5 ms·
As a customer of ride sharing services that's become accustomed to VC subsidizing my rides, this is great news.
by koolba 9y ago
As a customer of ride sharing services that's become accustomed to VC subsidizing my rides, this is great news.
- trhway 9y agoVC (at that scale) are just a pipe for the Fed's cheap money, ie. we all subsidize your rides. Strangely, it does seem to result in overall improvement to the society and economy.
- YuriNiyazov 9y agoCan't tell if you are being sarcastic or not with that "strangely", but yes - public transportation is a net good thing
- chimeracoder 9y ago> Can't tell if you are being sarcastic or not with that "strangely", but yes - public transportation is a net good thing Lyft isn't public transportation, and there was an article a few days ago which demonstrated that, in some cities, Uber and Lyft were causing a net decrease in public transportation use.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Uber and Lyft were causing a net decrease in public transportation use Darned consumer choice getting in the way of multi-billion dollar political handouts again [1]. [1] https://www.utrc2.org/publications/final-second-avenue-subway-case https://www.utrc2.org/publications/final-second-avenue-subwa...
- chimeracoder 9y ago> Darned consumer choice getting in the way of multi-billion dollar political handouts again [1]. I wasn't even advocating public transportation necessarily - just pointing out that Lyft doesn't qualify as public transportation. But, since you're bringing it up, I'll point out that glibly referring to the Second Ave line as a "political handout" is reductive. The Second Ave project is[0] a disaster for a whole lot of reasons, not just "political handouts", and it's also not at all representative of public transportation either in NYC or in general. [0] not was - is... Phase II and III have still not happened
- baddox 9y agoWhy would that be shocking? That seems like the obvious result to expect.
- jayess 9y agoI'd venture to say that in the far majority of american cities public transportation is a net negative. Lots of large, expensive, idling buses belching pollution and providing little useful service.
- pmalynin 9y agoIt’s like some twisted form of Keynesianism
- thatfrenchguy 9y agoYou mean for upper middle class people though.
- Tiktaalik 9y agoIndeed. The most universal and affordable transportation is walking or cycling, and any sort of expansion in protected bicycle infrastructure is met with extreme opposition.
- usrusr 9y agoI can almost hear the future excuses: "we love bikes and walkability just like everyone else, but we have N billion invested in car services, our shareholders will sue us to hell and back if we don't take every single not unquestionably illegal measure to keep cycling and walking from spreading"
- Mefis 9y agoCan you explain how VCs are a pipe for Fed money?
- SmellTheGlove 9y agoThat statement is a little hyperbolic, but at a very simplistic level, here's kind of, sort of, how - Fed keeps the interest rate low. That means low borrowing costs for those that can borrow, but also lower yields on debt instruments. Doing so keeps money in equity markets where VCs obviously play, because the risk-adjusted returns are favorable to investing in debt. At the same time, it's doubtful that the sorts of businesses that VCs back could raise debt funding at reasonable rates (they're not borrowing at the Fed overnight rate, nor do they have any real assets to collateralize the debt), so VCs come in and buy equity instead. If there's some path to which the Fed is printing money and directly washing it through VCs, I'd love to hear how that works. To me it's just more of a market dynamic with low interest rates (which the Fed drives).
- gigatexal 9y agoif the VC has access to a bank which has access to funds at the fed funds rate of < 1% then they can lend or borrow and invest at 10x returns thereby making them a funnel for fed money
- aluminussoma 9y agoI am not the original poster, but I share some similar sentiments. I will try to explain why I agree with that comment: The Federal Reserve has kept interest rates artificially low through its programs, in order to nudge economic growth. In turn, companies have used these low interest rates to borrow vast sums of money. Most have spent it on share repurchases but others have used it to fund acquisitions to chase higher growth. It is in this environment that VC money has thrived, funding candidates for future acquisitions or providing money to large companies (like Uber) to continue growing their business. I am by no means a professional economist. I am just trying to interpret the current situation with the little bit of knowledge I have. I welcome other opinions telling me I am wrong and why.
- Afforess 9y ago
- tedsanders 9y agoI hesitate to comment, but I think the notion that the Fed has caused cheap money is a fallacious narrative that's easy to parrot but hard to explain. The plain truth is that inflation is low. And inflation has been consistently low for years. Sure, the Fed rapidly expanded the base money supply from 2008 to 2014. But the reason they expanded the money supply is that demand for dollars (a safe asset) had skyrocketed. Increasing the supply of money was done to match rising demand for money, in order to keep prices stable. Without that new money, we would have faced deflation (see Japan and Europe) and probably even lower interest rates (again, see Japan and Europe). Monetary policy and monetary theory are complicated. You can argue that inflation is mismeasured somehow. You can argue that people are irrational. You can argue that an increasing money supply will have disparate impacts on industries (e.g., affecting VCs differently than the aggregate economy). But all of these arguments are complicated, subtle, and second-order. It's not enough to say that a rising money supply causes cheap money which causes increased investment. By itself, the logic doesn't hold.
- ethbro 9y agoI think the other thing "cheap money" bypasses is a relative metric. Fed fund rates are low compared to... what? Obviously compared to a hypothetical higher Fed rate, but that's not much of an argument.
- eternalban 9y agoNot just cheap money. The surveillance regime requires platform operators that are idologically aligned. Facebook and Google are the poster children. This 2ns wave is 'estabilishing' the transport platforms. The beauty of this scheme is that the quasi fascist entities are "private" and thus not subjects to laws governing "public" platforms: "it's a private company and they can refuse service to whomever they want."
- maxxxxx 9y agoActually they are investing your pension fund's money or money from your municipality so a lot of people are probably subsidizing themselves. It's mostly not the VCs' own money.
- TremendousJudge 9y agoIf you live in another country (specifically third world) then it's first world pension funds subsidizing rides in third world countries. Kinda weird actually.
- dannyw 9y agoAre you sure you are being subsidised? I was in Denver an Uber driver showed me how much she actually got for my ride. I paid $8 and Uber paid her about $4.20. I started asking every driver afterwards how much they actually got, and all were surprised to hear how much I’m paying. Uber’s real margin seems to be 45-48%. I’m sure in some competitive markets they are being subsidised. But I wouldn’t say everyone using ridesharing is being subsidised.