8 ms·
Oddly enough, I can share an anecdote too. After a health scare, I decided to change my diet. I didn't think that I was self disciplined enough to count calorie
by analog31 9y ago
Oddly enough, I can share an anecdote too. After a health scare, I decided to change my diet. I didn't think that I was self disciplined enough to count calories, so I arbitrarily eliminated certain things from my diet, most notably butter.
My exercise didn't change much: Cycling to work every day. I got a new bike, but it didn't make me go that much faster.
Within a few months, I went from 175 to 150 pounds (about 79 to 68 kg), and have kept it off.
Now, this goes against the current "ketogenic" hypothesis, and is actually kind of puzzling, but I realize that butter makes things tasty, and I was just eating a lot less food overall because it was less pleasant. So it probably was a reduction in carbs.
It took more than a year before I could enjoy a piece of toast without anything on it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- GordonS 9y agoIf butter is the only thing you removed from your diet, you must have been eating an incredible amount of it?!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- gtrubetskoy 9y agoThere is _no_ amount of butter (or fat, in general) that you can eat that will make you gain weight, provided there is no sugar in your diet. You will physically not be able to eat more than your body can deal with, this is because fat, unlike sugar, triggers the i-am-full hormones which make food impossible to eat.
- y4mi 9y agoNo, that is plain wrong. Calories count, no matter where they are from. Ketogenic diets might increase your metabolism and reduce your appetite and hunger, which makes weight loss easier, but you'll still gain weight if you eat too many fat calories each day. Even if you cut out carbs entirely.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- renaudg 9y ago"Calories count, no matter where they are from." This is the exact point the article is proving wrong.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoIt doesn't really prove it wrong. If you eat 3000 calories of butter every day, you're gonna get fat. In that sense, a calorie is a calorie.
- barkingtoad 9y ago"a calorie is a calorie" This is the exact point the article is... arguing against in a very convincing fashion
- y4mi 9y agoNo, the article is saying that people are getting obese and diabetic because of sugar. Its further pointing out that there are calories ("sugars") which make it much easier to gain weight. I didn't disagree there either. The article never claims that you can eat any amount of calories as long as you leave carbs from the table. And thats the only thing i pointed out. Because thats just plain wrong. If you eat too many calories, you will gain weight. And if you're predisposed to obesity, you will eat more calories when you're flavouring stuff with sugar. This will, as the author pointed out, cause you to get even more obese and eventually get diabetes.
- WillPostForFood 9y agoYou are getting lost in semantics, because if you are saying: there are calories ("sugars") which make it much easier to gain weight. Then a calorie isn't a calorie.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- y4mi 9y agoNo, butter makes the other stuff more delicious, making you eat just a little more each time.
- gras 9y agoDoesn't fat make food more satisfying, making you feel fulfilled sooner? Needs a citation I guess.
- bitexploder 9y agohttps://www.ncbi.nqlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10435117 https://www.ncbi.nqlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10435117 For most people high fiber foods are better.
- WillPostForFood 9y agoIt is a study of 14 people that self reported how hungry they were and how much they ate on their own. I don't think we can get to advice stating "most people" should do anything from that. It is an example of how bad science gets translated to bad advice and bad behavior. Not picking on you, you are responding rationally to a headline or blurb about the study. But it is a worthless study.
- bitexploder 9y agoThere are more studies. That was an example. Go look around for the others. Most importantly try it for yourself. It is pretty easy to figure out.
- ValentineC 9y agoI don't know why @gras's comment in this thread is marked as dead, but I agree with them. Reposting the question from the comment: > Doesn't fat make food more satisfying, making you feel fulfilled sooner?
- kbenson 9y ago
- analog31 9y agoAs I mentioned above, removing butter also resulted in the elimination of other things from my diet.
- nextos 9y agoPerhaps you removed bread?
- analog31 9y agoYes, that was probably a lot of it. I have no doubt that my caloric intake decreased more than just from butter, and next on the list would most likely be carbs. I started eating more of some other things such as lean meats and beans.
- nextos 9y agoI tend to think good quality butter, especially grassfed & unpasteurised, is very healthy in moderate amounts (great vitamin K2 source).
