15 ms·
It probably shouldn't be that big of a surprise. Police officers are almost entirely decent people that shouldn't feel the need to change their behavior just b
by jandrese 9y ago
It probably shouldn't be that big of a surprise. Police officers are almost entirely decent people that shouldn't feel the need to change their behavior just because they're being recorded.
Regular citizens would already be on their best behavior around cops, the camera doesn't change much.
I think people get a skewed perception of the police force from a relatively small number of highly publicized incidents.
Counter option: The DC cops are so brazen that they don't even care if they're being caught on film. This doesn't seem likely, since it would be such an easy payday for some hungry defense lawyer.
- crdoconnor 9y ago>I think people get a skewed perception of the police force from a relatively small number of highly publicized incidents. ...who receive lots of back up from other police officers, superiors and the law.
- losvedir 9y agoSurprised to see this downvoted - it was my initial thought as well. If most cops are decent and doing what they think is right, then that wouldn't change just because they're wearing bodycams. That said, I still think bodycams are a great idea. I hadn't heard justification of them based on improving some aggregate statistics before. Instead, I've always thought they were good for those particularly difficult "he said / she said" cases that capture public attention.
- gph 9y ago>Instead, I've always thought they were good for those particularly difficult "he said / she said" cases that capture public attention. I agree, but at what price point would you say it's worth it? In principle I want bodycams, but with this new study it's making me wonder if pragmatically it's really worth spending millions of dollars each year just for a handful of difficult 'he said / she said' cases to be better resolved. Probably it still is given that these small handful of cases get the biggest media attention / public backlash that hurts the image of the police. In that sense bodycams can almost be thought of as a public relations expense.
- corey_moncure 9y agoAn economic solution lies in wait. What is the impact of settlements in "he said / she said" cases resolved in the defendant's favor? Is it "millions of dollars each year"?
- magnetic 9y agoI don't know if that works... I mean, even if it's millions of $ each year that PD have to settle/pay, why does it hurt them? Aren't they simply going to pass that cost back to the taxpayers?
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoPolice departments have budgets, not blank checks. If the police come to the local government saying they need an extra umpty-million this year because they keep getting sued for brutality, questions are going to be asked.
- magnetic 9y agoCertainly, but at the end of the day, they'll say: "well if we don't get $x then we will have to cut the force. If we don't pay our officers, they are just going to leave." What do you do then? You can fire people you hold accountable, but that isn't going to fix your budget situation: if you don't fund the PD, the services are going to be cut, and taxpayers are going to be impacted.
- dsr_ 9y agoOnly millions? No problem at all. Let's revise that estimate, though. 765,000 sworn state-level personnel in 2008. We'll round up to a million. At $1000 each for hardened, certified cameras, that's a billion dollars. But we should expect them to last about three years, so $333M each year. Storage costs are cheap, but secure handling of storage is not. Let's say one full-time $100K employee per hundred camera-wearing officers. That's a billion dollars per year. So I'll go with a cost estimate of 1.3 - 1.5 billion per year for cameras for all police officers. Is that worth it? I think so.
- trumpownsyou420 9y agosurprised? you're surrounded by SJW retards.
- pzxc 9y agoI think maybe it was downvoted because it misses the point, just as the article misses the point. Behavior change would be nice but the real benefit here is accountability. So what if there were 1.6% (made up number) rate of reported bad behaviors, and now the rate is still 1.6% -- the point is that in those 1.6% of cases, there is now the best kind of evidence to ensure that the facts are represented accurately when these cases are adjudicated. That accurate portrayal of facts will actually protect both cops and citizens.
- wutbrodo 9y agoThis explains too much, since there have been other depts that did see a likely effect (like Rialto). I found this part more compelling: > Finally, cameras may have had less impact in Washington, D.C., because the police department there has already had to confront excessive-force problems. After a devastating 1998 Washington Post series revealed that the city’s police department had shot and killed more people per resident in the 1990s than any other police force in a large American city, the Department of Justice entered into a memorandum of agreement with D.C. to reform its policing. I do think people overstate the extent to which police violence in the US is a problem of evil cops committing wanton abuse as opposed to deeper systemic issues, but I think it's possible that bodycams end up being a useful piece of that puzzle.
- avn2109 9y agoIt's blindingly obvious (to me) that the cops are just disabling the cameras before doing controversial things. I find it extremely surprising that nobody else seems to believe this theory. As another commented pointed out downthread, you can hear them on accidentally-recorded video saying things like "We're still red here! Be careful!" when planting evidence/stealing stuff/whatever. Disclaimer: I think both street protesters/identity politics activists and the police are basically run by assholes.
