4 ms·
I tried to read the research article, but I'm not sure about the notation. One can of coke increase the risk a) from x% to x+18%? b) from x% to x*(1.18)%?
by gus_massa 9y ago
I tried to read the research article, but I'm not sure about the notation. One can of coke increase the risk
a) from x% to x+18%?
b) from x% to x*(1.18)%?
- viraptor 9y agoNeither seems reasonable. The a is definitely wrong, or 6 cans would give you diabetes guarantee, which is wrong. The b grows slower, but is still uncapped and speeds up as it grows.
- systoll 9y agoThe paper's conclusion that a can of coke per day is associated with a 'relative risk' of 1.18. That means X% -> x*(1.18)%, where X is whatever the baseline risk is. The blog introduces the result as increasing 'the likelihood of developing diabetes by 18%', which means the same thing. It then incorrectly translates this to a 'marginal chance of 18%' -- which means X% -> X+18%. And the math uses that. X%->X+18% is 'a marginal risk of 18%', or 'an increase of 18 percentage points' or 'a 0.18 increase in absolute risk'.