5 ms·
AFAIK, many other big-name companies have been donating manpower and resources to help get PR back on its feet. What makes this announcement any more noteworthy
by TheAceOfHearts 9y ago
AFAIK, many other big-name companies have been donating manpower and resources to help get PR back on its feet. What makes this announcement any more noteworthy? I'd get it if it included a bit more information, but the blog post reads as marketing fluff.
Does anyone know of any reliable sources showing in-depth sample numbers from previous deployments? I'd be really interested in getting an idea of what area size these balloons could cover, for how long it can be reliably maintained over an area, and their expected throughput. The Helping out in Peru [0] post has a bit of info, but it's very light on details.
If anyone is familiarized with these industries, I'd love to read up on the kinds of challenges faced with getting something like this deployed. Looking at it from an outsider's perspective, being without connectivity for over a month seems like a pretty long time. It's great that Project Loon is seeing improvements in their deployment time, but the article doesn't shed any light on the process, which is rather disappointing.
[0] https://blog.x.company/helping-out-in-peru-9e5a84839fd2 https://blog.x.company/helping-out-in-peru-9e5a84839fd2
- melling 9y agoIt’s newsworthy because an experimental Google X project is being used to solve a real world problem. The US military might spend a billion dollars in aid, for example, but the world won’t be any different in the future, beyond the lives directly impacted, because of this.
- jpm_sd 9y agoYou are definitely asking the right questions. It is way too easy for Google to declare victory here without any meaningful level of service delivered. "At least one of the balloons managed to station keep for a while" =/= "isolated people in Puerto Rico were actually able to communicate with the outside world"
- jpm_sd 9y agoSo far, the balloons are not doing a great job staying in the service area: (from flightradar24 on 2017-10-23) https://imgur.com/FdqTrQ7 https://imgur.com/FdqTrQ7