3 ms·
It isn't silly, it's an exact comparison to Newspeak, which is what the OP was doing. I mean, it's clear as day: the OP didn't even attempt to argue that censor
by peterwwillis 9y ago
It isn't silly, it's an exact comparison to Newspeak, which is what the OP was doing. I mean, it's clear as day: the OP didn't even attempt to argue that censorship isn't happening. They just wanted to change the word describing it to make it feel less like oppression and more like helpfulness.
Don't get caught up in the comparison to a fascist regime. Plenty of left-wing socially conscious movements use this same tactic. I think everyone does this, usually unconsciously.
- tptacek 9y agoIt's censorship in the same sense as Rolling Stone not running your fan-fic on the cover is censorship.
- peterwwillis 9y agoThat is curation. Censorship is the editor telling a writer they can't trash rap music. HN does both.