59 ms·
There's also an article on Ars Technica [1] about this. The Desert Team is skeptical of the idea that they were used for trapping animals for slaughter: > One
by tzs 9y ago
There's also an article on Ars Technica [1] about this.
The Desert Team is skeptical of the idea that they were used for trapping animals for slaughter:
> One hypothesis about the kites is that hunters herded animals into them for easy slaughter, but the Desert Team notes that the walls would have been too low to fence the animals in.
That makes sense if you are imagining that they chase the animals into the structure and then keep chasing them at full speed, so that the animals are running when they encounter the walls.
But is that how the people them would have hunted a herd? Try to chase it down at full speed?
Suppose instead that they were persistence hunters [2]. Persistence hunting takes advantage of two key differences between us and many herd animals.
• We are more effective at body cooling than they are.
• We can trot for a long time, even on a very hot day, at a speed that is too fast for the animal's efficient gaits, meaning it has to run to stay ahead.
A persistence hunter chases the animal just fast enough to make the animal run. The animal gets away, but its run is inefficient so it has to stop and rest. It also needs to cool down. The human just keeps coming, his more efficient body cooling allowing him to keep moving without overheating.
When the human gets close enough to force the animal to resume running, the animal is not fully recovered from the first round. It gets away again, but now is even more exhausted and overheated than it was the first time.
Repeat, and after a few hours of this the human can just walk right up and kill the animal, which is too tired to even try to further escape.
What it comes down to is humans are in fact one of the fastest land animals on the planet--over long distances. 100 meter race? We suck. 100 kilometer race? Bet on the human. Essentially persistence hunters make their prey engage in a long distance race with them.
This is quite effective, but it has an obvious drawback. You spend 4 or 5 hours chasing the animal away from your home. You are now several hours away from home, with a bunch of meat to carry back.
Perhaps the idea with these large fenced in areas is that you chase the herd in, but hang back far enough that when it gets to the far wall it thinks it has escaped pursuit and rests there instead of jumping. Then you circle around and come in from the back or the side, getting the herd to run across the field again, again timing it so that when it reaches another fence it stops.
Note that the fence does not have to tall enough or strong enough to stop the animals. It just has to be enough to make a tired animal that thinks it is now safe to rest decide that resting on this side is easier than resting on the other side.
You'll be giving the herd more rest time this way as opposed to with open field persistence hunting because of the extra time it takes to circle around the change direction, but that might be worth it because now you are chasing the herd back and forth instead of away. You'll have a much easier time hauling the meat back home.
[1] https://arstechnica.com/science/2017/10/archaeologists-are-mystified-by-ancient-gates-in-saudi-lava-fields/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2017/10/archaeologists-are-m...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persistence_hunting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persistence_hunting
- CryptoPunk 9y agoThe strategy you've propose doesn't seem likely to me. It would take a lot of effort to steer them to the kite, only to have to chase them out again to repeat the process. I think it's far more likely that they herded/chased them toward the kite, and from far enough away to keep them from scattering, and jumping over the stone 'walls', and when the herd traversed the kite, it gradually bunched up as it got closer to the point of the kite. At the point would be the kill zone, with hunters waiting to slaughter as many as possible.