38 ms·
Threat model, threat model, threat model. There are some people for whom "The government is literally after me, personally" is a valid threat model. There are
by geofft 9y ago
Threat model, threat model, threat model.
There are some people for whom "The government is literally after me, personally" is a valid threat model. There are some people for whom "Google employees with privileged access to Gmail are conspiring to be after me, personally" (one assumes there's a two-person rule for access to individual inboxes or deploying code that scans inboxes) is also a valid threat model.
However, those people should consider that the government will be willing to use either software 0-days or algorithmic 0-days to attack them (see e.g. Stuxnet taking out Iran's nuclear program using a previously unknown method of generating SHA-1 collisions, that looked kind of like how the academic community knew to generate collisions but with a different fingerprint), in the government case. Or that any interaction with anyone who uses Google must be avoided, in the Google case. See e.g. https://mako.cc/copyrighteous/google-has-most-of-my-email-because-it-has-all-of-yours https://mako.cc/copyrighteous/google-has-most-of-my-email-be...
For normal people (which includes me and probably everyone else commenting here)? Google seems at least as likely, probably a tiny bit more, to protect me from threats like "A personal relationship has gone bad and someone who isn't a government and isn't Google is trying to impersonate be me" or "I don't want to lose access to my email" (remember that availability is a part of security!).
- jstanley 9y ago> "I don't want to lose access to my email" (remember that availability is a part of security!). Really? You've heard just as many stories of unexpected Google account closures as I have. I'm quite confident ProtonMail just don't do that. And if they did, you'd have a much more credible chance of talking to a human and rectifying the situation.
- datawarrior 9y agoActually ProtonMail does do this. They can't read your email so they can't know if you're actually abusing it via their terms of service. Thus if you file complaints against users ProtonMail will actually suspend the account without evidence until you clear your name. It's abused fairly regularly in fact.
- tonyztan 9y agoHmm... Could you provide a source? I don't think they do this. At least not for paid accounts with a long history.
- datawarrior 9y agoCan start here: https://twitter.com/protonmail/status/900097982212845570 https://twitter.com/protonmail/status/900097982212845570 There are a lot of cases but I'm at work and can't spend too much time collecting much. The gist however is that they are bound by Swiss speech laws, which are very ambiguous. "Inciting violence" is one such example, but of course, they can't see what you are supposedly inciting, so they suspend you.
- jstanley 9y agoThat's not a very compelling example.
- geofft 9y agoThat is a pretty good counterargument, and I do think that you should count that risk when evaluating Google's security. But I think there are lots of other options besides ProtonMail that will do the same. (I pay $50/year for Pobox.com, personally, and vaguely feel like paying a bit of money for my email instead of relying on a free service is worthwhile.)
- zabuni 9y agoI think what's telling here is that the blog post does not point to Protonmail's own threat model. https://protonmail.com/blog/protonmail-threat-model/ https://protonmail.com/blog/protonmail-threat-model/ Which says don't use it if you are up against state actors and: "Sensitive business communications – You have sensitive business information that you want to make sure is protected from competitors and other malicious parties. For example, you fear a competitor may want to sue you under false pretenses to get access to sensitive data. In this case, ProtonMail offers a great deal of protection. ProtonMail will not release ANY data unless provided with an enforceable Swiss court order. To get such an order, the case must first work its way through the Swiss courts where stricter privacy laws might result in a different ruling. Even if an adversary went through the expensive and time consuming procedure of obtaining such an order, ProtonMail’s zero access cryptography means we would only be able to release data that is encrypted since we do NOT hold the decryption keys." Given that they have Javascript to handle the decryption keys, couldn't they demand ProtonMail change the code delivered to your browser session to give up the keys? This would make the only extra security provided by this scheme would be the multiple court jurisdictions and the less tested legality of a court order making their product less secure, ala the FBI and Apple.
- Canada 9y agoThis attack actually happened years ago at a company called Hushmail. Law enforcement had the encrypted email provider serve malicious code to the target which leaked the secret key.
