5 ms·
It is worth noting that there likely isn't going to be a single cure for dyslexia in a similar way that there won't be a single cure for cancer. Dyslexia is re
by slg 9y ago
It is worth noting that there likely isn't going to be a single cure for dyslexia in a similar way that there won't be a single cure for cancer. Dyslexia is really a collection of disorders that are grouped together because they share common symptoms but not necessarily common causes.
It sounds like this could help the stereotypical "see letters backwards" type of dyslexia. However there are numerous forms of dyslexia that have nothing to do with inverted images or difficulty identifying letters. For example, many dyslexics are able to write code or do math without the symptoms they might experience when reading/writing prose. That wouldn't be the case if the problem was based on vision.
- bryanrasmussen 9y agoright, lots of children with SLI later go on to be diagnosed with Dyslexia, I doubt language learning problems are related to the eyes.
- jdietrich 9y ago>Dyslexia is really a collection of disorders It's a practically meaningless catch-all, because the only useful definition is "bad at reading". The DSM5 politely declines to offer any diagnostic criteria. The only treatment that consistently beats placebo is reading practice; dyslexic students improve at about the same rate as non-dyslexic students after intensive reading practice. By the logic we use to diagnose dyslexia, I have countless developmental disorders, by simple merit of being bad at lots of things. It's entirely plausible that specific but as yet unknown developmental disorders have been lumped in to the classification of dyslexia, but dyslexia itself is a politically convenient label rather than an evidence-based disorder.
- timthelion 9y agoI agree. I also think that autism spectrum disorder is a meaningless catch all. But I further believe that these catch alls are harmful and should not be used. When I was in school I read a lot of papers on autism, and I found that almost all studies found that there is no general biological cause for autism, but there were always outliers. Some 20% of autism sufferers, for example, have significantly raised serotonin. I think, that rather than concluding in study after study that, "though some subjects showed signs of raised serotonin, this was not found to be a reliable indicator of autism". We really should have created a new disorder "speech delay with elevated serotonin disorder". And started studying that as a separate dissorder. Maybe we would have gotten somewhere. But instead, the US spent millions, perhaps billions of dollars trying to figure out the one and only reason why some people can't walk. "Oh no, it can't be because they don't have legs, 90% of people who can't walk DO have legs!"
- LaikaF 9y agoI think depression has the same problem. While I'm aware there are several types there's no really no guarantee for success for any particular medication or treatment for every case.
- timthelion 9y agoYes, but with depression the subtypes are recognized by medicine. For example, it short allele[1] is a recognized cause of depression, as is loss triggered depression[2]. And there is fruitfull research on the subtypes. When I am feeling paranoid and cynical, I go as far as to think that the reason for not having split up the autistic spectrum, as has been done with depression, long ago is that there is a lot of funding ear marked specifically for "autism" which would go away if you started actually breaking out the real causes. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15877307 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15877307 [2] https://www.mentalhelp.net/blogs/the-difference-between-grief-and-depression-the-dsm-v/ https://www.mentalhelp.net/blogs/the-difference-between-grie...
- kolinko 9y agoIf I'm not mistaken, this is true for most of the psychiatric disorders. Since we are yet unable to figure out the exact causes, and distinguish between variants, we group them by the appearance.
- DiThi 9y ago> isn't going to be a single cure for dyslexia Except not forcing children to learn to read too soon. In the 49 years since the Sudbury Valley school was open, not a single case of dyslexia was diagnosed. Because nobody was forced to learn to read, a few even not learning to read until their mid teens. Dyslexia is just one more problem of the "one size fits all" education system. Some people need to learn at a very different pace or order to learn properly without future difficulties.
- Oxitendwe 9y agoIs forcing children to eat their vegetables, take regular baths, and go to bed on time an example of "one size fits all" parenting? I find it very difficult to believe that learning to read later in life won't adversely affect your maximum reading proficiency later in life, a very concerning "future difficulty" as it is the most basic possible skill required to function in society after learning to speak. I don't think either that it makes sense to give children a choice in the specific matter of whether or not they should be instructed in this skill that is so critical to their development and usefulness to society - they are by definition the least experienced and informed about the consequences of their decisions. That's not to say I don't think kids should have a choice in anything, just that part of raising children involves not letting them make choices that significantly and adversely affect their future.
- DiThi 9y ago> Is forcing children to eat their vegetables, take regular baths, and go to bed on time an example of "one size fits all" parenting? Each parent has a different style, sometimes very different from one to the neighbor. For good or bad, there's no official manual on being a parent. On the other side every child has to learn every item of a bunch of subjects at each specific age. > I find it very difficult to believe that learning to read later in life won't adversely affect your maximum reading proficiency later in life. All Sudbury Valley School students have excellent SAT scores. Also, children of Finland which have the highest PISA score in the world don't learn to read until a few years later than in other places of the world. > it is the most basic possible skill required to function in society after learning to speak Maybe recognizing e.g. subtle differences in dense shapes is more important. Or basic things like remembering left and right. Things one shouldn't rush. Things children learn by playing. Reading depends heavily on those. > I don't think either that it makes sense to give children a choice in the specific matter of whether or not they should be instructed in this skill that is so critical to their development and usefulness to society Why not? You forget that children _are_ social, even more so in an environment like SVS where they have voice and vote to decide on school matters. Children are very curious and _want_ to learn stuff. As I said, all students have very good SAT scores. Also they're regarded as having very good social skills and tend to be very successful. Is there any better measure of the outcome? > they are by definition the least experienced and informed about the consequences of their decisions And the best course of action is not giving them the exposure to gain experience? SVS is not just "children do whatever they want all day". There are rules. Made and voted by all children. Most people don't have that kind of social interaction until much later in life. Instead they get bullies. Or they become bullies. > That's not to say I don't think kids should have a choice in anything, just that part of raising children involves not letting them make choices that significantly and adversely affect their future. Read more about SVS, or read the work of John Taylor Gatto. You may rethink what kind of choices are adversely affecting their future.