9 ms·
Please Stop Writing Secure Messaging Tools (2015)
- zeta0134 9y agoLooks like this site is being hugged to death, Google's cache works though: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:pwT4ikbpSd4J:https://dymaxion.org/essays/pleasestop.html+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:pwT4ik...
- deckar01 9y agoArchive.org cache: https://web.archive.org/web/20161019151428/https://dymaxion.org/essays/pleasestop.html https://web.archive.org/web/20161019151428/https://dymaxion....
- pdimitar 9y agoThis link is more recent: https://web.archive.org/web/20171015070908/https://dymaxion.org/essays/pleasestop.html https://web.archive.org/web/20171015070908/https://dymaxion....
- phyzome 9y agoI love that list of needed tools!
- vfranco 9y agoI am hoping for recommendations based on that list to show up
- PriyaPunjabi 9y agoFor metadata protecting applications I would check out ricochet.im, briar, and i2pbote.
- PriyaPunjabi 9y agoI would love to know of an encrypted cloud based document editor. Something like googledocs but with privacy. Does anyone know of something like this?
- EGreg 9y agoI totally agree with this guy, but who is he in the industry? Someone famous for something? Just curious.
- gumby 9y ago> I totally agree with this guy, but who is he in the industry? This "guy" is a security professional; her linkedIn profile shows her working in serious security roles for over a decade.
- empthought 9y agoYes, you can see Eleanor speaking at a conference at https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=zqnQ0Mvi-as https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=zqnQ0Mvi-as.
- King-Aaron 9y ago> This "guy" is a security professional; her This might be something more colloquial to Australians than [wherever you "guys" are posting from], but to me when I see someone referring to 'guys' (as in, "hey guys!", or, "you know, those guys") it isn't always gender specific. You can go up to a group of women and say "hi guys!". I'm going to gloss over the part where OP then referred to the author as "he", but I just feel that the word "guy" is more and more moving away from meaning "men" and instead just "people". I'll leave that two cent coin on the table for you guys
- gumby 9y agoSure, that’s often the case, and I would even have given the usage the benefit of the doubt but then, as you noted, OP said “he”. But in fact “guy” means “man or woman” the way “he” can mean “man or woman” or how someone will say “ethnic” to mean “non-white. It doesn’t mean the sayer is a sexis/racist/jerk/etc, but it does subtly and casually reinforce a way of looking at the world. So worth correcting without making a huge thing of it. And yes I’m an Aussie (...and as I was continually reminded as a kid, and sometime still am, I’m a wog too)
- 9y ago
- throwa34943way 9y ago> Because we have too many other tools we also need. Yes, but secure messaging is a well understood domain I suppose so it's the kind of app that is simple(not easy) to write and most tools compete on UX. A lot of tools on the list at the end have complex domains that are not that well understood by stock developers, or they might require a lot of R&D or actually talking to teams that have a problem to solve. Furthermore it is extremely difficult to market a lot of these tools to corporations. IM? it's fairly easy. The situation with secure messaging apps today isn't so different than social networks in the 2000's. It's a formula and it's easier to raise capital on that formula at the moment.
- vxNsr 9y agoI would think that at least half of the domains mentioned are being used in some way by developers. So it's entirely possible to dogfood them. Some examples I know I've used: PMS, Wiki, Calendar, VFM. I'd love a good group password vault, so far I've come up empty for something open source...
- kcmastrpc 9y agohttps://bitwarden.com https://bitwarden.com self-hosted / free / open-source password vault. extensions for every major browser out there (edge / ff 57)
- pingiun 9y agoI think matrix forms a nice basis for a secure chat platform. Only the apps are not really all that good. The desktop apps are electron based and the android app is just not up to par with telegram or WhatsApp.
- DiThi 9y agoIn a lot of regards, the "not up to par" part of riot.im or matrix is the lack of a contact list (or simulated equivalent with same UX). IMHO it's the usability problem #1, and the reason for our team not to switch yet. The issue[0] should receive more attention. [0] https://github.com/vector-im/riot-web/issues/4488 https://github.com/vector-im/riot-web/issues/4488
- Arathorn 9y agothis isn't strictly true - there's a new generation of desktop apps which are native Qt and looking really nice, e.g. https://github.com/mujx/nheko https://github.com/mujx/nheko. In terms of the Android app; we're working on it as fast as we can (but it's a one man team atm).
- drdaeman 9y agoI don't know if it's the app, server or protocol problem but the last time I've evaluated Matrix (Sep 19, based on logs) as a possible Telegram/WhatsApp/Skype/Discord replacement there were some weird issues with "Unable to decrypt: The sender's device has not sent us the keys for this message" even after both parties verifying the fingerprints. I've used a desktop/Electron Riot client, the other party had used the web version. Restarting the Riot had helped me to see the new messages, but not the old ones (which feels to be a correct behavior in regards to PFS). The actual problem is other party didn't knew I had issues receiving their messages until I've contacted them out-of-band - conversation looked just normal from the other side (except for me writing "test test" and not replying any meaningfully). We ended up with a decision to try Matrix again sometimes later. Like, next year.
- gumby 9y agoThe essay I wish she had written would have said, "we don't need more 'secure messaging systems' -- we should be making all the following tools secure by design" For example, (and whether you love them or hate them) Apple takes this seriously: your fingerprints don't leave the device and are implemented by a piece of hardware in such a way that even Apple doesn't have access to them. Compare that to the Android implementations which have fingerprints in the filesystem. I'm not intending to hold them up as some paragon, simply showing that securing information is more than just a messaging issue.
