4 ms·
In which case the definition of ritual becomes "any object or activity that isn't required for immediate survival needs", and it becomes meaningless. I would n
by marcus_holmes 9y ago
In which case the definition of ritual becomes "any object or activity that isn't required for immediate survival needs", and it becomes meaningless.
I would not describe a television as being used for "ritual purposes". It has a specific function and is used for a specific reason. If future archeologists cannot determine that function or describe that reason, then I would expect them to say "we don't know what this is used for", not "it was used for ritual purposes".
That's the thing that bugs me about it. If they said "we don't know" that'd be much more intellectually honest.
- OJFord 9y agoSo what's the definition to be? Must religion be involved? Drawing the lines around what is or is not religion is surely in itself a can of worms!
- marcus_holmes 9y agoNot necessarily religion: "a set of fixed actions and sometimes words performed regularly, especially as part of a ceremony" http://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/ritual http://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/ritual and yeah, determining what an ancient person would have thought of as religious, or not, or even ritual, would be tricky. but the point is that "rituals" (as opposed to "habits" or "customs and practices") make up a tiny part of our average day, and a tiny fraction of the objects we use. To suggest that ancient peoples spent vastly more of their time in rituals gives a completely erroneous impression of both the ancient people and their objects.