4 ms·
I did an in depth review of the research for a Human Computer Interaction class in college a couple years back before the Taylor and Francis study and the resea
by slg 9y ago
I did an in depth review of the research for a Human Computer Interaction class in college a couple years back before the Taylor and Francis study and the research then generally agreed with the idea that reading a print book was the best for comprehension (I tried quickly searching for the paper to pull sources, but no luck). However that difference appeared to be mostly related to form factor and not necessarily from the screen itself. Studies that used tablets showed smaller gaps in performance than studies that used computers. Studies that used e-ink e-readers showed almost no difference in comprehension. I was not able to find a single study that compared more than 2 or 3 different devices using the same methodology. If I were to design a study I would want to see a full range of tests including print books, e-ink e-readers, tablets with full color screens, traditional computer monitors, and e-ink monitors. Hopefully then you could better isolate the cause of the lower comprehension.
My own hypothesis (I have a comp sci degree, so take this psychology explanation with a grain of salt) is that comprehension is more dependent on the person's approach to the technology rather than the technology itself. Books are single purpose devices. When you have a book in your hand your brain knows it is time to focus on reading. When you sit down at a computer, the brain doesn't know what to expect or to focus on. It is similar to other advice about training your brain to expect certain activities such as reserving your bedroom only for sleeping or to have a dedicated home office if you work remotely.
- Moru 9y agoI find it personally important how fast the device is and how easy it is to use, if I can quickly look up things in the document and find my way back. If chapter references are clickable and so on.
- slg 9y agoI certainly agree with that. There are features available on each device that change their usability and that should be factored in when deciding what should be used in the classroom. However preferences for the different functionality isn't particularly interesting from a research perspective. It will vary too widely among users and use cases (e.g. novels have different feature demands than textbooks). The fact that reading comprehension varies between the devices is more counterintuitive and it isn't immediately clear why those differences exists. That is probably why most of the research on this topic focuses on comprehension.
- derefr 9y agoI wonder how much the gap would be narrowed simply by being able to put general-purpose devices into an instructor-locked single-app mode.
- azag0 9y agoI’d expect the conditioning to be subconscious. Doesn’t matter the computer is locked down. Your brain sees a computer, which triggers a multitasking, distraction-rich mode.
- jcfrei 9y agoHow did you test comprehension in the study? With a test on a screen, paper or verbally? If I recall correctly similar environments in test taking and learning have a big impact on your capacity to remember (and probably also on comprehension).
- nabla9 9y agoMy hypothesis is that the difference is related to how memory works by associations and spatial cognition. I read lots of research papers and books. I have tried to switch to e-readers several times, but it never works. I learn the subject slower and I remember much less of what I read from e-reader. I use computers and e-readers to skim or check some details, but never to thoroughly study. If I read physical book or printed article and underline it, leave coffee stains on the paper etc. I'm working with actual physical object. When I achieve the paper in a map, I can often recall where the book is stored physically and even the coffee stains and notes in the paper. I think physical book or paper works the same way as memory palace technique. You remember stuff by working with them physically better than in abstract. Physical library might be mirrored in our mind. Ancient augmented memory technology we did not know we have and might lose. E-reader or computer associates everything to the same object.
- danmaz74 9y agoIt's the same for me - I really enjoy ebooks for non-study material though. I wonder if it will be the same for my daughter :)
- nabla9 9y agoebooks are great for reading novels.
- the_af 9y agoI'm unsure... E-readers are wonderfully convenient to store multiple novels, but my experience is the same as in your previous post, even for novels. I tend to read non-sequentially -- going backwards and forwards in novels, re-reading previous chapters, going back a bit to re-read a paragraph I liked -- and e-readers are simply not good for that. Printed books are way better. I tend to remember what I read in paper books better than ebooks, exactly what you described for academic papers!
- danmaz74 9y ago
- posterboy 9y ago> When you sit down at a computer, the brain doesn't know what to expect or to focus on but on the upside, there really is a lot more depth to using a computer. Hyperlinks alone are a timesaver already; simple dynamic applications like animation/diagramming, interactive text search or, in technical topics, whole virtual environments that text is merely companion too are a huge boon for engagement and neigh impossible in plaintext.
- aswanson 9y agoMaybe that's a curse in disguise. Too much choice, directions to branch off in causes dissonance. Paradox of choice.
- alexc05 9y agoI'd add that I also think there is a three dimensional cataloging of information that you get from using a thick textbook. "Chapter 19" gets stored in your own memory in three dimensional space. Flipping backwards and forwards on topics can result in an unintentional mnemonic device. Especially when you consider a typical introduction to of comp-sci textbook (for example) the foundational principles (input, output, variables, loops) are all organized at the FRONT of the book. Things of increasing complexity are gated behind the foundations. Now that's also probably just a window into how my 40 year old brain grew up. With textbooks etc... there's nothing to say that younger brains won't re-wire themselves to learn from a screen and find their own mnemonics - maybe it's left and right as opposed to forward and back.