5 ms·
I am actually happy that life becomes more difficult the bigger companies get. It was a good thing that Microsoft got some heat in the 90s and stopped dominatin
by maxxxxx 9y ago
I am actually happy that life becomes more difficult the bigger companies get. It was a good thing that Microsoft got some heat in the 90s and stopped dominating the market. I hope that Facebook and Apple also will also get more scrutiny.
- sosuke 9y agoI wonder if Apple is getting less scrutiny because they are staying out of sharing any private information with third parties and even trying to prevent themselves from being able to see it.
- pwinnski 9y agoAnd yet as part of "less scrutiny," they lost a case in which they tried to disrupt the Amazon ebook near-monopoly.
- rainbowmverse 9y agoUsing behavior of oligarchies (price fixing) to fight a monopoly was maybe not the best strategy if they wanted to earn any sympathy.
- miniapp 9y agoAll those firms you've mentioned are already too big. Anything they do will generate scrutiny so they've stopped innovating. That's why Google is trying to take up role as an 'angel investor.' https://www.cnbc.com/2017/10/13/google-and-amazon-are-ready-to-disrupt-small-business-lending-former-obama-advisor-says.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/10/13/google-and-amazon-are-ready-...
- icebraining 9y agoTrying to take up? Google Ventures is almost a decade old. Also, there's no actual facts about Google in that article.
- stingrae 9y agoWhat is your evidence that Google has "stopped innovating"? In my opinion Google is very focused on making sure that innovation doesn't stop, because if it stops they will lose.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoGoogle acquires innovators, it doesn't innovate much itself. Everything new Google has launched since like... Chrome, has been an acquisition, or an integration of a couple of acquisitions together. (Sure, that work is not small, but at the point Google got involved, the innovative part was mostly over.) Self-driving car team was picked up wholesale from a university, DeepMind was an acquisition, most of what Google Lens is was from an acquisition. Projects like Ara, Jacquard, and Tango were all from Motorola's ATAP division, which they acquired. Almost anything you see coming out of Google can be traced back to an existing thing that Google purchased, rebranded, and relaunched. cromwellian's comment probably lends to explaining some of why: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15519220 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15519220
- stingrae 9y agoYou miss some key products (>1B Users) Google has created completely within: Search, GMail, Maps, Calendar, etc. Many of Google's products did start from acquisitions. Though those startups can't claim all the credit. Most wouldn't have become as big as they are now without the capital and talent that Google brought to them.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoI specified: 'Since Chrome'. All of those products predate Chrome.
- dunkelheit 9y agoAt least their Maps product originated outside Google.
- Consultant32452 9y agoLife becomes more difficult the bigger companies get regardless of outside pressures. Price's law states that the square root of the number of people in a domain do 50% of the work. This means the number of "useful" people increases linearly with size but the number of not-so-useful people increases exponentially. If you have 10 people, 3 do half the work. If you have 100 people, 10 do half the work. Google has 60k employees, so about 250 people are getting half the work done. This is basically impossible to maintain and is part of the reason megacorps die.
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> Price's law states that the square root of the number of people in a domain do 50% of the work. This means the number of "useful" people increases linearly with size but the number of not-so-useful people increases exponentially. Assuming you mean that the smaller group accomplishing half the work is "useful" and the larger group also accomplishing half the work is "not useful", it certainly doesn't mean that. It means, very clearly, that the number of "not useful" people increases linearly with size, and the number of "useful" people increases sublinearly. But even if your definition of "size" included only useful people, x^2 is a polynomial function of x, not an exponential function of it.
- Consultant32452 9y agoOne of the things I love about HN is that people get really pedantic about things like math terms used in casual conversation. That's not sarcasm, I actually do love it. Thanks for increasing the specificity of the language.
- spacemanmatt 9y agoThey did? I recall their penalty being entirely ineffective, and a subsequent decade of more Windows ecosystem hegemony. Every workplace I've been in remains ruled by Windows ecosystem, even where they have bought Google Apps for the whole enterprise.