4 ms·
As usual, I like Philip Greenspun's explanation better than all of the anecdotes and fuzzy generalizations in this blog post: http://philip.greenspun.com/career
by gwern 16y ago
As usual, I like Philip Greenspun's explanation better than all of the anecdotes and fuzzy generalizations in this blog post: http://philip.greenspun.com/careers/acm-women-in-computing http://philip.greenspun.com/careers/acm-women-in-computing http://philip.greenspun.com/careers/women-in-science http://philip.greenspun.com/careers/women-in-science
tl;dr: It's because the women who would do well in CS/STEM have much better paying, or easier, or more prestigious options available to them.
- mattdw 16y ago…or, you know, the directly hostile and sexist things women sometimes experience in the industry. As described in the original post. Not to say that Greenspun is wrong in his conclusions, but when women are saying "I find it unpleasant to be in the industry because…", it seems kinda patronising to turn around and suggest that they're wrong.
- btn 16y agoIt's not saying that they're wrong, but that there are factors beside sexism and bigotry that contribute to the problem.
- Tichy 16y agoTo experience the sexist things, you would first have to enter the industry, though. I somewhat doubt it is a good explanation. Also, is life in CS really so unbearable for Stubbornella and other women?
- AndyKelley 16y agoThe problem I have with that logic is, why wouldn't men decide the same thing? The author's reasoning seems to be 1. young men strive to achieve high status among their peer group 2. men tend to lack perspective and are unable to step back and ask the question "is this peer group worth impressing?" but I ask, why? The article seems to be rejecting the idea that men are naturally better than women at programming (and some other ideas) and embracing the idea that women are naturally better than men at finding a suitable career. I suppose this is just as valid of a hypothesis, but I don't think it is good enough to simply dismiss the other one.
- Tichy 16y agoFor one thing, achieving high status might not be so relevant for a woman. A womb is inherently valuable, whereas men have to prove by status that they can take care of a child. Or rather, in theory one high status male can make babies with a lot of low status women. It may not quite work that way anymore in todays society (? I am not high status enough to know), but it might still be genetically driving our behavior.
- cabalamat 16y ago> It may not quite work that way anymore in todays society Whether or not this is true today is irrelevant; what matters is whether it was true in the environment of evolutionary adaptation.
- gwern 16y ago> men are naturally better than women at programming (and some other ideas) and embracing the idea that women are naturally better than men at finding a suitable career. If it's plausible enough that millions of young women can have their career and life choices distorted away from STEM by a little sexism (a distortion in the dozens or scores of percents), then why isn't it even more plausible that millions of young men can suffer from well-known traits linked with autism or Asperger's (which are known to be vastly more common in males) and make choices distorted towards STEM?
- derefr 16y agoIt's not that they're not equally plausible; it's that they're not equally solvable. We can "fix" sexism (and thus cause the "right" number of women to go into STEM); we can't "fix" Autism-linked chromosomes in people who have already been born.
- gwern 16y agoDoes reality care whether something you have a problem with is solvable?
- 16y ago