4 ms·
In a rational market, yes, absolutely; if prices are driven by a supply deficit then increasing supply cuts prices (or at least reduces price growth, if a small
by rsynnott 9y ago
In a rational market, yes, absolutely; if prices are driven by a supply deficit then increasing supply cuts prices (or at least reduces price growth, if a smaller deficit remains).
Housing markets tend not to be all that rational, though; there's often an aspect of speculative mania to them. It's likely that increasing supply would cut prices, but it's not actually certain, as it may just increase speculative 'investor' demand from the "house prices always go up" crowd. The Irish property bubble in the late 90s to late noughties was originally driven by supply shortages, but even as supply started to meet demand prices kept going up for a couple of years due to property "investors" (before crashing spectacularly).
- AznHisoka 9y agowhat differentiates a real estate investor from a speculator?
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoDiversification? Although drawing the line there would put plenty of big time "investors" on the speculator side. Maybe it's just a distiction without a difference.
- rsynnott 9y agoThe speculator buys property because they expect it to go up in value; the rent is just covering part of their costs. For instance, if you have an "investment" property, but the rent doesn't cover the interest component of the mortgage, but you think that's okay because you expect it to go up in value, you're a speculator, not an investor.
- AznHisoka 9y agoOk, so anyone who invests in stocks with no dividends is also a speculator too by your definition? Or is the criteria different for stock investors?
- kevinburke 9y agoSure there is bubble like behavior at times but there’s also 68 years of data in SF showing that a 1% increase in supply leads to a 1.7% decrease in rents, http://experimental-geography.blogspot.com/2016/05/employment-construction-and-cost-of-san.html?m=1 http://experimental-geography.blogspot.com/2016/05/employmen... In the vast majority of places low supply is causing high prices, not speculation.