4 ms·
> When is this going to stop? It feels like we're going backwards in terms of people understanding science. Who is there that is telling the public what the sc
by tzs 9y ago
> When is this going to stop? It feels like we're going backwards in terms of people understanding science.
Who is there that is telling the public what the science says and that the public can trust?
Government agencies and their scientists?
They often have a tendency to make recommendations based on weak science, and if they are regulating an industry with a lot of political influence they may even make recommendations that go against what the science says.
For an example take a look at dietary recommendations in the US. Almost everything that has gone into them has not held up. The public followed them, reduced fats, eggs, and protein, and loaded up on carbs...and became fat and diabetic.
How about non-government advocacy groups?
They botch it too. Continuing with the dietary recommendations example, the American Heart Association, for example, jumped on the unscientific "fat and cholesterol bad" bandwagon, and spent decades giving people harmful advice.
Industry scientists?
Their employers often get to decide what they publish, which means that although the industry scientists might not outright lie about results, they may remain silent about results that would go against their employer's interests.
Academic scientists?
This is probably your best bet. The problem here is that academic research is often not directly on point for the particular issue that regulators or legislators are addressing. Academic researchers are more likely to be doing the basic research that industry, government, and NGO researchers should be building upon.
- kobeya 9y agoWhy should people trust someone else instead of using their own brain to evaluate arguments?
- Larrikin 9y agoIt's impossible to become an expert in everything.
- ShabbosGoy 9y agoBut it is possible to apply Occam's Razor to a scientific hypothesis. Is it too much to ask to require people to read? And draw their own conclusions?
- int_19h 9y agoIt is, actually. It doesn't scale once you start talking about too many things at once. There's so much time one can spend reading. At some point, you just have to trust the experts (whoever you consider those to be) on many things.
- ShabbosGoy 9y ago> At some point, you just have to trust the experts (whoever you consider those to be) on many things. That's extremely dangerous IMO. If you have a populace that is not literate or engaged, you end up with a slave society. Just see the rise of the concept of a "thought leader" [1]. It's quite scary when you see the implications such a concept will have for society. [1] https://newrepublic.com/article/143004/rise-thought-leader-how-superrich-funded-new-class-intellectual https://newrepublic.com/article/143004/rise-thought-leader-h...
- int_19h 9y agoTo repeat, it's not physically possible to judge every single thing. It doesn't matter if you're literate and engaged - there's just not enough time, even if you were to spend every hour you have on this. And most people have jobs etc.
- kobeya 9y agoThis is simply not true. Once literate it often takes a minimal amount of effort — back of the envelope calculation or google search— to do a first pass test of the veracity of a source.
- lovich 9y agoYou're still relying on another party when you do a Google search, hell if you want to get crazy about it, you are relying that you were correctly taught literacy and that when you read a word, the meaning it has for you is the same meaning the author attributed to that word. It's not guaranteed
- Trundle 9y agoBecause not everyone wants to be some super nerd who reads studies 24/7.
- adreamingsoul 9y agoSo, what is your process to disprove wrong assumptions that you or someone else has?
- labster 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_method