4 ms·
> One of our guiding principles in developing Microsoft Edge is that end users should never have to worry about which sites work in which browsers. This philoso
by shmerl 9y ago
> One of our guiding principles in developing Microsoft Edge is that end users should never have to worry about which sites work in which browsers. This philosophy—”the Web should just work for everyone“—led to our choice to target the “interoperable intersection” of web APIs in our browser engineering.
That's a good move by MS. In this context it's great to see them supporting open codecs, and for istance OGG container for audio which was recently announced as work in progress in Edge. Quite a turnaround from the old times of "best viewed with IE", ActiveX, Silverlight and etc.
Why can't MS apply same principle across all their teams? Compare the above to their push for 3D graphics API lock-in.
- roblabla 9y agoBecause video-games is still the one place where Mac and Linux are lagging behind, and they have DirectX to thank a lot for that.
- shmerl 9y agoSo, MS isn't new, it's same old MS, and their good behavior happens only when they already lost their monopolistic grip. Q.E.D.?
- CapacitorSet 9y agoPrivatize the profits, socialise the losses. This is why commercial companies cannot be trusted to sustain a wiki, open source, or free software model.
- skocznymroczny 9y agoIn case of Linux, you forgot availability of drivers, cohesive user experience, stability and ergonomy rather than programmer designed interfaces.
- roblabla 9y agoI guess I should have said "Mac or Linux", but I'll answer your points because they tick me off. First some context : I'm both a Windows, Mac and Linux user, and my favorite is probably Mac. But I've converted a fair share of my family to Linux (my grandma too) because it's more predictable than Windows, and cheaper than MacOS (I'm basically my family's IT hotline). Most of what I'll talk here is a mix of my own experience, and feedback from my family members. Let's talk about drivers. Turns out, drivers are available for most of the hardware you'll need (which is basically GPU, WiFi, Bluetooth and Webcam). Sure, this weird piece of equipment might not have linux drivers, but in truth I can't even remember the last time I've hit that problem. I don't think equipment compatibility is the reason people use Windows in 2017 anyway, given we're all using Android/Linux on our smartphones and tablets, so I'll move on. Let's talk about cohesive UX. Windows, since 8 and 10, has the least cohesive UX ever. Running Gnome or KDE on Linux today will get you a more cohesive UX than win10, and that's no compliment. Half the Windows apps still use the old winforms look, half use the new metro (or whatever it is called) look, and then there's all the webapps that have their own custom look and feel. Cortana is a clusterfuck of an UX, the File Manager has this weird "It's a filesystem but not really" mentality (the location bar doesn't show the full hierarchy, WHY ?), and there are so many papercuts here and there that I end up fighting my OS half the time. Let's talk about stability. Windows forces reboots every few days because it has "mandatory updates". Windows basically built this feature where they force the computer to reboot and the user has absolutely no say in the matter. This is not the stability guarantee I'm looking for. Another anecdata : one of the few family members to still have a windows has a Microsoft Surface Pro. She has to reboot it every few days because it won't detect the Wifi card anymore. Microsoft can't even make their own OS stable on their own hardware. Windows might have been good at all of this at one point, but that's not the case anymore. It's become terrible at all of it. So bad that Linux slowly creeped its way into my family, and that made my life much easier.
- NiveaGeForce 9y agoWindows is better and more efficient than it ever was, thanks to many improvements since Windows 8. https://np.reddit.com/r/Windows10/comments/74xc2z/windows_and_efficiency/ https://np.reddit.com/r/Windows10/comments/74xc2z/windows_an... Most default Windows apps are UWP with Fluent Design now, and more are migrating towards that since they have major advantages that you won't find on Mac and most Linux distros https://np.reddit.com/r/Windows10/comments/75lgti/announcing_uwp_support_for_net_standard_20/do7ifkr/ https://np.reddit.com/r/Windows10/comments/75lgti/announcing... Also, your other points mostly contain misinformation.
- NiveaGeForce 9y agoNonsense, any of such APIs are abstracted away in most game engines, and cover only a tiny fraction of a game engine codebase.
- shmerl 9y agoYou sound like engine developers just produce those abstractions out of thin air and they work perfectly out of the box. They need to work on them and waste their time on duplicating efforts. Bugs that plague Unreal Engine for instance demonstrate how far from trivial this is.
- narrowtux 9y agoYet here I am and still have to fight flexbox bugs in IE 11 they were too lazy to fix for 2 years and then closed the ticket because IE 11 was legacy at that point.
- ktta 9y agoAlso Edge is the only web browser where Netflix can be streamed at 1080p and 4K. OTOH Chrome and Firefox are only at 720p. Safari is at 1080p though. (Netflix's windows app is another route) Edge also supports Apple's Live streaming tech so, again the only browser on Windows which can be used to watch Apple's Live events. Too bad that Edge won't ever be on Linux.
- pritambaral 9y ago> where Netflix can be streamed Isn't that because of Netflix's choices, rather than technical reasons?
- ktta 9y agoI'm not entirely sure. I believe it has to do with the DRM implementation. While Widewine is the DRM in Chrome and Firefox, Edge uses something different[1]. I've seen people talk about Chrome being able to handle 1080p in ChromeOS. So there seems to be more than just Netflix's choice involved here. Although I bet Microsoft being proactive helped. Definitely unclear. Also I don't see any reason why Netflix wouldn't want to support 1080p in all the major browsers. The only downside might be excess bandwidth, but with the Open Connect Appliance being a thing, I doubt it is a big factor. [1]: https://blogs.windows.com/windowsexperience/2016/07/13/get-better-quality-video-with-microsoft-edge/ https://blogs.windows.com/windowsexperience/2016/07/13/get-b...
- 482794793792894 9y agoAs far as I understand it, you need tight coupling between the browser and the OS to implement the sort of deep-reaching DRM that Netflix/Hollywood wants for 1080p. That would explain why Edge on Windows and Chrome on ChromeOS can do it. Personally, I see it as a plus that my browser/OS combo does not support this. There have to be horrid security implications that just wait to be unturned.
- shmerl 9y agoIndeed: https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2007/02/drm_in_windows_1.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2007/02/drm_in_window... Insistence on DRM ironically is causing the opposite effect - wider piracy of DRM-free versions.
- skocznymroczny 9y agoMS only implements standards when they don't get to make one. They didn't want to implement WebGL in their browsers until Safari/Chrome/Firefox had it and they risked being behind. Same thing here. "Web should just work for everyone" means "Oops, people are making Chrome-only websites, we need to catch up on web standards so we aren't left out". Meanwhile they'll boast how you need Edge to watch 4k Netflix.