- darawk 9y agoIt'd be trivial to find evidence of that in the data. They said that the number of use of force incidents was the same in the camera and non-camera groups. If the cops were disabling their cameras in anticipation of these events, these events would not show up in their camera recordings.
- mistermann 9y ago> Police officers are almost entirely decent people should perhaps be > Police officers are almost entirely almost decent people The fact that the "few" (so we're told) bad apples aren't rooted out by their fellow honest, law-abiding officers suggests they're not as squeaky clean as some might think.
- irrational 9y agoOr they don't know. I had a coworker who was recently arrested for child porn. Despite knowing and working with him for years there was no indication that he wasn't "squeaky clean".
- s73ver_ 9y agoBut we're talking about incidents that are public. When Eric Garner was choked to death by police, I don't recall hearing a lot of cops call for those detectives to be fired. Hell, when the Mayor of NYC said something about it, at the next event, cops turned their backs on him. These are not "decent people".
- eric_h 9y ago> Hell, when the Mayor of NYC said something about it, at the next event, cops turned their backs on him. > These are not "decent people". I really don't think it's that clear cut. The cops who turned their backs aren't all, necessarily, bad people. The insularity of police culture generates significant peer pressure for cops to cover each other's backs and to protect their mutual perceived safety and self interest. They respond to perceived attacks on interests in a similar way to what many subcultures do when they feel their interests are being encroached upon; they protest and grow more insular in solidarity. This tends to lead to a bubble and allows otherwise decent people to, inadvertently or otherwise, overlook the shortcomings of "a few bad apples", in the interest of protecting people who they think have their best interests at heart. I'm not saying this is good, it's just important to remember that cops are humans and behave like humans. Training is supposed to reduce the incidence of human misbehavior but I think that even just the fact that police wear uniforms tends to make them take the side of the "team" that they're representing.
- coffee9 9y agoI assumed the point of body cameras was simply for physical evidence after an incident, that cops might "behave" better due to some psychological effect doesn't strike me as important.
- OrwellianChild 9y agoAgreed. I thought that any "nudge" factor was secondary to getting reliable reporting at the scene rather than relying upon corruptible testimony by officers after-the-fact. All the problems stated elsewhere in this thread around discretion in deactivating cameras still exist and need to be addressed.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Consultant32452 9y agoCounter counter option: Not all districts are created equally. We know from history that some districts have become so corrupt that the feds had to step in and replace entire police forces. I suspect police abuse is not as wide-spread as we've been led to believe by social justice marketing, but I'm open to evidence to the contrary. Let's put our engineers to work and get the costs of these camera systems way down, and then let's put them on every cop in the nation. It's not just the BLM folks talking about this, the MRAs also have claims about things like men who are physically abused by women, cop shows up, arrests the man anyways, and those sorts of stories. One way or the other we can put a number of social justice issues to rest.
- forapurpose 9y ago> social justice marketing ... not just the BLM folks ... It doesn't sound like you are "open to evidence to the contrary". Those words seem to dismiss such evidence.
- weberc2 9y agoSkepticism is merited after a certain volume of debunked claims.
- forapurpose 9y agoPartisans always 'debunk' every claim made that disagrees with them. It's not a meaningful signal.
- weberc2 9y ago1. As a point of clarification, I'm not partisan, nor are the sources I had in mind. 2. There's a distinction between "debunked" and "claimed to be debunked"; you're conflating my meaning (the former) with the latter. If you did mean the former, then you're questioning all empiricism and objectivity, in which case we have no basis for discussion or reason and we may as well stop now.
- s73ver_ 9y agoI can't agree with the characterization of them being "almost entirely decent people" when they clam up and defend the objectively bad among them. Decent people don't do that.
- jandrese 9y agoIn fact there were some famous studies that disproved that assertion when the "decent people" are part of a larger organization. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment
- majormajor 9y agoSeems like either a) decent people in fact do that, or b) there just aren't many decent people out there, based on the evidence of the behavior of insiders in pretty much ever organization or industry that's ever had a highly-placed sexual assaulter, fraudster, or similar.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> I think people get a skewed perception of the police force from a relatively small number of highly publicized incidents. It's not just the incidents themselves, but the fact that the entire force seems to be quite willing to shield the worst offenders. Sure, Office Steve probably won't knock me around because of my skin color, but how many times has he looked away while Officer John did?
