4 ms·
I'm not attempting to claim subject matter expertise but I would like to raise two points. 1) If your hypothesis assumes that information is actually created t
by dogma1138 9y ago
I'm not attempting to claim subject matter expertise but I would like to raise two points.
1) If your hypothesis assumes that information is actually created then it's either wrong (as it's contradictory to our current understanding of physics) or you need to describe a mechanism through which information can be created or added to our universe from an external source.
You might be able to contrive a mechanism through which the expansion is simply a byproduct of the every increasing entropy but I don't understand why would it then appear to an observer that the total area of the hologram is shrinking.
A hologram cannot hold more data without expanding it's surface area (adding additional dimensions to a hologram to make it more complex would also impact "our universe" in this analogy), the popular science "formula" for the total information that can be stored in a hologram is basically it's information density (which has a limit) x it's surface area.
Now you can say that our universe is encoded in a hologram that hasn't reached the Bekenstein bound so the information density of it can increase but again that would require some sort of a mechanism that I'm not aware off, but I'm not an expert or even particularly knowledgeable in this matter to be able to have a truly constructive discussion.
2) A theory that describes the "true nature" of the universe is useless unless it gives new predictions or new tools to explain existing phenomenon.
It doesn't really matter if our universe is encoded on the surface of a black hole in another universe, is one of many bubbles of the foam that makes up the multiverse or is it one of many marbles in the marble bag of some alien teenagers from the trans dimensional universe five-nine-alpha.
- mojomark 9y agoGood stuff. Thanks for the thoughtful reply. I do think that if the driver for our universe's accelerated expansion were understood to be a matter of perceiveing an effect of the activity on the holographic membrane rather than 'a push' from some yet do be discovered energy source in a non-holographic model, that could open the door to new discovery. Regardless, I think I'm going to stick with the 59A Marble Bag hypothesis and crawl back into my mechanical engineering design site where I belong.