7 ms·
Pay attention to the 2nd dot point under known issues. This release uses Wayland, and that has profound implications for screenshot, streaming and remote deskto
by roenxi 9y ago
Pay attention to the 2nd dot point under known issues. This release uses Wayland, and that has profound implications for screenshot, streaming and remote desktop-ing.
The Wayland protocol apparently made some bold decisions to enforce security through isolation, and apart from the compositor it is all but impossible for anything to sneak a peak at what other programs are doing visually. It'll be interesting to see if that causes users a problem.
- SmellyGeekBoy 9y agoNot to mention HiDPI problems and serious issues with the proprietary nvidia driver. The situation is improving all the time though and hopefully this should mark the beginning of some good times for Wayland. More choice is always a good thing. Of course, the option is right there on the login screen to start an X session instead, if Wayland doesn't work for you.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoThat's interesting, I was hoping for some improvements in HiDPI support with the shift to Wayland.
- lultimouomo 9y agoOn a Debain sid install I was somehow recently bumped from Gnome3 on X11 toi Gnome3 on wayland. Chromium and Qt apps got broken scaling; I solved it by forcing the session to be Gnome3 on X11. This is just anecdote of course! I would have liked to dig more into it and figure things out, but honestly I just had too much to do and chose whatever was working for me.
- jbicha 9y agoHave you tried again after upgrading to gnome-shell 3.26 (it's only been in Debian unstable for one week)?
- lultimouomo 9y agoTried right now; QtCreator and chromium are still broken. Curiously, the former is super tiny and the latter huge!
- ganeshkrishnan 9y agoNo issues with Gnome 3.26 HiDPI on Wayland using nvidia driver. I was running alpha version of 17.10 on my Dell XPS with minimal issues
- bklaasen 9y agoWhich generation XPS is that?
- ganeshkrishnan 9y agoXPS 9560
- madez 9y agoI recommend everybody intending to run Linux to avoid nvidia GPUs. The experience with amd and intel GPUs is vastly superior.
- rootbear 9y agoI use nothing but Nvidia on Linux. Their performance and stability is greatly superior to AMD on high-end 3D applications such as Maya. I'll admit, I have not revisited AMD cards in a while, so perhaps I'm out of touch with the current generation. I also do not consider the open source nouveau driver to be acceptable. I've had too many problems with it in 3D apps.
- danieldk 9y agoBut their proprietary driver is lagging behind a lot of the ecosystem. E.g. until recently their driver did not work with Wayland/mutter because NVIDIA was pushing their own device memory allocator (via the EGLStreams API). It seems that it now finally works, but is very slow. In contrast, AMD is actively contributing to the open source amdgpu driver.
- rootbear 9y agoYes, I wish Nvidia was a bit more generous with the open source community, but for some situations, they are the best choice, if not the only choice.
- plus 9y ago>until recently their driver did not work with Wayland/mutter because NVIDIA was pushing their own device memory allocator (via the EGLStreams API). It seems that it now finally works, but is very slow. Can you give a source for this? I'd be very much interested in trying out Plasma on Wayland on NVIDIA, but I can't find any information about NVIDIA implementing GBM.
- smacktoward 9y agoYour experience is not incompatible with the parent commenter's. On Linux, generally speaking, Intel > NVidia > AMD.
- hyperbovine 9y agoI'm writing this on 17.10, a 1080Ti and a 4k monitor. Other than the lack of video acceleration in any browser (which is not specific to this setup), it's fine.
- gtirloni 9y agoFedora's transition to Wayland was smooth. We work with screen readers here and things just kept working.
- angrygoat 9y agoWith Fedora jumping over nearly a year ago to Wayland as default in F25, and now Ubuntu in a non-LTS release, hopefully we'll see a tipping point where software (especially third-party/proprietary software) simply must work well on Wayland in order to have a user base. Once we've got an Ubuntu LTS and a RHEL/CentOS release out there with Wayland by default, X11 ought to rapidly become a thing of the past. There's Xwayland, but with any luck that'll become something you basically never use, just like happened with Xquartz.
