3 ms·
The title is a bit misleading but that is sort of par for the course. Blue Origin did the first "hot fire" test of the BE-4. What that means is that everything
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
The title is a bit misleading but that is sort of par for the course. Blue Origin did the first "hot fire" test of the BE-4.
What that means is that everything on the engine was turned on and the fuel ignited. This is the one of the final steps in engine development where you run it for a short period, collect data about as much stuff as possible, try to predict trends from that data to insure that the motor wasn't destroying itself. That sets up the next hot fire test which, I've read, are between 2 and 10x longer. Then you get durability tests (you run it at a variety of external temperatures, and conditions) and longevity tests (you run it for the entire mission life) then you take it completely apart and retest the metallurgy on bits that got hot (to insure they didn't get changed into something that would be out of spec for the engine) and check for erosion in the combustion chamber etc etc. Its a long and detailed process to go from a rocket engine 'design' to a rocket engine 'data sheet'.
It is a very large engine. With 50% more thrust than the SpaceX Raptor. Historically, engine thrust has been significant because the overall "efficiency" of rockets has been the fraction of the overall mass of the complete rocket they can get into orbit (or where ever they are going). So for a given engine what is important is what does the engine and its components weigh, versus the thrust it delivers. According to NASA this was the reasoning behind the F1 engines in the Saturn V, they had only 5 engines but they were huge, which gave them the thrust they needed but only 5 turbo pumps, 5 sets of propellant valves, 5 nozzles, etc.
It is also less complex to operate fewer engines.
On the flip side an engine out is a bigger loss of capability (and one of the advantages touted by the F9's 9 engines, the ability to achieve orbit with one engine out). And if you're re-landing these things, the ability to finely tune the throttle is very challenging on a larger engine. Look at the F9 which lands with exactly 1 engine firing. It has been reported that the landing weight of the F9 booster stage is such that even at its lowest throttle setting the booster would accelerate if the engine was left on. That means no 'hover' ability, just trying to intercept the ground before the rocket starts going up again :-).
Blue Origin still 'feels' about 3 years behind SpaceX though, and I continue to think the challenge here will be whether or not Falcon Heavy is successful in its first flights. SpaceX has the booster recovery aspects working smoothly, and Heavy has enough extra capacity to lift all the 'common' payloads, so it could monopolize a lot of the launches (and money that goes with them). That will make it much more difficult for New Shepard, because there will be little if any margin of error, and unlike SpaceX which can now lower prices given their understanding of recoverability, New Shepard will need to be able to compete from the first flight forward.