5 ms·
Archaeologists are mystified by ancient “gates” in Saudi lava fields
- marcus_holmes 9y ago"Ritual Purposes" - the archeologist's get-out clause when they have no idea what something is used for. If they said these things were for hunting or agriculture, they'd have to explain how. But if they're for "rituals" then they don't have to explain what the use was or the ritual was. However it leaves us with an impression of ancient peoples as superstitious fools who spent vast amounts of time and energy building ritual objects with no practical purpose. Instead maybe we should be left with an impression of archeologist's massive ignorance about ancient culture.
- OJFord 9y agoOr just a broader interpretation of 'ritual'. The modern family sitting on a long soft bench at one end of a room facing some sort of oblong panel next to a tangle of wire, likely electrical, might be a 'ritual lost to time'.
- marcus_holmes 9y agoIn which case the definition of ritual becomes "any object or activity that isn't required for immediate survival needs", and it becomes meaningless. I would not describe a television as being used for "ritual purposes". It has a specific function and is used for a specific reason. If future archeologists cannot determine that function or describe that reason, then I would expect them to say "we don't know what this is used for", not "it was used for ritual purposes". That's the thing that bugs me about it. If they said "we don't know" that'd be much more intellectually honest.
- OJFord 9y agoSo what's the definition to be? Must religion be involved? Drawing the lines around what is or is not religion is surely in itself a can of worms!
- marcus_holmes 9y agoNot necessarily religion: "a set of fixed actions and sometimes words performed regularly, especially as part of a ceremony" http://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/ritual http://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/ritual and yeah, determining what an ancient person would have thought of as religious, or not, or even ritual, would be tricky. but the point is that "rituals" (as opposed to "habits" or "customs and practices") make up a tiny part of our average day, and a tiny fraction of the objects we use. To suggest that ancient peoples spent vastly more of their time in rituals gives a completely erroneous impression of both the ancient people and their objects.
- zabana 9y agoI wish I could upvote you another 100 times.
- cm2187 9y agoWell in 3000 years, archaeologists are going to have a hard time explaining the practical purpose of the statue of liberty.
- marcus_holmes 9y agoYes, they are. And if they don't know those practical purposes, I'd hope they'd have the honesty to say "we don't know".
- mcphage 9y ago> However it leaves us with an impression of ancient peoples as superstitious fools who spent vast amounts of time and energy building ritual objects with no practical purpose. Every culture spends vast amount of time and energy building ritual objects with no practical purpose. But that doesn't make them superstitious fools, that just makes them human beings with a culture, thus whose lives aren't entirely consumed by practical matters like survival. That's a good thing!
- xaedes 9y agoFrom someone in the ars comments: The 4th and the last image are fair matches to form and wall height of desert hunting kites of Central Asia seen here: https://news.nationalgeographic.com/2016/08/desert-kites-out-of-eden-walk-uzbekistan-iron-age-saiga/ https://news.nationalgeographic.com/2016/08/desert-kites-out... See especially this image: https://news.nationalgeographic.com/content/dam/news/rights-exempt/nat-geo-staff-graphics-illustrations/2016/08/desert_kites/Kite_traps04-Artboard_2.ngsversion.1470860356983.png https://news.nationalgeographic.com/content/dam/news/rights-... From the linked article (on nationalgeographic): “They make more sense when looked at from above,” says Shamil Amirov, an archaeologist who uses satellite imagery to map the colossal artifacts in western Uzbekistan. “Most are shaped like arrows. We have found them in chains across the migration trails of antelopes. They probably directed thousands of animals into killing pits.” In effect, Amirov says, Central Asia’s desert kites—named after similar triangular or kite-shaped features discovered earlier in the Middle East—were massive protein pumps. Built over generations by nomadic pastoralists some 2,500 years ago, the structures siphoned vast numbers of animals from the environment. ... Desert kites first came to the attention of science nearly a century ago, when World War I pilots reported low walls tracing gigantic polygons, funnels, and triangles across the sunbaked barrens of modern Jordan, Israel, Syria, and Saudi Arabia. Experts have been debating the function of these cryptic structures ever since.
- jdonaldson 9y agoThat has to be the purpose of the kites. I still wonder about the gates though. Those don't look useful for hunting. Especially the one on the volcanic mound.
- coda_ 9y agoIt seems they could have been designed as an attempt to guide, trap and pool lava that might otherwise flow toward settlements or other things of value. Didn't see that hypothesis in the article. Not sure how effective it would have been... But if your elders told stories of villages being wiped out by lava, you would probably try to do something to stop it.