3 ms·
No, that ruling by the Court is not an error, it just has different interpretation of the Commerce Clause than yours. Even if you don't necessarily agree with t
by astura 9y ago
No, that ruling by the Court is not an error, it just has different interpretation of the Commerce Clause than yours. Even if you don't necessarily agree with their interpretation (and I'm not sure I do, but they make a compelling argument) it wasn't factual error. It's extremely disingenuous to claim it was. That case entirely is irrelevant to the topic at hand.
>The Supreme Court interpreted the Constitution's Commerce Clause under Article 1 Section 8, which permits the United States Congress "to regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes." The Court decided that Filburn's wheat-growing activities reduced the amount of wheat he would buy for animal feed on the open market, which is traded nationally (interstate), and is therefore within the scope of the Commerce Clause. Although Filburn's relatively small amount of production of more wheat than he was allotted would not affect interstate commerce itself, the cumulative actions of thousands of other farmers just like Filburn would certainly become substantial. Therefore, according to the court, Filburn's production could be regulated by the federal government.
- BearGoesChirp 9y agoIf the Supreme Court interprets the Second Amendment to apply to the upper appendages we call arms, that is a factual error, not just a different interpretation. It is possible for an interpretation, given the evidence, to be factually wrong in as much as anything can be factually wrong.
- jgowdy 9y agoAnd by that argument, you could Butterfly Effect literally any action as having commerce implications and thus hyperextend the commerce clause into completely reshaping the balance of power between federal and state government. There are just a few supreme court decisions that very rapidly shifted our federal government from one of very limited and explicitly laid out powers, reserving all other powers for the states, to a federal government that has supremacy on almost every topic even several levels of indirection away from their explicitly stated powers. This was effectively a revolution. The form and breadth of the federal government before and after this and other decisions that made their power nearly universal is as different as the federal government under the articles of confederation versus the constitutional federal government. The original intention was to make a federal government of limited powers. Between the incredible expansions of the commerce clause and the necessary and proper clause to effectively cover every major aspect of daily life, and the supreme court decision that claimed that the 10th amendment was effectively a "noop", we've reached a system where the federal government has almost universal control. Then they finished up the final power grab by using the power of the purse by taxing more than they need to run federal programs and then only returning money to the states based on compliance with the rest of their agenda. The dream that was a federal government with limited powers died along the way in the United States. Their power is almost universal today, and that was not the stated or written intention from the start.