9 ms·
I really want one of these, but the ergonomics look awful. Is there a technical reason they only come with low resolution (1080p) screens? (“Linux” is not a v
by hedora 9y ago
I really want one of these, but the ergonomics look awful.
Is there a technical reason they only come with low resolution (1080p) screens? (“Linux” is not a valid reason...)
Also, as much as I would like a 15” screen, the off center keyboard is a deal-breaker. It’s just asking for RSI.
Does anyone own one? How is the trackpad / keyboard / battery life / fan noise? Maybe I can deal with 1080p in exchange for a reasonable OS and security.
- mi100hael 9y agoYeah I would have bought one when I was shopping but numpads on a laptop are a terrible idea. I ended up going for a Dell Precision 15 instead.
- duncan_bayne 9y agoSeconded. I discovered this the hard way when I bought a 15" Lenovo.
- klibertp 9y ago> numpads on a laptop are a terrible idea. I disagree completely. Having a numpad on a laptop is the only way of getting cursors and function keys (from Home to Insert to Delete) in a sane place. On my current laptop, were it not for a numpad, I'd have to press a Fn key every time I wanted to use Home/End. I'd also need to hunt for Delete somewhere above the Backspace, and PageUp/PageDown being on both sides of Up arrow (and close to it!) is simply infuriating. And it's a Dell Latitude[1], much better in this regard than tons of normal laptops. I'm not against remapping some keys, but you need the physical keys to be there in the first place to remap to them! Without the numpad, disabling the irritatingly placed PageDown/PageUp keys would leave me without the keys completely. There are downsides - mainly the fact that it's harder to work with a laptop actually on my lap, ie. it's harder to balance the device when most of the applied weight is on the left side, but I can deal with this with a $20 laptop tray. For additional $10 I can even get a tray with a place for an external mouse, although as I use trackballs exclusively I have little need for it. [1] https://www.computershopper.com/var/ezwebin_site/storage/images/media/images/dell-latitude-15-5000-keyboard/1258789-1-eng-US/dell-latitude-15-5000-keyboard.jpg https://www.computershopper.com/var/ezwebin_site/storage/ima...
- fdej 9y agoMy HP laptop has a single column with delete/home/pgup/pgdn/end, like this: https://h30434.www3.hp.com/t5/image/serverpage/image-id/36461i4890F5FE8ACCAFFB?v=1.0 https://h30434.www3.hp.com/t5/image/serverpage/image-id/3646... This works very nicely for me.
- mantis369 9y agoThe arrow key cluster, it burns us!
- chme 9y agoI could not deal with those arrow keys, though.
- Narishma 9y agoThat arrow key design is terrible though.
- klibertp 9y agoOk, now I know what I'd need to do to finally switch to hjkl (for arrows) when using Vim, I'd just need to buy a keyboard like yours ;) Joking aside, a keyboard is a very personal thing and picking the right one depends on many factors, from the shape and size of your hands and fingers to your chair and desk setup, to your OS and programs you use. For most people, it probably doesn't matter that much, but for people who use keyboards for work, it's IMHO worth it to take your time and choose a keyboard that is precisely right. As an example, I was perfectly happy with a standard desktop keyboard when I used Vim, even though Esc is rather far from home row (but it's easy to find by touch). Once I switched to Emacs, with its famous dependence on pressing and holding (as opposed to just hitting Esc in Vim) Ctrl and Alt, I almost immediately started getting RSI in my left hand. I quickly noticed that it happens only on the full-sized keyboard, not on (most) laptop keyboard. I considered switching away from Emacs, but, as with many cults, you can only leave in a body bag, so I had to find another way of dealing with it. After a lot of research, I found that Logitech K340[1] is the keyboard for me. As you can see, the Ctrl key is where it should be (in the bottom left corner - sometimes there's a Fn key there), is bigger than usual and much closer to the home row than in full-sized keyboards. This eliminated pain in my hand almost entirely. Full-size Enter key and Backspace (their shrunk versions are evil), quite workable placement of function keys above the numpad, the Fn key placed where it doesn't bother me, and arrow keys which are easily found by touch are all essential features, which match my workflow very well. The only key which is not as accessible as I'd like is Insert (the top one), but I don't use it very often. I'm sure there are tons of people who would find that keyboard unworkable for their workflows, though. I guess what I want to say is that if something works for you, then you should just use that. Still, you should make sure it actually works, because a wrist pain a year down the road is not a pleasant thing. [1] https://purplezest.files.wordpress.com/2010/03/121.jpg https://purplezest.files.wordpress.com/2010/03/121.jpg
- kbart 9y ago"numpads on a laptop are a terrible idea." Terrible idea for you, great idea for me. As I've mentioned in my other comment, numpad is a must for me, even on laptop, so you shouldn't generalize like that.
- kakarot 9y agoActually for me a numpad is a requirement. Some of my tools specifically rely on numpad key mappings.
- Kenji 9y agoHow is 1080p low resolution???
- chme 9y agoCompare that to the gdp pocket 7'' with 1920×1200.
- Yaggo 9y agoIt's more about DPI than the number of pixels ("resolution"). In more exact terms, the angular diameter of single pixel, or the ratio between DPI and viewing distance. The resolution is good enough when you cannot anymore see any pixelization effect from typical viewing distances. 1920x1080 on 15" screen is not quite enough, 2560x1440 or 2880x1800 are better options. I'm not sure what's the status of high-DPI support in FOSS graphics stacks today. The 1920x1080 may be practical choice, because it makes UI elements to look "normal size" on 15" screen without additional scaling. Without high-dpi mode, e.g. websites look way too tiny past 1080P (1 virtual pixel == 1 real pixel).
