8 ms·
Is English insane? I'm a native German speaker so germanic languages feel rather "regular" to me, while I find romanic languages grammatically simpler but they
by k__ 9y ago
Is English insane?
I'm a native German speaker so germanic languages feel rather "regular" to me, while I find romanic languages grammatically simpler but they still feel more exotic to me.
- StavrosK 9y agoCompared to German, very much so. In German, you can read a word and know how it is pronounced, and hear a word and know how it's written. I'm not in love with the five noun declensions or the grammatical genders that aren't derived from the word itself, but I'll take them over a language that's a big ball of stolen words. I'd prefer something more regular over both of those, though, perhaps Spanish. I've also heard that Korean, Arabic and Japanese are super regular.
- k__ 9y agoI learned a bit Japanese and it was very regular, but your have to learn 3 alphabets. The first one, hiragana, is only for small "filler" words, the second one, katakana, is for foreign words that got somehow included into Japanese and the third one, kanji, has thousands of "letters" each for one word. While the first two are rather easy to learn, you can't read or write anything meaningful without kanjis. Many of my friends started studying Japanology and switched to Koreanology because it was easier :D
- schoen 9y ago> each for one word Not necessarily just "one word" as western language speakers would understand it, since each kanji usually has at least two readings and potentially many more, often with different meanings. (Other people have even compared them to morphemes because the same kanji can be used with related meanings in different multi-kanji words.)
- Gigablah 9y agoEven putting the writing system aside, there's multiple styles of speech too; casual, formal, super-formal, etc. There's also regional dialects. Not to mention Internet lingo.
- raverbashing 9y agoEnglish has historical spelling and that's pretty much all the crazy that there is to it The problem in German is not the declensions, it's how they mix and match Like 'der' can mean masculine in one case and feminine (or plural) in other cases. Or the 'er' ending can mean a lot of things. > I've also heard that Korean, Arabic and Japanese are super regular. I can't say anything about Korean but in Arabic it's common to drop vowels (they also have 2-plural) and Japanese with its thousands of symbols with no easy way to derive their meanings and no hint to how each one are pronounced are anything but regular. Especially Japanese.
- schoen 9y ago> they also have 2-plural Not only is there a dual number, there's the most complicated system of agreement of numerals with nouns that I've ever seen in any language: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arabic_grammar#Numerals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arabic_grammar#Numerals
- Grustaf 9y agoThere are in fact very strong hints on how to pronounce most Chinese characters, at least their Chinese reading (on-yomi, used in compound words). A vast majority of characters are made up of two parts, one giving the (reading and one the area of meaning. When it comes to their Japanese readings (kun-yomi) it sort of follows when you know what the character means and what that word is in Japanese.
- stevekemp 9y agoThe same is, broadly, true of Finnish. (But despite that it is a hard language to learn, I'm making only small amounts of progress despite having lived in Finland for two years.)
- irrational 9y agoI hardly think the Normans invading England and forcing their language onto the Britons hardly qualifies as stealing (and of course before the Normans, the Germanic Angle and Saxon tribes invaded and forced their language on the peoples). When something is forced onto you, would you say that thing was stolen?
- Aloha 9y agoIn fairness, english has 'stolen' as much vocabulary, as we've had foisted upon us... of course I don't think you can 'steal' a word anyhow.
- yongjik 9y agoKorean spelling is pretty regular (because it was standardized in the early 20th century), but the language itself is very difficult for average English speakers. For one thing, each verb can have several thousand different forms: in fact I don't think anyone can enumerate them all. (Sometimes people even make up new forms!)
- kwhitefoot 9y ago> In German, you can read a word and know how it is pronounced, and hear a word and know how it's written. So there are no dialects in Germany, do they really pronounce all words the same in the dockyards of Hamburg as they do in the university at Heidelberg? What about Austrian German, Swiss German, and the German speakers in Argentina and Brazil. And you never 'steal' words? What about spaghetti (or is it spagetti now?). If German had been the most used auxiliary language for the last two hundred years I think it too would have borrowed a few more words.
- StavrosK 9y ago> So there are no dialects in Germany, do they really pronounce all words the same in the dockyards of Hamburg as they do in the university at Heidelberg? No, but they pronounce the words consistently in each dialect, as opposed to English where bow and bow are pronounced differently. > What about Austrian German, Swiss German, and the German speakers in Argentina and Brazil. What about them? > And you never 'steal' words? Fine, "borrowed" then. I didn't mean it pejoratively. Also I'm not a native speaker of either English or German. > If German had been the most used auxiliary language for the last two hundred years I think it too would have borrowed a few more words. What do you mean? That, say, the word "fraternity" is French-derived because the French spoke English? It seems to me that it's exactly the other way around.
- kwhitefoot 9y ago> No, but they pronounce the words consistently in each dialect, as opposed to English where bow and bow are pronounced differently. So I have to know which dialect the author used in order to know how to pronounce a word.
- StavrosK 9y agoAs opposed to English where all dialects pronounce the words the same? Why was that comment even worth making?
- jcranmer 9y agoThe only thing truly insane about English is its writing system. Grammatically, it's one of the simplest Indo-European languages; the only thing hard about it is the inconsistent remnants of the Germanic ablaut system for verb conjugation (i.e., all of the "irregular" verbs).
- StavrosK 9y agoThat's ignoring the biggest issue with it, which is that it's half Germanic and half Romantic.
- Aloha 9y agoArguably that makes it easier to learn for people who speak either Germanic or Romance Languages. The hard part about english is our vocabulary, compared to any Germanic or Romance language its huge, because of the history of english we have two or more words for many things - some are context based, some are just archaic, and some are in every day common use.
- StavrosK 9y agoThat's kind of a tradeoff, though. It makes half the language easy for other Germanic language speakers, the other half easy for Romanic language speakers, but speakers of neither just end up having a harder time because they pretty much have to learn two different vocabularies.
- Aloha 9y agoArguably you can get by with just one (plus a little of the other) vocabulary and still be pretty intelligible.