- Pxtl 9y agoImagine somebody whose favourite snack is a nice slice of baguette with butter slathered on it. By cutting butter, he's also effectively cut an unnecessary carb-heavy between-meal snack, since he doesn't want the baguette without the butter.
- atom-morgan 9y agoIt sounds like they learned to enjoy the plain bagel.
- Spare_account 9y agoI was just eating a lot less food overall because it was less pleasant. So it probably was a reduction in carbs. It literally says in the text that he ate less overall.
- Tehnix 9y ago> So it probably was a reduction in carbs No, it was a reduction in calories, quite simply. If anything, butter is very heavy on fats and low on carbs...
- kbutler 9y ago> It took more than a year before I could enjoy a piece of toast without anything on it. Sounds like in his particular case, reducing fat (butter) also reduced carbs (toast).
- dmichulke 9y agoFYI: The butter in my fridge has 743kcal per 100g. Could you share how much butter you bought per month and what the package size was?
- analog31 9y agoI'd estimate that my family of four was going through a pound of butter a week. As I mentioned above, I doubt that butter alone was the cause, since the butter was always accompanied by something else. My whole family has reduced our butter intake quite drastically, so I don't have a good estimate of how much I was personally consuming.
- alkonaut 9y agoBefore assigning top much blame on butter, remember that being on any diet, including e.g. taking only placebo diet pills, will lead to improvement. When you are on a diet you are on a diet you pay attention to what you are eating, and that helps in itself. This is probably why there are so many kinds of diet - most diets work.
- kbenson 9y agoIf I have to choose between "don't eat artificially added sugar but don't feel like I'm eating less" and "don't eat butter, and by extension eat less because food tastes worse", I can tell you I'll choose the former in a heartbeat.
- NegativeLatency 9y agoThe new bike could've made your commute more efficient.
- analog31 9y agoThe main difference was more closely spaced gears (9 instead of 3) allowing me to find a better cadence at higher speeds. So I was going faster and working harder. No free lunch. But it wasn't enough to account for my weight loss. My commuting is only about 1600 miles per year. Now I'm riding single speed, so who knows.
- SwellJoe 9y agoI remember reading a study that indicated that simple carbs combined with fat are worse than either fat or simple carbs alone. I can't find the study at the moment, but the gist of it was that a high fat, high sugar, meal will be metabolized differently than either in isolation and also that it triggers cravings for more fat and sugar. So, a keto diet is fine. Eating bread every now and then is fine. But, something like a fast food meal consumed with a sugary soda may be particularly unhealthy and may cause you to eat more and crave more similar foods. I don't know all the mechanisms at play, and I don't think even experts have a really good understanding of how our very complex digestive and metabolic systems (and the bacterial colonies that live in our guts) interact. It's clear that caloric reduction works for weight loss, even if you're eating mostly carbs or mostly fats. Some people report better management of cravings and hunger on different kinds of diets, and the research indicates that a low-fat or low-carb diet results in weight loss at about the same rate (contrary to popular belief about low-carb diets lately). Source: https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/wellness/low-carb-vs-low-fat-new-research-says-it-doesnt-really-matter/2017/07/13/270d2270-61c1-11e7-a4f7-af34fc1d9d39_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/wellness/low-carb-v... But, really, if you run a caloric deficit, you'll lose weight. Cutting arbitrary foods can do it for some folks. Some folks like keto or other relatively extreme restrictive diets. Some folks do intermittent fasting (I've been intermittent fasting for several months and have lost a little over 20 pounds). No matter how you do it, if you cut 500 calories off of your diet, you'll lose weight at a healthy clip.
- TrinaryWorksToo 9y agoI saw that study. I never saw if they kept the amount of protein people ate constant. Do you know? It seems mysteriously lacking the third macronutrient. And I can't tell from the article if there was a control "eat fat and carb" group.
- narag 9y agohttps://www.google.com/search?q=dissociated+diet https://www.google.com/search?q=dissociated+diet I remember seing a book about that diet 20 years ago by a singer: https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raffaella_Carr%C3%A0 https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raffaella_Carr%C3%A0