4 ms·
I both understand and don't understand your sentiment. I had two options. Buy my phone outright for $600. Pay $10 + $30 a month for the line and data. OR. Buy
by drivebyacct2 16y ago
I both understand and don't understand your sentiment. I had two options.
Buy my phone outright for $600. Pay $10 + $30 a month for the line and data. OR. Buy my phone for $200 and sell my soul to Verizon for 24 months. Pay $10 + $30 a month for the line and data. I plan on being with Verizon for the foreseeable future. Why would I not choose the subsidized phone?
- tortilla 16y agoThe only major US carrier that I know of that gives a discount on monthly plans when you bring your own phone is T-Mobile.
- Tichy 16y agoAt least in Germany it is very different. You can get cheaper rates if you bring your own hardware (in fact, my base rate is 0€ and I can also quit at any time). That seems the way it should be. I can see how from US perspective the calculations don't make sense. But then that seems as if mobile operators would be conspiring to make iPhones the only attractive devices?
- drivebyacct2 16y agoRight, but if you just get a plan with a German carrier w/o your own hardware, do you buy it outright or do you get it free and it's added into each monthly bill. If it's the latter, it makes complete sense. Plenty of people can't afford to go throw down $500 at a time. It's the same as any other subsidized or installed-payments model...
- Tichy 16y agoYou can buy phones without signing up with a mobile provider. If you want to buy the phone from the provider, they'll usually offer you the subsidies. The big providers don't make it very open that you can actually get a plan without buying hardware. If people want to go the subsidization route, whatever (I personally happen to think that if you can't afford 500$, maybe you shouldn't buy the hardware - get a 50$ feature phone instead). It just irks me if people think they are getting something for free. I hear "phone x costs 0€ at provider x" all the time, so people definitely don't understand this. My personal take is to avoid the maze of operator prizing completely (50 free minutes between 9am and 11am, but double prize on weekends, except for SMS which are free on a full moon), so I only sign up for plans that I can quit at any time, and with the lowest recurring fee possible.
- stanleydrew 16y ago>Why would I not choose the subsidized phone? Because there is an implicit cost to being in a contract. It restricts your choices. I know you plan on being with Verizon for the forseeable future, but things change quickly in the world of mobile devices. Also, people move for jobs, school, family reasons, etc, and service quality isn't consistent even on Verizon. For some people it's worth $400 to avoid having their decisions restricted by a contract.
- glhaynes 16y agoBut that's $400 of guaranteed cost vs. an early termination fee (usually around $300, I think?) that you very likely won't have to pay.
- detst 16y agoA termination fee that decreases with time. It makes no sense to pay full-price for a phone in the USA.
- jemfinch 16y ago> Because there is an implicit cost to being in a contract. It restricts your choices. Given the balkanization of cell phone hardware in the US (i.e., most phones only work on one carrier) is this really a factor?
- listic 16y agoI was thinking that you end up paying more for the service when you buy subsidized phone. I was implying that you can choose between paying-as-you-go when buying phone without contract and paying flat rate when you get contract and subsidized phone. So you spend extra money because (a) you end up paying more for the service you receive (voice talk minutes, SMS, data) and (b) flat rate plan includes more service than you would use paying-as-you-go. At least, that's how things are here in Russia. Now I see the options in the US are not what I thought. While you get bound by contract, at least the subsidies are real. As I understand, you normally use flat rate data plans regardless of when you are on contract or not. Are there options for paying for what you use? Are they widely used? Though I understand the reason to have unlimited data on a modern smartphone, paying-as-you-go (and prepaid) is what they normally use here, and I suspect most people will spend less than $40/month using a smartphone. If they make you pay for what you won't otherwise use, you can still count it as a tax for your "subsidy"