- kevinconaway 9y ago> see e.g. Stuxnet taking out Iran's nuclear program using a previously unknown method of generating SHA-1 collisions, that looked kind of like how the academic community knew to generate collisions but with a different fingerprint) To my knowledge, it was Flame that did this not Stuxnet, and it was an attack on MD-5, not SHA-1 [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flame_(malware) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flame_(malware)
- ekianjo 9y ago> "I don't want to lose access to my email" (remember that availability is a part of security!). Arent there many (difficult to judge how many) cases of people losing access to their Google account, and therefore about everything they had online (photos, email, videos, etc...). That is also scary enough, especially when it happens randomly with no clear reason why and the support of Google seems to be limited to sending info via forms in the hope of a future human interaction.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> the support of Google seems to be limited to sending info via forms in the hope of a future human interaction People underestimate the power of a calm, deliberate letter sent by post with an elected representative or two copied.
- linkregister 9y agoWhy include the elected representatives? Is that an implied threat of “reinstate my email or these legislators will regulate you into being a public utility”?
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Why include the elected representatives? It shows you're serious. Most people complain to blow off steam. This is what customer service handles. If you want something done at the corporate policy level, e.g. to have policy changed or have a decision made per policy reversed, you attack at higher levels. The traditional form of leverage is legal. Have a lawyer pen a letter gets you out of customer service. It is as effective as it is expensive. Next best is a regulator (you can think of these as narrowly-scoped, publicly-funded lawyers). Unfortunately, nobody regulates Google. So your final threat is getting a lawmaker pissed off with you. This is less about passing legislation (it's hard to pass legislation; everyone knows that) than creating an official, reliably-corroborated paper trail which could go public, causing PR damage, and/or damage relationships the company may want to lean on in the future. More practically, I don't want to sit around writing and responding to letters. Having someone else do the back and forth with me Cc'd is more pleasant. Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer. This is not legal advice. If you need legal advice, contact a lawyer.
- ploggingdev 9y ago> "Google employees with privileged access to Gmail are conspiring to be after me, personally" I thought employees do not have access to user data. Can anyone comment on this?
- cisanti 9y agoIf there is a will, there is a way. It's all about trust, but I'm sure st least publicly they have stated employees do not have that access.
- zabuni 9y agoIt's happened before: https://techcrunch.com/2010/09/14/google-engineer-spying-fired/ https://techcrunch.com/2010/09/14/google-engineer-spying-fir... If a person has enough access, and they have to, given that someone has to have admin access.
- joshuamorton 9y agoWorth noting that this occurred in 2009 (ie when gmail looked like this: https://1.bp.blogspot.com/_ZaGO7GjCqAI/SYD3g8LflXI/AAAAAAAAO4I/tH0-Ftb5P2o/s640/gmail-outbox.png https://1.bp.blogspot.com/_ZaGO7GjCqAI/SYD3g8LflXI/AAAAAAAAO...).
- londons_explore 9y agoAround 100 people have root @ Google. They get a tshirt with it on. With months of effort researching tripwires and auditing systems, any of them could read your mail. There's a pretty good chance they'd get caught by some auditing or alerting system they were unaware of though. Many of those systems are kept secret from employees for obvious reasons. Any two employees collude to much more easily read your mail. There's probably ~1000 people in that position (not only the gmail team, but anyone who writes any kind of library code used by any of the databases, datastores, or application servers). They would leave audit records though, although they might go unnoticed.
- DINKDINK 9y ago
- the_stc 9y agoOur company is not legal (details in profile). We chose Protonmail to start because our biggest concern was getting our emails served to the government on request down-the-line. We pay a significant monthly charge to use their services and feel it is worth every penny. A lot of people in our industry and others have this same model. It is not that the NSA is after you. It's local law enforcement. In our case, SEC and FBI. For average users, local LE will not have 0 days or anything special. Protonmail is out of reach for a lot of LE and that is important. The best choice for us when we're fully operational is to run a Protonmail-like setup, self-hosted. Deal with mail issues and spam. It is a pain!