- izacus 9y agoWhat? Google CTS demands that devices store fingerprints in TEE and they never can touch filesystem. Where did you get the idea that fingerprints are stored on a filesystem?! O.o (Android Fingerprint HAL document: https://source.android.com/security/authentication/fingerprint-hal https://source.android.com/security/authentication/fingerpri... ) (Note that the document allows storing fingerprints on FS, but they must be additionally encrypted. Better devices do not do that.)
- gurkendoktor 9y agoGoogle may theoretically demand that, but: https://betanews.com/2015/08/11/htc-and-samsung-phones-storing-unencrypted-fingerprints/ https://betanews.com/2015/08/11/htc-and-samsung-phones-stori...
- zaroth 9y agoSounds like you are agreeing then with gumby.
- gumby 9y agoIf you read through the TEE design requirements the goal is DRM, and data exchange (not just a handshake) is permitted. Apple uses a dedicated mechanism so that the entire path (sensor->authentication) is hidden from apple by physically bonding the pieces together. This is why, when you get your screen replaced, you have to teach your phone your prints again: they are gone. The Android CTS permits a path from the sensor to the trusted environment, a path which could be subject to interception. The need for a trusted path has been well understood since the 1960s at least (and its roots run back through the "break" key on the teletype); it's reflected in the rainbow books and of course in the design of Multics. Plenty of people at Google understand this well; some of them even participated in writing those rainbow books! You can ship a device without passing CTS and it is very common (though TBF, things like my Mavic drone don't have a thumbprint sensor). And just a few months ago, HTC shipped a phone with unencrypted fingerprints: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/aug/10/htc-fingerprints-world-readable-unencrypted-folder https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/aug/10/htc-finge... Again, I'm not holding Apple up as some paragon, it was simply the example I used to point out the importance of security design at depth, defense at depth, and integration into all aspects of a system.
- pudo 9y agoThat list is pure genius. I'm working with reporters mostly in non-OECD countries, 80% of the stuff on that list are real, largely unmet needs. Signal isn't perfect, but it works fine, thanks. A special place in hell should also be reserved for those in the tech world that mix up security (a real and critical need that people have) and their software politics. If you don't like Microsoft, Google, Adobe, "the Cloud", or smart phones, that's fine. There are plenty of reasons. But don't short circuit security assessments in the interest of promoting technology you find politically superior.
- m3rc 9y agoSignal is honestly pretty close. The "failures" are usually design choices that would only affect actual infosec people, which the developers are explicitly not trying to court.
- yamba789 9y agoIt's a helpful list, but I don't actually agree... Reporting isn't a high-tech job, and most of the suggestions to me seemed unnecessary. Document-sharing with edits being tracked is the big one, though (like the article raised). Also, Signal being tied to a phone number is a nightmare.
- peterburkimsher 9y agoThink about the "free" apps we're all using that are on that list, and wonder what Google and Apple are doing with the personal information in there. Calendaring system: Google Calendar, iCal Contacts databases: GMail Contacts, Apple Contacts Location coordination tools: Google Latitude, Find My Friends. Some of those programs don't exist, as far as I'm aware. A Wiki/Etherpad/Word style change tracking mashup, and Map-based storytelling and analysis systems are two that I'd like to see implemented.
- pudo 9y ago> Reporting isn't a high-tech job I disagree. Sitting on a phone and sweet-talking sources isn't high-tech, and neither is bundling up five tweets to make a clickbait. But as soon as you're talking about doing public records research, tracking the activities and ownership of a multi-national company, working in a team with people from 30 countries on a single story, try to manage your confidential evidence across five years, it becomes quite technical.
- dokument 9y agoBandwidth and local storage considerations are missing from this. All of those features are great, but if my decentralized application uses all of my available bandwidth and disk space, then it is not very great. This is very relevant because decentralized means that all that centralized storage and bandwidth needs to split up and amplified to account for offline users.
- t0mbstone 9y agoJust use Keybase!
- subway 9y agoI can't help but get an embrace, extend, extinguish vibe from keybase. It was a nifty key discovery service initially, but more and more feels like a closed platform, and gives me a sense of deja vu akin to XMPP on GTalk.
- dasil003 9y agoI get what you're saying, but realistically PGP will never cross the chasm, so there was not really a viable business there. I like that they have integrated it, but are moving in a direction that lowers the barrier to entry. There are risks to be sure, but it feels like the most promising of the secure messaging platforms.
- wiml 9y agoI have to agree — I was excited about Keybase, but my interest vanished as soon as they became yet another place to have an account rather than being a way to discover and semi-trust existing identities.
- hdhzy 9y agoIt's also worth noting that there are Keybase alternatives in the works, e.g. Linked Identities [0] for proofs about social accounts (Github, Twitter etc.) that just utilizes OpenPGP, and Key Transparency [1] for tracking changes in keys. [0]: https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-vb-openpgp-linked-ids-01 https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-vb-openpgp-linked-ids-01 [1]: https://security.googleblog.com/2017/01/security-through-transparency.html https://security.googleblog.com/2017/01/security-through-tra...
- egberts 9y agoSounds like it would have benefited the large state actors to have less secured messaging tools around...
- pdimitar 9y agoarchive.org mirror: https://web.archive.org/web/20171015070908/https://dymaxion.org/essays/pleasestop.html https://web.archive.org/web/20171015070908/https://dymaxion....