3 ms·
"Periodic" Cosmological models without a Big Bang are not new. They are easily extracted form the usual equations under certain conditions and it's one of the t
by Anon84 16y ago
"Periodic" Cosmological models without a Big Bang are not new. They are easily extracted form the usual equations under certain conditions and it's one of the typical exercises you do in an intro do cosmology class.
What seems to be new here is that this specific model seems to explain something that has yet to be well understood. This is a big win for this model but it can easily mean that it happens to capture part of real mechanism in that specific aspect while making unrealistic assumptions elsewhere (like the possibility of there not having been a Big Bang).
It will be interesting to see how this model affects our current understanding of the universe. It might be a complete change, or just an incremental one. Odds are on the latter one but the former makes for much better blog posts... ;)
- dazzawazza 16y agoI like it when 'non standard' models get some attention. It shakes things up and maybe a eureka moment will happen.
- wlievens 16y agoUnfortunately many (most?) 'non-standard' theories are absolute crap, and it's hard for non-experts to separate signal from noise. For proof, see the perpetual energy source products that pop up every few months. (not talking about this article in particular)
- mjfisher 16y agoGood to know! If a periodic model is a potentially viable way of looking at things, could it be squared with thermodynamics? Specifically, the constant increase in total entropy.
- eru 16y agoThermodynamics just says that entropy can't decrease in a closed system. So entropy can stay constant, and in an open system everything can happen.
- flipbrad 16y agovery difficult for entropy to stay constant in a closed system. And surely universality (all-encompassing, there-is-nothing-else) means closed system? Or are we looking at open and closed in the wrong way; if the universe is periodic, could entropy decrease with order 'warping in' from a different point in time (future or past) if time happened to fold or loop over itself to feed into the back of it?
- eru 16y ago> And surely universality (all-encompassing, there-is-nothing-else) means closed system? Not necessarily. The question isn't really settled. It seems quite complicated when you get to those scales. E.g. just as an analogy, in general relativity even energy isn't really conserved. (See http://math.ucr.edu/home//baez/physics/Relativity/GR/energy_gr.html http://math.ucr.edu/home//baez/physics/Relativity/GR/energy_...) So I don't know whether we can say anything definite about entropy.
- Yzupnick 16y ago"making unrealistic assumptions elsewhere (like the possibility of there not having been a Big Bang)" I'm not sure I agree with this line. Copernicus made the "unrealistic assumption" that heavenly bodies and motions were not spherical, and Galileo made the "unrealistic assumption" that earth wasn't the center of the Earth. This type of thinking hampers scientific progress.
- JshWright 16y agoYeah, and George Smith made the "unrealistic assumption" that the moon was made of cheese, and John Doe made the "unrealistic assumption" that dogs communicate telepathically... While there are certainly a handful of "unrealistic assumptions" that have lead to scientific breakthroughs, giving credence to an idea simply because it is unrealistic is... well... unrealistic.
- evilduck 16y agoI don't know if I'd say they made unrealistic assumptions. Geocentrism failed to make accurate predictions and required a whole slew of tricks to reconcile the problems. Heliocentrism was "unrealistic" because the church disagreed with it, not because it disagreed with observations. It also took approximately 300 years for common opinion to shift from a Ptolemic universe to Heliocentrism. We're on a much shorter time scale for the Big Bang theory, and it's very well acknowledged the theory has problems.
- william42 16y agoGalileo's problem wasn't that he made an "unrealistic assumption", it was that he couldn't explain the lack of visible parallax. (It turns out the answer to that was that we didn't have good enough equipment.)