4 ms·
And nobody cares to give you a good adblocking solution out of the box. Google makes money by ads so I guess they'll never change that. I agree with everything
by pdimitar 9y ago
And nobody cares to give you a good adblocking solution out of the box. Google makes money by ads so I guess they'll never change that.
I agree with everything else said. Android is just a half-done OS in any regard I can think of. My Xiaomi Mi 6 is awesome, beautiful and very snappy but Android's idiosyncrasies are visible everywhere:
- I have a gigabit internet that gives me 50 MB/s (yes, megabytes, not megabits) to USA which is halfway around the globe but the Play Store still manages to lag.
- My GPS can find my location in 1.5 secs max (there are dedicated apps to test that) yet most apps that go through Google's Location Services consistently need 10+ seconds (a full minute is not a rarity as well) to report a location back to the apps.
- Still no native themes. If you don't like white or if it's hurting your eyes, well, tough luck. Pray your OEM offers them. Luckily Xiaomi does. (Objectively, iOS is at fault here as well; they're trying with the Smart Invert Colors feature and it's decent, by the way, but still long way to go)
- Still no good support for volume controls; if you want to decrease media volume, most of the time you end up decreasing phone call volume. Like, seriously. It's 2017.
- Idle battery life. Damn it, why the hell must I lose 20-30% of battery when out and about with 90-98% cell signal and never unlocking my phone? Why? I had a work iPhone 5s around a year and a half ago and it was full of apps I used for work -- at least 20. I go out, do real-life stuff for 3 hours, come back home. Android lost 25% battery. iOS lost 3%. And then people wonder why iPhone fans love their phones. It's not only about being fans. There are real, measurable reasons.
- ...There are others but let's not make this a book.
After installing a VPN app that filters traffic I was just astounded. I use my smartphone on average 2.5 hours a day and holy shit, that's ~17000 ad/tracker requests blocked a day!
Android is overhyped and clumsy. And the efforts of Google lately are laughable, incomplete and are coming too late. And oh yes, they absolutely are a desperate reaction to the inevitable huge success of the iPhone X.
- nunez 9y agoAdguard worked extremely well and doesn’t require root privileges
- pdimitar 9y agoUsing DNS66, also very happy with it. Thank you for the recommendation.
- khedoros1 9y agoThe volume controls used to be better; they didn't try guessing which volume you wanted to change by context. They've changed things for the worse since then. My battery's pretty small (2150 mAh), and I've spent about half an hour today playing games. Pulled the phone off the charger at about 8:30, and it's 16:00 now. Power's at 81%. The iPhone 6 would be a little higher, granted. I wish Android were better, but out of the available options, it suits my needs the closest.
- voltagex_ 9y agoWhat kind of mobile network do you use? LTE or 3G? What signal strength do you have where you spend most of your day? Where I work has terrible LTE (and previously terrible HSPA) and every phone I've had has noticeably worse battery drain while I'm at my desk.
- khedoros1 9y agoReasonable, but not great, LTE.
- Nition 9y agoThere are features that both Android and iOS are missing that old pre-2007 phones had as well, e.g. - Profiles where you can set custom volume, vibrate, and sometimes other settings. e.g. "Home", "Vibrate", "Silent". And easily customise + switch between them. - Alarms that work when the phone is off. Set your alarm to wake you up, turn your phone off, and the alarm sounds in the morning. Lots of old phones had this feature. My Nokia N9 and Jolla smartphone had it too.
- viraptor 9y ago> Profiles where you can set custom volume, vibrate, and sometimes other settings. e.g. "Home", "Vibrate", "Silent". And easily customise + switch between them. There are many Android apps which provide this functionality. It doesn't need to be a part of the system.
- pdimitar 9y agoThat's okay but I see too many people evangelizing "the pure Android experience", yet they have to compensate for a lack of certain features with apps. We can also treat this as Google not giving much fucks, I think. Not only as "the pure experience". Let's be objective to the both sides of the argument. IMO though, everything that adds everyday convenience must be a part of the system. Did you forget these phones are sold to people who have trouble tying their shoe laces? All the casual quality of life improving apps MUST STARE THESE PEOPLE IN THE FACE from the get go. They shouldn't jump through hoops. Maybe you shouldn't look at the Pixels as improved Nexii. Google is aiming for a wider audience now.
