3 ms·
There’s been an explosion in the engine, and the plane is going to crash in 15 minutes. There’s no chance of survival. There is a potential way out—the plane ha
by analog31 9y ago
There’s been an explosion in the engine, and the plane is going to crash in 15 minutes. There’s no chance of survival. There is a potential way out—the plane happens to be transferring a shipment of parachutes....
Those who choose not to take that option, please remain in your seat—this will be over soon, and you will feel no pain.
Why does this argument strike me as analogous to Pascal's Wager? You can pray for an afterlife, or not. Your choice. Which do you choose?
- doctoboggan 9y agoThe difference as I see it (as a non-believer) is if I could just choose to believe in God, I would as that would be much easier and probably make me feel better. I can't force myself to believe something, but I can just choose to sign up for Alcor
- analog31 9y agoBut I'm not asking for belief. Just prayer. Or maybe even just money. In my view, cryonics is just a synthetic religion that has been constructed to replace supernatural stuff with technological-sounding stuff. It should appeal to people who have rejected the supernatural but are still afraid of the finality of death.
- apsec112 9y agoThis is the fallacy of Bulverism (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bulverism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bulverism): "You must show that a man is wrong before you start explaining why he is wrong. The modern method is to assume without discussion that he is wrong and then distract his attention from this (the only real issue) by busily explaining how he became so silly." - C.S. Lewis In this case, the real issue (how likely cryonics patients are to be revived) is replaced with the alleged motives of the debater ("fear of death", although I'd argue that almost everyone is afraid of death; most people would feel fear if a gun was pointed at them).
- analog31 9y agoThat's fair. It's a puzzling situation. I don't think it's possible to prove that cryonics is wrong, because it strikes me as a non-falsifiable proposition.
- ggreer 9y agoI can think of several things: - If neuroscientists find that long term memory is encoded in something not preserved by cryonics. (Such as pH levels around certain neurons, or some weird quantum phenomena.) - If small animals such as mice are trained to perform some task, then fail to demonstrate that training after being cryopreserved & revived. This requires technological advances, but not as much as human-level revival. - If scientists discover a theory of consciousness that precludes its resumption after cryopreservation-like circumstances. (This would also mean that philosophical zombies are possible.) Some of these may seem like a tall order, but if cryonics doesn't work, then that would tell us something new about biology, physics, and/or the nature of consciousness. So far, we've seen all the evidence you'd expect to see if cryonics works: Memories are preserved even after cessation or disruption of electrical activity in the brain. Embryos and other tissues are cryopreserved and thawed without problems. Small mammal organs have been successfully cryopreserved and thawed, and remained functional. SEM micrographs of cryopreserved brain tissue show intact structure, including axons and synaptic vesicles. Most of the problems seem to be in the implementation, not the principle itself. (eg: avoiding warm ischemia when people die suddenly)
- evgen 9y ago> Small mammal organs have been successfully cryopreserved and thawed, and remained functional Wow, nice rhetorical dodge there. No one cares too much if small mammal 'organs' have been successfully cryopreserved and revived because we can replace your kidney and you are still you. Tell me about the small mammal BRAINS that you have cryopreserved and revived with any evidence of retention of memories or prior training. Tell me about any nervous systems at all which you have successfully preserved and revived. Doesn't have to be a mammal, I would settle for an insect. Tell me about those please. Until you can do this you are just selling another version of snake oil.
- apsec112 9y agoAn afterlife would require fundamental revisions to the laws of physics, while cryonics does not (as the article goes on to explain). Pascal's Wager is about how an infinite payoff leads to infinite expected value, regardless of the odds. There are no infinities anywhere in cryonics, it's just a question of weighing the odds against the expected payoff, like taking a risky new drug or any other experimental medical procedure.
- analog31 9y ago... or sending money to Nigeria, to transfer millions of dollars to your name, which also doesn't violate the laws of physics. The traditional afterlife of religion was constructed to obey physics as it was understood at the time.
- saint_fiasco 9y agoIt is a bit similar. The issue with Pascal's Wager is that you do not know a priori if praying for a good afterlife makes the good afterlife more or less likely. For example maybe you pray to Jesus and then Allah disapproves of your idolatry. You just can't know, because it's impossible to reason about supernatural stuff. With cryonics, though, you can be pretty sure that you are not going to be more dead. There is a small probability you will be revived in a dystopian world and regret it. You can never know for sure, but you can at least reason about it and think about the probabilities given what you know about human nature and history and so on.
- ggreer 9y agoPascal's Wager posits an infinitely large reward, meaning that even a tiny (but finite) chance of the proposition being true still has an infinite expected value. Cryonics has a large (but still finite) reward. If you think the chances of cryonics are low enough, then it's not worth pursuing.
- MichaelGG 9y agoPascal assumes one true God or not. For all he could prove, maybe the afterlife punishes people for choosing that God. All that aside, there's zero evidence to believe in an afterlife. With cryonics we in theory understand it, if the brain is just its atoms, then it's quite conceivable that the information might be able to be reconstructed. I don't see how they are comparable.
- QAPereo 9y agoThat brain is going to be a brain slurry after freezing, but hey, I’m scared of dying too so I get it. I’m just no more able to buy into the fantasy of cryonics or digital afterlives than I am the “divine” kind. More than anything it strikes me as old hopes, dreams, and fears in a new skin, like “Simulated Universe” theory.
- apsec112 9y ago"Brain slurry" is not an accurate description; modern providers use vitrification and perfused cryoprotectants to prevent freezing damage. http://www.alcor.org/FAQs/faq02.html http://www.alcor.org/FAQs/faq02.html
- QAPereo 9y agoHere's the view from sources other than people trying to sell you something. https://msu.edu/~ciofujac/ https://msu.edu/~ciofujac/ https://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2016/01/29/how-can-you-protect-a-brain-by-destroying-it/ https://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2016/01/29/how-can-y...
- enoch_r 9y agoPascal's wager boils down to "vanishingly small likelihood, but nearly infinite reward." It's fascinating because it's difficult to get to a reasonable answer in a way that is consistent with normal utility-maximizing behavior. Comparing probabilities and expected costs and benefits is normally an extremely useful thing to do, and it doesn't just automatically stop being useful when the probabilities get small (consider that many people choose to buy insurance even when only a small percentage end up benefiting from their decision). Fundamentally this boils down to a pretty simple question: what's the likelihood that cryonics will "pay out"? If your answer is 0.00001%, sure, don't sign up. But if your answer is, say, 2%, then maybe it's worth it.
- KGIII 9y agoI'm taking the parachute. How often do you get to jump out of a fiery wreck of a plane? Besides, if there is a deity, I'm probably well passed the threshold for acceptance in a mere few minutes. If I find out there's a deity, I'm going to punch them right in the mouth.