- reacweb 9y agoI have bought a new desktop this spring. The first thing I did was configuring wake on lan (in France, we have 7 days to cancel a purchase). The second one was to configure ssh and gnome to be able to administer it remotely (line DisallowTCP=false in /etc/gdm3/custom.conf). I use Linux at work since 1999 and I have used a local display less than 1% of the time. An application that does not work remotely does not exist for me.
- shakna 9y agoGnome Remote Desktop [0] is coming, it reached Fedora stable on September 30th, but exposes an API that allows Wayland and Gnome to work together over a remote connection. For all other uses, you always have xwayland [1], until they adopt the new guy. [0] https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1483499 https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1483499 [1] https://wayland.freedesktop.org/xserver.html https://wayland.freedesktop.org/xserver.html
- majewsky 9y ago1% of users with very particular requirements should not hold back the experience of the other 99%.
- castle-bravo 9y agoSomething as fundamental as remote desktop should not be sacrificed for the convenience of a tiny minority of developers.
- asfdsfggtfd 9y agoHang on did they drop Mir?
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoYes.
- rippsu 9y agoNo
- XzetaU8 9y agohttps://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=Mir-0.28-Artful https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=Mir-0.28...
- shakna 9y agoYou've had both yes and no answers. The answer is no. Mir 0.28 landed just in time for 17.10, as a sibling linked. This version includes basic Wayland support. A read over Mir/Spec [0] shows that though they don't want Wayland to be at the core of Mir, they want to be able to talk and integrate with it at a higher level. It should be noted that Mir is only installed by default on Ubuntu Touch, and probably won't be integrated into the desktop by default until Unity8 is ready. [0] https://wiki.ubuntu.com/Mir/Spec?action=show&redirect=MirSpec#Why_Not_Wayland_.2F_Weston.3F https://wiki.ubuntu.com/Mir/Spec?action=show&redirect=MirSpe...
- teekert 9y agoUnity8 is as dead as Ubuntu Phone (if you don't count community forks). Gnome is the future of Ubuntu, there will be no Mir, there will be no Unity8.
- shakna 9y agoAs I said, Mir has a fresh release in this release, and continued development. If it's dead in the water... You might want to go tell the team.
- krisgenre 9y agoOh! thanks for the comment about screenshot. I was thinking on upgrading to 17.10 (still on 14.04) and one of my most handy app is Shutter. Looks like it doesn't work on wayland - https://bugs.launchpad.net/shutter/+bug/1502263 https://bugs.launchpad.net/shutter/+bug/1502263
- jhasse 9y agoYou can still use X11 on 17.10, just select it on the login screen :)
- randallsquared 9y agoI've been using Wayland (with nouveau) in the Artful beta for over a month, and screenshots haven't been an issue... I didn't notice anything was supposed to be wrong, there.
- jbicha 9y agoIt depends on the app whether screenshots work. Some apps use the GNOME screenshot API and are fine; other apps assume X.
- joelthelion 9y agoI've been using Gnome on Wayland as my primary desktop on Arch and Fedora for several months if not a year. It's a marked improvement over Gnome/Xorg, and most of the issues have now been resolved. You might need to find new ways to accomplish a few tasks, though. But I can attest it works. Edit: fix desktop/compositor confusion
- majewsky 9y agoSmall but important nitpick: Wayland is not a desktop, it's a set of protocols for GUI compositing. "Plasma on Wayland" or "Gnome on Wayland" or Sway or Weston is.
- jhasse 9y agoDid it crash yet? That has been the blocker for me so far, since on wayland GNOME Shell crashes will bring down the whole session.
- fmoralesc 9y agognome-shell in 3.26 can be reloaded, so in case it crashes it shouldn't take down the session anymore, I think.
- jhasse 9y agoDo you have a source? The bug report about it is still open AFAIK.
- fmoralesc 9y agoWell, myself. I am using the wayland session and just restarted the shell with <Alt-f2>r. EDIT: Well, I just checked and it turns out I am not running the wayland session! I will have to investigate why...
- runeks 9y ago> It's a marked improvement over Gnome/Xorg […] How so?
- ganeshkrishnan 9y ago>. It'll be interesting to see if that causes users a problem. The only issue I had was Synaptic was crashing. Other than that I have fewer crashes and hangs on wayland compared to X