3 ms·
Australia recently went through a very strange process in which signing was removed as a requirement for credit cards, with a pin being required instead. Goodn
by andrewstuart 9y ago
Australia recently went through a very strange process in which signing was removed as a requirement for credit cards, with a pin being required instead.
Goodness knows what it cost but there was a giant campaign to get everyone to ensure they had a pin number on their cards.
And at the same time, you can use PayWave to just wave a credit card for a transaction with no PIN required - presumably for smaller transactions. Even so it was strange to go through this giant campaign of ensuring your card has a PIN and then not needing it. "IMPORTANT! Ensure you have a PIN on your credit card! (although you won't need it)".
https://www.lifehacker.com.au/2014/01/credit-card-pin-number-changes-in-australia-everything-you-need-to-know/ https://www.lifehacker.com.au/2014/01/credit-card-pin-number...
I've wondered what sort of security issue PayWave is..... what if somehow a criminal got a PayWave reader and surreptitiously touched it to everyone's bag and pocket on a crowded train? Is there a possible exploit there somewhere?
- d4l3k 9y agoI'm pretty sure the wireless tap is some form of challenge response/one time password so it's probably not a huge issue. It's not like they can make unlimited purchases just by reading it. It's slightly more secure than just a credit card number.
- ryukafalz 9y agoThere was a video on that a few years back that you might find interesting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HRXb-FZ6WFM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HRXb-FZ6WFM Basically - yes, it's more secure than just a credit card number, though if it works the same way it did in 2012 there's still all sorts of shenanigans you could pull.
- jazoom 9y agoHow recent was this? I've been using PIN only for at least 7 years. The limit for just tap and no PIN is $100.
- inferiorhuman 9y ago> I've wondered what sort of security issue PayWave is..... what if somehow a criminal got a PayWave reader and surreptitiously touched it to everyone's bag and pocket on a crowded train? Is there a possible exploit there somewhere? Yeah, I thought about that too. On the plus side, Apple Pay works pretty much anywhere PayWave is accepted, and Apple Pay requires a fingerprint or face.
- rocqua 9y agoGood luck at preventing all transactions with that PayWave reader being flagged as fraud. You'd need to somehow launder the reader by using it in large amounts of legitimate transactions.
- Veratyr 9y agoAre you Australian? I don't think you understand what happened. The change wasn't removing signing as a requirement, it was removing signing as an _option_. It hadn't been a requirement in years (decades?). When I was working in fast food someone tried to use a signature roughly once a day max and typically they were using a business account. http://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/financial-services/pinonly-purchases-as-credit-card-signatures-to-be-phased-out/news-story/910a06cdb8b13790555882f8edd26567 http://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/financial-services/... > Goodness knows what it cost but there was a giant campaign to get everyone to ensure they had a pin number on their cards. I never saw this... It was widely reported in the media but use of signatures was rare enough that few people cared. > And at the same time, you can use PayWave to just wave a credit card for a transaction with no PIN required - presumably for smaller transactions. Not presumably, the maximum is $100 and when you reach the $100 limit you still wave, you just need to enter a PIN afterwards. > I've wondered what sort of security issue PayWave is..... what if somehow a criminal got a PayWave reader and surreptitiously touched it to everyone's bag and pocket on a crowded train? Is there a possible exploit there somewhere? It's not bulletproof but damage is pretty limited: - If you use an actual portable payment terminal to process transactions on the spot, the fraud rate will be incredibly high and you're not likely to keep any of the money. The transactions will be reverse and you'll be fined and/or prosecuted. - If you capture a token and try to use it, you have to do it before the actual owner does because if the bank sees tokens out of order it'll freeze the card. - Banks have pretty good guarantees on contactless fraud.
- sundvor 9y agoGood post, thanks. Australia really is on the forefront of this; we may be behind on a lot of other things, but not NFC payments. Edit: And my Samsung Pay works contactless as well, and is linked to my bank account same as my MasterCard plastic - but with the added advantage of giving me instant electronic receipts.
- Veratyr 9y agoWe really are. It seems crazy that Australian banks had contactless phone payment apps (that actually worked pretty much everywhere) before Google and Apple.