- broodbucket 9y ago1080p is considered low res! Crazy the times we live in. There are still laptop manufacturers making 1366x768 displays, the worst resolution ever invented. I understand pixel density is nice, but for the vast majority of workflows you do not need anything better than 1080p on a 15" display.
- andy_ppp 9y agoNo you don’t need better than 1080p but most developers need crisp text and I would like to go further and 4k 15inch displays would be perfect for me as it would allow me to have smaller text without a loss of quality.
- jchw 9y agoIt's a bit absurd to argue that you need a high pixel density to code. It's no longer an insane luxury, but even being a relatively younger programmer I remember 640x480 being the highest resolution my first personal computer could display. What fundamentally changed about programming that now we can't even do it without 200 PPI displays? Obviously, nothing. High resolution for most people is still just a 'nice to have.' But even 1080p@15" will produce relatively crisp text. I'd argue East Asian languages are the only ones to significantly improve in legibility, as sub-pixel rendering pretty much does what it needs to do for English nowadays. That being said, I absolutely will always go for high DPI and everything, I just don't think it's sane to argue it's an absolute must for what amounts to typing and reading text.
- mrec 9y ago> I remember 640x480 being the highest resolution my first personal computer could display <FourYorkshiremen> Eeee, you were lucky. My first personal computer maxed out at 320x256, or 160x256 if you wanted more than 4 colours. </FourYorkshiremen>
- zimpenfish 9y ago> 320x256 LUXURY. We had 32x24 b&w characters and we were glad of them. (ZX81, nominally 256x192 pixels but only accessible as 8x8 character cells.)
- Yaggo 9y ago> Also, as much as I would like a 15” screen, the off center keyboard is a deal-breaker. It’s just asking for RSI. Agree. Is entering numbers with a numpad so common use case that it justifies the inclusion of mini-numpad at the cost of off-centering the main keyboard?
- kbart 9y ago"Is entering numbers with a numpad so common use case that it justifies the inclusion of mini-numpad at the cost of off-centering the main keyboard?" At least for me - definitely yes. I won't even look at the laptop that doesn't have dedicated numpad. I guess it's a matter of taste and use case.
- Yaggo 9y agoJust out of curiosity, what kind of work do you do?
- kbart 9y ago(Embedded) System engineer, so lot's of hex typing and editing. It's a pain without full numpad.
- letsgetphysITal 9y agoHow about a USB numberpad with all 16 hex characters? http://www.ipv6buddy.com/ http://www.ipv6buddy.com/ I am in no way affiliated, I just searched "USB hex numberpad"
- kbart 9y agoI've tried regular USB numpad, but it's just not the same as having everything in a single keyboard. You need table or stable base for that and typing is slower when you have to reach for it, especially if it's not fixed and moves constantly. Still better than nothing though.
- 9y ago
- allendoerfer 9y agoI basically have the same technology in my 4 year old Zenbook (1080p screen, no USB-C ports, etc.). The CPU was upgraded, but is still outdated. But that I could maybe compromise on if the build quality was good. What are absolute dealbreakers are the missing keyboard options for my country.
- zingmars 9y ago> Is there a technical reason they only come with low resolution (1080p) screens? (“Linux” is not a valid reason...) Apart from the fact that a lot of systems still have mediocre high-dpi support at best, there's also battery life, cost and the fact that 1080p on a 15" is more than adequate for most people.
- hrrsn 9y ago>a lot of systems still have mediocre high-dpi support As far as I can tell, the only desktop OS with good high-DPI support is macOS.
- dmix 9y agoGnome has had good high DPI support for a while now...
- mamon 9y agoAny DE that does not support fraction scaling does not qualify as "good HDPI support". KDE is doing it the right way.
- holtalanm 9y agoI'm running Gnome on my retina displayed laptop and I can confirm that this is not true. The high DPI suppport on gnome equates to 'SCALE ALL THE THINGS 2x DERPA DERPA DERP' And the scaling is integer-based. So, I can choose 1x, 2x, or any other whole number. Useless as hell for me, who wishes it was probably 1.25x. It sucks bad enough that I actually WISH I was on a 1080p screen, because with the 2x scaling i effectively have a 1324x768 pos screen.
- SmellyGeekBoy 9y agoThey introduced experimental support for fractional scaling in 3.26: http://www.omgubuntu.co.uk/2017/09/enable-fractional-scaling-gnome-linux http://www.omgubuntu.co.uk/2017/09/enable-fractional-scaling...
- dmix 9y agoWhy would Linux even been a reason for low resolution? Plenty of software supports hi-dpi.
- Drdrdrq 9y agoXfce unfortunately not. I have 4k laptop set at 1280p because it is impossible to set everything so that it doesn't look ridiculously small. Still, I prefer low res to KDE/Unity/Gnome.
- nerdponx 9y agoI just wish they made this in a desktop, or in a standalone board I could build a machine around.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cryptonector 9y agoWho cares about the ergonomics? It's a _laptop_ -- those always have terrible ergonomics, which is why you should carry a (small) keyboard and (small travel) mouse. Put the laptop on a table and the keyboard on your lap -- that way you won't hurt your neck as much as if you put the laptop on your lap, nor your arms/hands as much as if you put the laptop on a table but don't use an external keyboard.
- eeZah7Ux 9y ago> the off center keyboard is a deal-breaker. It’s just asking for RSI. No. Laptop are a disaster for RSI and posture in general. The off center keyboard has a tiny effect. Use external keyboards and monitors!