4 ms·
I don't think there's any "there" there, w/r/t this article. All it's really saying is "some companies build infrastructure and they profit when other companie
by mindcrime 9y ago
I don't think there's any "there" there, w/r/t this article. All it's really saying is "some companies build infrastructure and they profit when other companies use their services". Well duh. In this regard Google or Amazon are no different from the local electric utility. Well, with the exception of that fact that there are many cloud hosting providers to choose from and there is actually some competitive pressure there, where electric providers almost always have a true monopoly.
So Snap is paying Google $400MM USD / year or whatever... OK, now ask "how much would it cost Snap to build their own datacenter(s), host and manage their own services, provide electricity, cooling, etc..." It might or might not add up to the same as they're paying Google, but it would definitely be a significant chunk of money. It's not like Google is taking their money and not providing some value in return!
The flipside of this is that services like AWS, Google Cloud etc. make it FAR, FAR easier and cheaper to spin up a new (software) business. For some of the stuff we're doing at Fogbeam, we would never even be able to start if we had to build a datacenter, buy servers, etc., etc. But we can deploy on AWS for a minimal spend during development, and then scale our use of AWS as we start to generate revenue. If/when the day comes that the economics make sense, we could look at moving to a colo center or even build a dedicated data center.
Personally, I don't begrudge Google, Amazon, etc. the money they're making. shrug
- rhizome 9y ago"Some value" might be your standard, but that doesn't mean the choice is capital-efficient.
- mindcrime 9y agoWho said anything about being capital efficient? The point is that this article is all hyperbole trying to paint Google / Amazon / etc. as vultures who are just ruining startups. And my position is that those startups have to pay somebody for the services they're getting from AmaGoogFaceSoft, even if it means building the services from scratch themselves. And when you balance all of that against the fact that AmaGooFaceSoft enables startups that probably couldn't even exist otherwise (due to large initial capital demands) it's ridiculous to say that those large vendors are somehow detrimental to startups in this regard. I see this article as nothing but click-bait preying on the currently prevailing "woe is me, the sky is falling" negativity meme.
- rhizome 9y agoSo Snap is paying Google $400MM USD / year or whatever... OK, now ask "how much would it cost Snap to build their own datacenter(s), host and manage their own services, provide electricity, cooling, etc..." It might or might not add up to the same as they're paying Google, but it would definitely be a significant chunk of money It definitely wouldn't add up to $400MM.
- peoplewindow 9y agoI agree that the article is kind of useless, but I think you're maybe over-estimating the difficulty of racking your own machines. You don't have to build your own physical building to run your own hardware, and unless you're using tens of thousands of machines they don't die that often. The savings from bringing it in house can be substantial. On the other hand, if you need some of the more exotic cloud services that don't exist or exist very badly in the self hosted space i.e. you are really paying for access to their software stacks, then sure.
- mindcrime 9y agoThe savings from bringing it in house can be substantial. Oh yeah, absolutely. I don't dispute that. But I don't see any reason to think that anybody put a gun to the head of any Snap executives and made them sign the deal with Google. Apparently they thought they were getting their money's worth, or else why sign up? Anyway, all I'm trying to get at is that it isn't like Google are somehow victimizing some poor, defenseless, startup. These guys made a deal that they thought made sense, and they know their business better than any of us.