4 ms·
One of my all-time favorite talks. The IT industry is pretty bad in general at knowing what problems have previously been solved.
by macintux 9y ago
One of my all-time favorite talks. The IT industry is pretty bad in general at knowing what problems have previously been solved.
- romaniv 9y agoYeah. Almost every time I watch a Marvin Minsky or Alan Kay video of any kind I'm surprised with info on some awesome technology or research from the 60s or 70s.
- pjmlp 9y agoYou should also check the systems programming research that was happening on those days, NEWP already had UNSAFE blocks that required "root" blessing to be executed. Or the IBM RISC research using PL/8. And many other examples, lost in research papers from all those companies.
- skadamat 9y agoI think you'll like the discussion he had at CMU a few years back, which focused a lot on the technology side of things https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PFc379hu--8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PFc379hu--8
- pjmlp 9y agoAlso for me. When I delve into the digitized copies of these researches, I am always fascinated by the little treasures I find out. And by being old enough to have experimented with some of them it saddens me the amount of left turns we have taken, for some to still be happy with a plain phosphor terminal experience.
- robbrit 9y agoIn many cases, we have to first acknowledge that the problem exists before we attempt to apply some of these solutions. I've noticed myself seeing solutions to problems that I didn't know I had, only to brush off the solution as though it were only an interesting curiosity with no real practical use. It was years later when I went back to that and realized how useful it could have been.
- fhood 9y agoThis was one of my professors favorite gripes. He loved to tell stories about how companies would reinvent algorithms (usually multiple times) that had been published in the 70's and 80's
- zvrba 9y agoThe problem here is search. The problem may have been solved, but finding the relevant paper is like looking for a needle in the haystack. It doesn't help that terminology has changed during the years...
- mrec 9y ago> It doesn't help that terminology has changed during the years... As has hardware. Trivial example, but linked lists made a lot more sense in the 1970s than they do today.
- tj-teej 9y agoThe problem with the solution to the problem of search is searching for the solution to the problem of search?
- acuozzo 9y ago> The problem here is search. And training. I've had to reinvent algorithms I know already exist for my hobby work because they were invented to solve another unrelated problem I'm not familiar with and phrased using domain language I don't know.
- BjoernKW 9y agoApart from making information easily retrievable, which ironically academia at least used to be notoriously bad at, inventing an algorithm and using it effectively in an application in many cases are two very different matters. These arguments often get handwavy rather quickly. Real-life applications have to accommodate edge cases and non-functional requirements, something a scientific paper doesn't need to account for. That's perfectly fine. It isn't a scientist's job to worry about implementation details but those shouldn't be brushed off lightly either.
- shalabhc 9y ago> what problems have previously been solved And we're worse at identifying what the problems actually are.
- pierre_d528 9y agoTreasures from Alan Kay and friends can be found here: http://www.vpri.org http://www.vpri.org Do check the STEPS project: a complete system in 10_000 readable LOC. Really exceptional. Bret Victor can be found here: http://worrydream.com http://worrydream.com Friends can be found here: https://harc.ycr.org/member/ https://harc.ycr.org/member/ Make sure to check Alan Kay's answers on Quora: https://www.quora.com/profile/Alan-Kay-11 https://www.quora.com/profile/Alan-Kay-11