4 ms·
The main problem with it is that we cannot afford UBI. Back of the envelope calculations say we would go bankrupt within a year giving out just 500 PLN/month/pe
by AstralStorm 9y ago
The main problem with it is that we cannot afford UBI. Back of the envelope calculations say we would go bankrupt within a year giving out just 500 PLN/month/person. Which is way not enough to live on. A serious amount would be 4x that.
(Which would amount to about 100 billion PLN or 16 billion Euro or similar USD. Not counting overhead. Essentially eating a sizable chunk of GDP. Some ways to cut it would be free public housing and transport - where? How much?)
Even 500+ as currently implemented is too expensive. It is essentially financed by debt right now. And currently Poland is somewhere around 60% debt.
I suspect even USA cannot afford it long term given the state of debt. They had trouble even with public healthcare.
- ajuc 9y agoWe're giving 500 PLN a month to 3 800 000 people right now. If we scaled that to full population it would be 50 PLN. 6 times that (so - 300 PLN) isn't that big a stretch (especially that you get like half of that back in taxes from increased consumption). It's doable for a few years. Especially, if you cut some other social costs (but then it has to be more than 300 PLN per month).
- AstralStorm 9y agoAs I mentioned, 500+ is already financed by debt as the alleged other budget savings that were supposed to pay for it never materialised. (They amounted to populism.)