3 ms·
If 95% really was evil, not merely terrorized themselves or unaware and there was no better way to oppose the 95% then 5% would be unfortunate but perfectly acc
by michaelmrose 9y ago
If 95% really was evil, not merely terrorized themselves or unaware and there was no better way to oppose the 95% then 5% would be unfortunate but perfectly acceptable collateral damage. I would be surprised if any large scale conflict was less damaging.
- Retric 9y agoNow, having said that, I am going to define 'evil' as failure to follow the correct religion.(1) Again, in my original statement I never said anything about what they did or did not do just applied a label and suddenly by your comment total genocide is ok. (1) Historically a commonly accepted definition of 'evil'. PS: I am in no way supporting the horrors humanity has produced. Just commenting on how easy it is to apply labels and then by your own words kill millions of innocent people.
- michaelmrose 9y agoEvil is really hard to define in any remotely acceptable way. If 95% of a population was actively dangerous to the safety of me or people I cared about I would totally be OK with harming up to and including killing the innocent 5% if and only if there wasn't a better way. Herein population can be understood to mean any group of people from a small band of individuals up to the population of a continent. This isn't morally reasonable because I would in fact probably sacrifice any number of people who are not close to me for those that are however I tend to think that the majority would make the same decision. This is why having individuals make such life and death decisions would probably be a bad idea. I don't think I could reasonably on the other hand punish the guilty 1% and also the innocent 99%. I guess everyone probably has a line but I don't know if you can ethically define and what point it becomes right or wrong because I don't think most people consider even the mundane choices they make logically. I think most such choices are actually made emotionally.
- Retric 9y ago> I think most such choices are actually made emotionally. I would go so far as to suggest most choices are made emotionally. Brand advertising and propaganda are used because they work. Also, I must complement you for honesty, and I think most people share your views. I can only comment that very rarely is a population a meaningful direct threat rather than at worst a dangerous tool, but those terms will be banded about to leverage our natural responses.