2 ms·
> The primary benefit of putting people in prison for robbery thus is showing everyone that it's conduct that is so unacceptable that we put people in prison fo
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
> The primary benefit of putting people in prison for robbery thus is showing everyone that it's conduct that is so unacceptable that we put people in prison for it.
Sure, but nobody is proposing repeal of the law against robbery.
And when you look at something like felon in possession of a weapon, the same argument doesn't apply. Felons mostly acquire weapons for self defense like anybody else. Even most felons aren't murderers. And felons have more enemies than most -- former rivals, compatriots who may think you ratted them out, or prosecutors told them you ratted them out whether you did or not.
When the choice is a 5% chance of going back to prison for having a weapon or a 70% chance of getting beat down for not having one, so many people break the law that no social norm can be established.
So the only effect of laws like that is to make things too easy for prosecutors. Round up some ex-convicts at random and you can throw half of them back in prison for years without ever showing that they harmed anyone.
At best prosecutors are only doing this to "bad people" for some entirely subjective definition of bad, but we all know this is exactly the sort of thing that leads to selective prosecution of minorities and dissidents.
The question is how to get rid of laws like that when they have bipartisan support. Republicans like to be "tough on crime" and Democrats like anything that smells like gun control.
- speedplane 9y ago> the only effect of laws like that is to make things too easy for prosecutors No question that judicial and prosecutor efficiency are important factors in deciding to prosecute, but they are not the only ones. Prosecutors often take on difficult cases when there is strong political support for it. For example, after years of dragging their feet, NYC prosecutors tried to convict someone (anyone) involved in the 2008 financial crisis. They got a few people on the sides, but their effort was mostly seen as a failure. Still, it was probably better that they tried and failed rather than not tried at all. Another example is the war on drugs in the 1990s. As far as efficiency and resources, it was a horrible program, not easy or efficient by any measure, but the country was terrified of drug use and it's related crime. The goal was based more in societal norms than efficiency. Last example, Mayor Guiliani's tactics of removing small crimes (illegal street vendors, minor trespassing, graffiti) was based in the theory that you can improve entire neighborhoods and reduce major crimes by eliminating the smaller ones. Again, unclear if this tactic really worked, but it's clear that his aim was not purely judicial efficiency, it was economic development. These cases were not efficient at all, but there was strong demand to