4 ms·
"A few days later, the defendant’s hand was inspected: if it was burned, he was guilty; if not, he was innocent." No. That isn't how it worked. The miracle w
by sandworm101 9y ago
"A few days later, the defendant’s hand was inspected: if it was burned, he was guilty; if not, he was innocent."
No. That isn't how it worked. The miracle was not that the hand was not burnt. It always burned. God's intervention was measured upon whether or not the hand was healing. If it was infected then god was not with you (and there was a good chance you would die). If the wound/burn was healing nicely then god was with you.
They did not expect miracles so dramatic as a hand not being burnt. To think that they did suggests that everyone was found guilty. They were not. The OP also suggests that ordeals were rigged. Some certainly were but people in the past weren't idiots. They knew what boiling water or red-hot iron looked like, fat better than we do today. They could spot a trick.
Trial by ordeal was not some scam or legal trick. People actually believed in the process took it very seriously. And we see remnants of it today. Many still believe that sickness and recovery from wounds involves "faith" and regularly pray for healing. Others believe that sickness is the result of God's displeasure, evidence of sin. Trial by ordeal is alive and well.
- fjsolwmv 9y agoI wouldn't argue too much from modern religious thoughrt. Much of modern religion is obvious jokes and scams and become "divine truth" via the passage of time. See Scientology and Mormonism for the newest examples, and realize that Islam and Christianity were not so different.