4 ms·
That's what happens when we abandon protocols (RSS feeds) in favor of walled gardens.
by visarga 9y ago
That's what happens when we abandon protocols (RSS feeds) in favor of walled gardens.
- jkaljundi 9y agoRSS feed ads used to be quite a thing.
- cat199 9y agoquite a thing that you have the ability to filter if you wanted to..
- jasode 9y ago>That's what happens when we abandon protocols (RSS feeds) Yes, in general terms, there's always an abstract discussion about RSS vs Facebook,Twitter,Google AMP, etc. However, your particular comment is not relevant to this particular blog post. The RSS protocol is "free" but that doesn't matter if it does not address the targets that Facebook does. (Besides that, the journalist writes for DennikN and they didn't "abandon" the RSS feed. It's at: https://dennikn.sk/rss-odber/ https://dennikn.sk/rss-odber/) We can't just reflexively reply with "RSS" every time the trigger word "Facebook" comes up. It needs to be relevant. RSS is not applicable to what the journalist is talking about. RSS is not relevant to the perspective of the publisher for metrics of "audience reach". RSS feed is a convenience tool for the reader and the blog post isn't about that perspective.
- Frondo 9y agoRSS feeds aren't social. Social functionality might not be important to you, but it is very important to many, many people. (Services that graft social functionality onto RSS feeds could satisfy the same need, but then we're not talking about RSS feeds anymore...)
- r00fus 9y agoArguably, using social feed for ads isn't social either. It's advertisement. So the argument still stands. RSS was a much better mechanism to distribute updates and could have been made "social" if companies like Twitter and Facebook weren't intent on dominating that space.
- Mediterraneo10 9y agoIt is kind of understandable that RSS feeds would fade in prominence as content creators, even of more casual blogs, increasingly sought to monetize. RSS feeds tended to present successively posted content without the ads that site owners were keen to confront users with. A person subscribing to feeds would often never need to visit the actual site and see those ads, not would they get tagged by lucrative tracking cookies. Rather they could read everything "for free" through an RSS reader. Yes, you could introduce ads into the RSS feed, but when the RSS channel is increasingly seen as something for only a tiny niche of anoraks (especially since the demise of Google Reader), no surprise that it was no longer seen as worth the trouble.
- Crespyl 9y agoOr you could simply take the route that most monetized sites with RSS did, and only include the first few paragraphs of your content in the feed. Ars Technica still does this, and it strikes a good balance between letting the user see what content is available in the tool of their choice (and whether they'd be interested in reading more), and the site/publisher having control over how the complete articles are presented. Of course, this requires the site to actually have more than a paragraph worth of actual content for any given article.
- coryl 9y agoMy RSS feeds quickly became noisy dumps of data