- viraptor 9y ago> All the casual quality of life improving apps MUST STARE THESE PEOPLE IN THE FACE from the get go. The issue you'll run into is that everybody has a different idea of a life improving app. You can't cater to everybody and make their choice the default. Google does a pretty decent job elevating the truly popular apps to the default status: see flashlight, night mode, hotspotting, photo filters, etc. But your life quality app is not my life quality app - and that's ok. That's the place where apps step in.
- kllrnohj 9y agoYou're using a Xiaomi Mi 6, a heavily hacked up and forked Android. Why are you hoisting all the blame on Android instead of on Xiaomi? You're running a completely different OS from AOSP, so why are you pretending your critiques are globally applicable to all builds of Android?
- rrix2 9y agoBecause most of them are?
- kllrnohj 9y agoMost of them certainly aren't true on my Pixel XL. Play store loads immediately, GPS locks immediately, idle battery life is excellent, volume controls consistently adjust whatever is playing, etc... GP's list of complaints also don't apply. My AOSP Pixel XL never lags, has no malware, the UI is great, and it doesn't feel cheap at all. Reviews all match my experience as well, so I don't have any reason to believe I somehow got a golden lucky device. It seems far more likely that Xiaomi's implementation is just garbage, particularly since OEMs have a well established history of fucking this up. The only complaints that match my experience are no native themes and no good ad block solution, but I also think native themes are a terrible idea. It seems op just wants dark mode instead of native themes anyway, but Android sort of has that it's just called night mode instead.
- pdimitar 9y agoI forgot to mention I used 13 Androids over the last 5 years, of several brands. The Mi 6 is actually the best experience I had so far, by the way. I see you lean heavily towards Google's take on devices which is okay. But right in this thread people recommend apps to fix things that are missing from the pure Android. That is... not very okay. When I used Samsung, they had a mini app for everything. Even their clock / alarm / stopwatch / timer app was extremely easy and convenient to use. It's hard to quantify, it's a feeling that adds up over time. I also happen to think the Pixels take away too many features. microSD slots used to be one of the differentiating features of Android devices over iPhones, for example. Now we don't have that and we also no longer have a headphone jack, a decision that was widely frowned upon even by iPhone fans. To me, as a mostly neutral side observer who never was fanboying on neither platform, it looks like Google is trying to emulate Apple, and is failing.
- ericd 9y agoHave you tried a Pixel? Xiaomi isn't running vanilla Android.
- pdimitar 9y agoI am not impressed by the Pixels. They take away key differentiators that made Android the better choice in the past -- microSD slot, and now the headphone jack -- and are pitched mostly on their "AI" apps. Add to this the current drama with the XL 2 having burn-in screen issues on week one and IMO Google shot themselves in the foot.
- ericd 9y agoEh I find the voice assistant to be much better than Siri, and their preemptive AI assistance to be pretty spot on. Given the strengths of the two company, I think this gap will grow. Conversely, Apple is obviously much better at hardware and they have better taste when it comes to design. It depends on what you care about.
- pdimitar 9y agoVoice assistants, hm. Knowing Google and Amazon and having in mind their history, I won't trust them not eavesdropping on me and my wife having sex, ever. I do care about privacy. Google and Amazon care about data collection and ad dollars. They'll do absolutely anything to get those, including stuff we find amoral. Most businesses are like this: "it ain't illegal if you don't get caught". Please deny it! ;) I think we all know it's true. History has shown it time and again. Simple math, really. I am not losing anything in my life if I spend 20 seconds typing a query in a browser. I don't need to order goods with my voice. Voice assistants have a few good uses but in 90% of the time they are a solution looking for a problem. I get that some folks feel special and living in the future but that's hardly worth giving up your privacy at your own home. As you said -- personal priorities.
- viraptor 9y ago> 50 MB/s (yes, megabytes, not megabits) to USA which is halfway around the globe but the Play Store still manages to lag. Bandwidth is not latency. If you're in APAC, the only thing that will help you is if Google opens a mirror of play store nearby. (Unless it's software latency and everybody gets the same behaviour) > Still no native themes. Version 8 opened some new possibilities over adb. Hopefully fully accessible by v.9. > if you want to decrease media volume, most of the time you end up decreasing phone call volume https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.tomwandroid.rockerlocker https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.tomwandroi... > I use my smartphone on average 2.5 hours a day and holy shit, that's ~17000 ad/tracker requests blocked a day! If you think that's os dependent - it's not. I get that there are various issues people spot and they can be annoying. But a lot of that is familiarity with the system. Use iPhone for a few months and you'll find a lot of issues as well - it's not like it's flawless.
