5 ms·
Why did they reduce the viaduct from six lanes down to four? If you're going thru the trouble for boring a tunnel, do it proper and either keep the same lanes
by mc32 9y ago
Why did they reduce the viaduct from six lanes down to four? If you're going thru the trouble for boring a tunnel, do it proper and either keep the same lanes or add (even a convertible lane --disabled vehicle/rush hour lane) But reduction? Except for earthquake proofing the roadway, this does not improve upon the traffic on SR-99.
It reminds me of the Caldecott Tunnels --they had to bore a new one to carry all the traffic --but at least you can forgive that because traffic volume was lower when they orig built them.
- BurningFrog 9y agoTunnels digging costs are roughly proportional to the square of their diameter, if we take Elon Musk's word for it. So a six lane tunnel probably cost more than twice of four lanes.
- mc32 9y agoThat's a great point, I failed to realize. This is a two-deck tunnel, so the price increase might not have been as steep. In any event, some of the original proposals were for six lanes --wished they'd carried that out.
- pygy_ 9y ago> Tunnels digging costs are roughly proportional to the square of their diameter Given a constant length and homogeneous ground composition (conditions that apply to the current discussion)... It makes a lot of sense that the cost is proportional to the volume being removed.
- mulmen 9y agoThere has to be more to it than just homogenous ground composition. Surely drilling into granite is harder than clay or something? Also my understanding was that the SR99 tunnel is through both fill and clay. http://www.wsdot.wa.gov/Projects/Viaduct/About/Tunneling http://www.wsdot.wa.gov/Projects/Viaduct/About/Tunneling
- pygy_ 9y agoI may not have used the best phrasing: For a given tunnel length and ground composition, the cost is proportional to the area of the cross section.
- c22 9y agoFor what it's worth the project eliminates the downtown exits which is where a lot of people on the existing viaduct are either coming from or headed. Combined with a toll, I expect traffic over this section of roadway to improve. It's the other nearby roads that are concerning.
- mc32 9y agoI see where they are just trying to alleviate things for thru traffic, but that leaves the side roads to make up for the traffic off-load --making it worse for the commute. My complaint is that if you're going to invest a few billion into boring a tunnel, at least make it wide enough to carry all the orig traffic given that adding marginal width is a small fraction of overall cost of building a tunnel.
- loeg 9y agoAt 32 feet, it does seem like they have plenty of width for 3 lanes each way with no shoulder. 12 foot lanes are the standard for 60-70 mph interstates, but Aurora's top speed limit is like 45 mph or something and I think it's even lower in the current tunnel. So 10.6 foot lanes seem pretty reasonable.
- mulmen 9y agoTake a look at the sides of the I90 E tunnels. Tunnel walls tend to jump out at Seattle drivers. Gotta give people some breathing room and I'm sure there is some consideration for leaving space for emergency vehicles to squeeze by. I am also hoping they increase the speed limit inside the tunnel since there are no ramps. I think there is probably consideration for making it easy for buses to navigate as well.
- loeg 9y agoI think you have a good point about emergency vehicle access. I-90 is a much higher speed road, though. (Assuming they don't take your suggestion of increasing the speed limit in the tunnel.) Freeway standard is 12 feet per lane (and even the 1940-era Mt Baker tunnels have 12 foot lanes[0]), but again, Aurora isn't a freeway. Meanwhile, buses are about 8.5 feet wide[1] and easily fit in a 10 foot lane. Most Seattle streets are narrower than that. [0]: http://www.seattleasce.org/committees/hh/LaceyBridgeReport.pdf http://www.seattleasce.org/committees/hh/LaceyBridgeReport.p... [1]: https://cptdb.ca/wiki/index.php/New_Flyer_Industries_XDE60 https://cptdb.ca/wiki/index.php/New_Flyer_Industries_XDE60
- mulmen 9y agoSeattle is very limited with the amount of land available. It's not feasible to build the 18 lane ultra freeway required to allow everyone to drive to their destination. For better or worse Seattle city planners have taken a car-hostile approach to try and force people onto public transit. Unfortunately they also can't figure out how to pay for enough buses and trains to get everyone where they are going. Also, my understanding is that there will be a surface street where the current viaduct is which combined with the tunnel will allow downtown access and increase capacity beyond what we have today.
- ACarDrone 9y agoFucking car drone. Cars are not a sustainable form of transit for cities. Those shitty suburbs that can sustain cars cannot sustain themselves. Seattle is too confined by water to allow for your 18 lane highway, that wouldn’t help traffic anyway. You aren’t stuck in traffic, you ARE traffic. Idiot.
- BurningFrog 9y ago> Seattle is very limited with the amount of land available. Tunnels don't use land.
- mulmen 9y agoThe ramps to get in and out of them do though. Also tunnels do occupy space. Seattle already has a bus tunnel and a rail tunnel to avoid. On top of being built on Jell-O.
- andrewem 9y agoThis is an important point, and one you can see in practice in downtown Boston walking above the I-93 tunnel - lots of land is still used for off-ramps and on-ramps, which tends to have high-speed traffic, whose presence is dangerous and discourages walking, which is the lifeblood of the city.
- omgbananas 9y agoThe exits, entrances, and ops building uses surface land. There is limited subterranean land as well.
- andys627 9y agoAdding lanes doesn't reduce traffic. It's called induced demand. In 1 year new capacity (supply) creates 50% in demand and in 5 years it is 100%. You want less traffic? Stop giving roads away for free.