3 ms·
Your determination to make the point that this experiment does demonstrate some level of understanding seems to have led you into thinking that any discussion o
by mannykannot 9y ago
Your determination to make the point that this experiment does demonstrate some level of understanding seems to have led you into thinking that any discussion of how deep that understanding goes is counterproductive, for some reason. When, however, you asked "what more is there to understanding?", the answer is that in this case, there could be more than that which the experiment actually demonstrates, but it will take further experiments to determine whether that is so.
While you may not be interested in this question, the biologists performing these experiments certainly should be (and I am sure they are.)
There is also the distinct possibility of this experiment being misunderstood by those with a casual interest in biology and/or cognitive science - just because our understanding of the experiment involves buoyancy and displacement, it does not follow that the raccoons' does.
- naasking 9y ago> When, however, you asked "what more is there to understanding?", the answer is that in this case, there could be more than that which the experiment actually demonstrates, but it will take further experiments to determine whether that is so. You could interpret my question very broadly, but it seems clear from context that I was asking why one would need to set the threshold for qualifying as "understanding" higher than the simple causal reasoning the experiment demonstrated. The most fundamental question is about the minimum unit of understanding and how to test for that, and everything above that bar would simply be more elaborate chains built from these simple units. This seems to be what the OP I responded to was asking about, and he seemed to want to set that threshold too high IMO.