- grasshopperpurp 9y ago>Police officers are almost entirely decent people . . . This statement requires justification. >Research suggests that family violence is two to four times higher in the law-enforcement community than in the general population. >As the National Center for Women and Policing noted in a heavily footnoted information sheet, "Two studies have found that at least 40 percent of police officer families experience domestic violence, in contrast to 10 percent of families in the general population. A third study of older and more experienced officers found a rate of 24 percent, indicating that domestic violence is two to four times more common among police families than American families in general." Cops "typically handle cases of police family violence informally, often without an official report, investigation, or even check of the victim's safety," the summary continues. "This 'informal' method is often in direct contradiction to legislative mandates and departmental policies regarding the appropriate response to domestic violence crimes." Finally, "even officers who are found guilty of domestic violence are unlikely to be fired, arrested, or referred for prosecution." https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2014/09/police-officers-who-hit-their-wives-or-girlfriends/380329/ https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2014/09/police-...
- dogma1138 9y agoFamily violence is also more common in first responders/EMTs and soldiers. Take a wild guess on what those have in common with police officers. People that are constantly exposed to highly stressful situations tend to develop psychological problems.
- grasshopperpurp 9y agoHe said: >Police officers are almost entirely decent people . . . Between 20% and 40% abuse their families. Does an entirely decent person abuse his family? I'm not aware of a higher family abuse rate among EMTs, and a quick Google search produced nothing, so I'd appreciate any sources. Your reasoning makes sense, but I can just as easily say that violent people are more inclined to be police officers and soldiers - for obvious reasons. I'd guess it's some of both (some high stress and the attraction of the occupation to violent people).
- Anechoic 9y ago> I think people get a skewed perception of the police force from a relatively small number of highly publicized incidents. Or perhaps people arrive at their perceptions based on personal experience? Certainly my own experience with police has shaped my views far more than anything I've seen in the news.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> > I think people get a skewed perception of the police force from a relatively small number of highly publicized incidents. > Or perhaps people arrive at their perceptions based on personal experience? Probably also a factor, but that's also not representative and subject to perceptual biases.
- Anechoic 9y ago>but that's also not representative One occurrence possibly. When it happens multiple times, I'm not inclined to attribute it to perceptual biases.
- rhizome 9y agoWhat do cops care about a defense lawyer's "easy payday?"
- PhasmaFelis 9y agoThey care when the chief has to explain to the city council why they need an extra $2 million in the budget this year. Shit rolls downhill.
- rhizome 9y agoThat money isn't paid out of the budget, they have insurance for it.
- DanielDent 9y agoInsurers are not charities. They price based on a risk model. A police department with frequent liability payouts can expect their premiums to be priced according to the risk they represent (assuming they are even able to find an insurer still willing to underwrite them).
- rhizome 9y agoDo those risk adjustments actually occur in real life? Is it even specifically "police insurance," or is it under the umbrella of the insurance for the jurisdiction (city, county, etc.) where those risk adjustments can get buried within larger coverage patterns?
- forapurpose 9y ago> I think people get a skewed perception of the police force from a relatively small number of highly publicized incidents. What is this statement based on? Can you provide any data? What about people - whole communities in many places, over generations - who claim to be persecuted continuously by police. Are those people making it up? The people protesting in St Louis - what are they spending all that time and energy on if there is no problem? This issue has been discussed heavily; I think more 'IMHOs' don't add to what we know about it.
- weberc2 9y agoWell, if Ferguson is any example, communities will absolutely lie about the police. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shooting_of_Michael_Brown#Evidence https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shooting_of_Michael_Brown#Ev... This isn't to say police are completely innocent; just that the "entire communities..." defense isn't a very good one.
- forapurpose 9y agoIf what you say about Brown is true (Wikipedia is not a reliable source on politically controversial issues), it's not evidence. That's just one incident in among claims by millions of people that have been going on for generations.
- weberc2 9y ago> Wikipedia is not a reliable source on politically controversial issues I can't imagine it's less reliable than, say, the field of sociology. At any rate, the claims in the wikipedia article are well-sourced, so if they are false, it should be trivial to demonstrate as much. > it's not evidence. That's just one incident in among claims by millions of people that have been going on for generations. What you describe is evidence. It isn't proof. But your broader point stands--we need more data about this to know how prevalent it is. My only point is that it's not unprecedented for communities to lie--specifically your refutation ("it's been going on for generations") supports my pet theory, which is that a lot of historical oppression by police has turned many black communities against police, driving uncharitable interpretations of police behavior at best and outright slander (as in the Ferguson case) at worst. Note that these communities can be lying and not necessarily be bad people--slander is morally wrong, but it's also an understandable (though unjust, misguided, etc) response to oppression. Compassion and honesty aren't mutually exclusive, as we are often tempted to believe.
- sumedh 9y ago> I think people get a skewed perception of the police force from a relatively small number of highly publicized incidents. I assume you are white which is why you made that statement, I think a black person would have a different opinion.