5 ms·
For such a smart person, it surprises me that he seems to have missed the point of what is going on in <insert politicized debate of the day here>. In modern W
by nl 9y ago
For such a smart person, it surprises me that he seems to have missed the point of what is going on in <insert politicized debate of the day here>.
In modern Western thought, voices aren't suppressed. Instead, they are politicized and used to put the speaker on a "side". Then the people on that side will defend their side (although not always the speaker) using that person as a proxy for their side.
We see this in global warming, in nuclear power, in gender equality, in free speech rights, in gun rights, in nurture vs nature.
I can think of only two examples where something similar to the behavior called out in this article occurs in the modern West. The first is the "neural network conspiracy" where CIFAR funded research for years, until they suddenly won. The other is cold fusion, where there are persistent rumors that this wasn't perhaps the dead end it was made out to be (I don't have the expertise to evaluate that and tell if it is crackpots or not though).
- TeMPOraL 9y agoHe didn't miss that; in fact, he wrote about it frequently in the past. It's not true that voices aren't suppressed in the modern Western world, though. The original post by Scott Aaaronson, the one from which this post takes it title, was a response to present-day suppression of opinions. Both Scotts have opted to write their posts in a very general tone (even though they're obvious responses to some recent events), but I'll nevertheless spell it out in concrete terms: if you express your disagreement with the current feminist/social justice ideology on a public forum, you risk losing your job to an angry Twitter mob.
- empath75 9y ago> if you express your disagreement with the current feminist/social justice ideology on a public forum, you risk losing your job to an angry Twitter mob. "Free speech" doesn't and shouldn't protect you from facing personal consequences for your speech. If you publicly profess stupid and/or offensive ideas, other people have a right to form opinions of you because of them, and those people have a right to choose not to do business with you.
- nl 9y agoOP here - no, that's not the point here, so please don't go down this road. I think we all agree with that point. My argument is that the personal consequences of that speech aren't what people think. Yes he lost his job, but he is now celebrated in some part of (fairly mainstream) politics. That's pretty different to the examples in the linked article.
- saint_fiasco 9y agoThe people in the article are celebrated too. Not a lot of consolation for those burned at the stake, but the ones like Galileo would probably be satisfied. Fortunately nowadays Galileos are much more common than Brunos.
- detaro 9y agoWhat part of the parent post or the article are you responding to? They didn't make a "but it's free speech!" argument, to the contrary, they explicitly are about personal consequences as you describe.
- nl 9y agoHe didn't miss that; in fact, he wrote about it frequently in the past. Can you point to that? if you express your disagreement with the current feminist/social justice ideology on a public forum While I agree that kind of behavior is what he is referring to, I'd note that is a perfect example of exactly what I said. In the case of Damore specifically, yes, he lost his job but in return picked up numerous speaking engagements and is now a player in the culture wars. That's a long way from being executed! He's suing Google, and being represented by Harmeet Dhillon, "a prominent San Francisco Republican who was considered for a post in the Trump administration" who is "a member of the Republican National Committee". Is it possible to be more entrenched in the mainstream culture wars than that? Far from being Kolmogorov or Giordano Bruno, it seems to me he is closer to Kanye West circa the 2006 "Bush Doesn't Care About Black People" interview, or the Dixie Chicks anti-war comments, or Judith Miller's pro-Iraq war NY Times columns. All made some people really, really mad, and had some consequences for their authors, but long term just solidified their position for the other side.
- saint_fiasco 9y agoI think this post is the one that is most relevant to what you mentioned about politization: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/11/04/ethnic-tension-and-meaningless-arguments/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/11/04/ethnic-tension-and-mean... As for Damore, it looks like he is being advised by socially savvy people. A nobody who expressed that opinion and didn't attract the attention of powerful allies would get fired unceremoniously without us ever hearing about them.
- asddddd 9y agoIf you're genuinely interested in how someone could view the situations as equivalent, here's one post (regrettably long, but I haven't found better): http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2009/01/gentle-introduction-to-unqualified.html http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2009/01/gentle-... Kolmogorov also becomes more relatable if you consider Damore's computer-science-related activities at Google science, and the role he's now cast into as politics. We don't execute, but we can blacklist and exclude. (Consider what might happen if he wanted to present a paper at a conference.)
- quanticle 9y agoIn modern Western thought voices aren't suppressed Well, "incorrect" voices are still suppressed. There are still things you can't say [1]. The first question is whether the number of things you can't say is greater today in the West than it is elsewhere or it was in the past. The second question is whether that number is increasing or decreasing over time. In fact, the assertion that we don't punish speech is a pernicious one, because it puts the burden on the other person to prove you wrong... at which point you can punish them! [1]: http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html