the same? Most foreign wars have surprisingly banal reasons for taking place...
- cat199 9y ago'their bankers' -> look into the backers of lenins train full of gold..
- Synaesthesia 9y agoA few more reasons occur: Bolsheviks nationalized all foreign possessions in Russia (which were very substantial - foreigners owned 90% of the railways for instance). Also they appealed to the proletariat in the world and showed the potential of revolution to be real. Lastly they simply weren’t integrated with the western global financial and economic system. Really the source of the friction, more so than ideological reasons. For centuries before Russia was a virtual colony of the West, sort of like the third world today.
- digi_owl 9y agoReminds me of how during revolutions one of the first actions is to burn loan ledgers. Supposed the term jubilee comes from ancient rulers recognizing the problem of debt slavery and thus every X years would annul all outstanding debt.
- cat199 9y agoExcept the truth is far less clear. Look up Lenin's train full of gold and how Trotsky made his way back to Russia through several countries despite being a wanted criminal.. or the actual start of the war w/r/t austrian occupation of serbia and nicholas II's slavic brotherhood movement and things become far more murky as to who 'the west' was backing.. esp. when one considers what position russia would have been in in to negotiate with the fallen ottomans and what that would mean for french/british hegemony in the near east.. As for afterwords - the USSR still traded with the west, and some people still made money.. look into the NEP beyond seeing it as a curious historical footnote and it too is not so clear.. Funny, kind of sounds like the last 20 years or so... hmm..
- pm90 9y agoIts not murky at all. Russian Empire was allied with the Serbians, who were considered fellow Slavs. Germans/Austrians were not keen on fighting on the eastern front with the powerful Russian empire and thus wanted to destabilize the country making it incapable of fighting against them (which they actually succeeded: the Soviets signed a humiliating treaty ending the war on the eastern front while ceding huge territories to Germany/Austria). Thus, they assisted the revolutionaries, among them Trotsky and Lenin.
- eighthnate 9y ago> As it turns out, backing the losing side in a civil war does not ingratiate you with the winner. You could say the same thing with the west's relation with china and vietnam and almost every other non-western nation on earth. It's difficult to form a deep relationship with china or russia or vietnam or anyone else when you back the losing side. Is there a bigger thorn in the side of the sino-american relationship than taiwan?