- pdimitar 9y agoWith Android, it's always "maybe next year", man. One gets tired of it. You're pointing me at apps. But I keep hearing Nexus/Pixel folk praise "the pure experience". Something doesn't add up. ;) And yes iPhone is far from flawless, I completely agree. But I'll take improved privacy and better battery life.
- viraptor 9y ago> You're pointing me at apps. But I keep hearing Nexus/Pixel folk praise "the pure experience". Something doesn't add up. Yes, you're bringing up "Nexus/Pixel folk" like some kind of homogenous group thinking of the same ideas and think I belong to it. Neither one is true - you're projecting your ideas.
- pdimitar 9y agoI have to say, my discussions with Nexus/Pixel fans have usually been awful. Sorry. Habits I am guessing.
- bubblethink 9y ago>And nobody cares to give you a good adblocking solution out of the box. Google makes money by ads so I guess they'll never change that. I've never used an apple device, but does apple give you that ? The problem you are describing is a general one due to overlapping roles of all hardware and software makers. Everyone wants ad and data money.
- pdimitar 9y agoFinally a good point in this mini-thread. Yes they don't do it as well. However, Safari claims to block some trackers by default which is still a win for the average consumer who won't ever fiddle with settings. Safari allows you to use an adblocker (Firefox Focus). Chrome on Android doesn't have such settings and I suspect it won't ever have them. They plan to add adblocking but knowing Google, they'll use that feature to axe their competition, not to protect their users. As for me, I'll just setup a VPN in my Mikrotik router and will add all widely known DNS blacklists to it (~53000 hosts). As mentioned above, I am not too keen of my devices doing 17000 ad/tracking requests a day, Android or iOS. So yes, sadly to this day people have to jump through hoops to take back some (most?) or their privacy and not donate their internet traffic to corps who only want to farm your data.
- bitmapbrother 9y ago>And nobody cares to give you a good adblocking solution out of the box. Google makes money by ads so I guess they'll never change that. No widely used OS give you a ad blocking solution out of the box - desktop or mobile. >I agree with everything else said. Android is just a half-done OS in any regard I can think of. My Xiaomi Mi 6 is awesome, beautiful and very snappy but Android's idiosyncrasies are visible everywhere: You're using an old version of Android that was butchered by a Chinese OEM. I realize you have an attitude towards Google, but these "idiosyncrasies" seem to be with your cheap Chinese phone. You get what you pay for. >My GPS can find my location in 1.5 secs max (there are dedicated apps to test that) yet most apps that go through Google's Location Services consistently need 10+ seconds (a full minute is not a rarity as well) to report a location back to the apps. My phone also picks up my GPS location very quickly and significantly less than 10 seconds. If your phone does take 10 seconds to get a GPS signal then you may want to talk to call your Chinese OEM support line. >Still no good support for volume controls; if you want to decrease media volume, most of the time you end up decreasing phone call volume. Like, seriously. It's 2017. Decreasing your media volume is a tap away when you press the volume button. And if you want to directly control the media button with your volume buttons there are many free apps that will do that. >Idle battery life. Damn it, why the hell must I lose 20-30% of battery when out and about with 90-98% cell signal and never unlocking my phone? Why? I had a work iPhone 5s around a year and a half ago and it was full of apps I used for work -- at least 20. I go out, do real-life stuff for 3 hours, come back home. Android lost 25% battery. iOS lost 3%. And then people wonder why iPhone fans love their phones. It's not only about being fans. There are real, measurable reasons. I can tell you haven't used iOS 11 recently. I use it everyday on my iPhone and iPad and it's been very bad on battery. As for Android, standby time is very good on 7 and even better on 8. Unfortunately, I doubt your Chinese phone gets OS updates let alone security updates. >There are others but let's not make this a book. Please do. >After installing a VPN app that filters traffic I was just astounded. I use my smartphone on average 2.5 hours a day and holy shit, that's ~17000 ad/tracker requests blocked a day! Are you new to technology? What your blocking are browser ads and app ads. Do you think iOS is immune to ads and trackers? >Android is overhyped and clumsy. And the efforts of Google lately are laughable, incomplete and are coming too late. It sounds like you're frustrated by your cheap Chinese phone. >And oh yes, they absolutely are a desperate reaction to the inevitable huge success of the iPhone X. You should really get an iPhone considering all of the issues you have with your Chinese phone.