3 ms·
Near as I can tell, [1] provides virtually no data beyond opinion polls, certainly none showing discrimination. [1] is also an advocacy piece written by people
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
Near as I can tell, [1] provides virtually no data beyond opinion polls, certainly none showing discrimination. [1] is also an advocacy piece written by people with a vested interest in finding discrimination, since it will get them more funding/chairs/office space/etc.
[2] seems to be a review of psychology, but whatever data they have on discrimination seems to be buried deep within the article (I only skimmed it). I skimmed [3], but it seems to have virtually no data on women in computing at all, and what it has seems concerned primarily with the 90's or earlier.
Then I gave up. I think you should read your sources before posting them.
I don't see a single source which, e.g., shows women outperforming men at the same level, which would be fairly concrete proof of discrimination.
- Confusion 16y agobut it seems to have virtually no data on women in computing at all, Are you asserting that we need to experimentally verify discrimination in every single new context one can think of? Usually, we generalize from other research: there is no reason to suppose CS is miraculously free of discrimination against women, considering the variety of areas in which this kind of discrimination has been shown exist. I don't see a single source which, e.g., shows women outperforming men at the same level, [..] Why do you have to outperform others before you can be discriminated against? The fact that they are being discriminated against is in itself a reason why they are unlikely to outperform the others.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoUsually, we generalize from other research: there is no reason to suppose CS is miraculously free of discrimination against women, considering the variety of areas in which this kind of discrimination has been shown exist. There is also no reason to assume that all or most of the gender gap is caused by discrimination. If we generalize, we discover that lots of other fields (e.g., medicine, law) have sexism, but they also have 50% women. Remember, we are asking what makes CS special. Why do you have to outperform others before you can be discriminated against? Suppose you are biased against green cars. You want to buy fast cars, and you generally only buy a car if it drives at least 80mph. However, since you hate green cars, green cars must drive at least at 100mph before you will consider buying one. Therefore, you will have plenty of slow (80-90mph) red cars, but your green cars will all drive at least as fast as 100mph. Substitute "women" for "green", "men" for "red", and "productivity" for "speed", and you'll see the same conclusion applies to workers.
- Confusion 16y agoIf we generalize, we discover that lots of other fields (e.g., medicine, law) have sexism, but they also have 50% women Firstly: in neither medicine, nor in law, are 50% of the graduate students women. Secondly: even when the number of students in the field is 50/50, that doesn't mean there is no discrimination. Here's a nice study about discrimination among students of medicine[1], the consequences of which you can guess. Remember, we are asking what makes CS special. No, that's what you are asking, because you assert that gender discrimination does not influence gender ratios in other studies and occupations, which is simply not true. Solely based on experimental observation of cognitive biases, it is extremely unlikely to be true. Women are always, everywhere, underrepresented in the top echelons. Even in nursing, there are more males in leadership roles than you would expect from the number of male nurses. [..] and you'll see the same conclusion applies to workers. Wait, what? The women have to perform better to be even considered and only if they are then rejected, then they are being discriminated against? It's the fact that they have to perform better in the first place that is the problem. You are already discriminating against green cars. That's the point. [1] http://pdfs.journals.lww.com/academicmedicine/2002/12000/Gender_Discrimination_and_Sexual_Harassment_in.18.pdf http://pdfs.journals.lww.com/academicmedicine/2002/12000/Gen... (BTW, I did an experiment here: I upvoted your comment some time ago. I have a feeling that in a discussion of 'score 1' comments, bumping one of them to '2' precipitates upvoting of the '2' and downvoting of the others)
- yummyfajitas 16y agoFirstly: in neither medicine, nor in law, are 50% of the graduate students women. Oops, my mistake. The actual numbers are 49% and 49.4%. http://www.aamc.org/data/aib/aibissues/aibvol6_no7.pdf http://www.aamc.org/data/aib/aibissues/aibvol6_no7.pdf http://www.lawschool.com/femalemajority.htm http://www.lawschool.com/femalemajority.htm The women have to perform better to be even considered and only if they are then rejected, then they are being discriminated against? You've completely misinterpreted what I said. Women overperforming at a given level is a consequence of discrimination, not a precondition. Discrimination is equivalent to a higher standard. If women (or any other group) are held to a higher standard than men, then they should overperform men. Another (non-emotionally loaded) example: colleges have a higher academic standard for regular students than for football players, equivalent to discriminating against non-football players. As a result, non-football players tend to perform academically better than football players. For this reason, I'd like to see a study that measures performance rather than opinion.